@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider Earthly wine causes intoxication, illness, and headaches, whereas the wine of Paradise provides pure delight without harm or loss of intellect.
@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider Projecting the physical constraints, biology, and dualities of this world onto the Creator and the Hereafter is a false equivalency. The One who created biological limits and dualities is fully capable of creating pure, unadulterated positive states without -ve counterparts.
@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider If you taste honey or hear a beautiful melody for the first time, you experience real delight without needing prior starvation or ear torture. An infant does not need to drown to enjoy breathing fresh air.
@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider Even regarding ranks, children are raised to join the highest status of their righteous parents through divine benevolence, without diminishing anyone's reward.
@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider Giving an adult who endured decades of sacrifice higher ranks than someone who endured no struggle is perfect justice.
Free will is an instrument for accountability, not an end in itself. Godโs justice requires that no one is punished without a test and wrongdoing.
@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider If a person looks at a beautiful scene, listens to truth, or experiences love, the joy felt is immediately pleasant in and of itself, not because they were in agony a moment prior.
@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider Receiving eternal bliss without having to undergo the risk of damnation is immense grace, not deprivation.
In Paradise, there is no jealousy, resentment, or feeling of deprivation. Every inhabitant experiences total and perpetual bliss suited to them.
@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider The moral hard work of adults is not wasted; it yields immense spiritual ranks, divine praise, and specific celestial rewards that untested souls do not attain.
@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider If a ruler fully pays an employee every promised wage with bonuses (justice), and additionally gifts a beggar out of pure generosity (grace), the employee has suffered no injustice.
@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider There are wisdoms behind sufferings which one may not perceive with their finite limited knowledge. Infinite reward eclipses finite temporal experience. To grant eternal bliss in exchange for brief, finite earthly moments is maximal benevolence, not sadism.
@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider The claim that admitting deceased children into Paradise is "unjust" or "sadistic"โstems from a failure to distinguish between justice, injustice, and divine grace. Honoring the innocent is mercy and generosity; calling unearned benevolence "sadistic" is a contradiction in terms.
@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider The claim that "pleasure cannot be felt without pain" is a faulty psychological and philosophical assumption known as the fallacy of contrast.
@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider "Torture," confusion, boredom, or existential despair cannot exist in Paradise, as every negative state of mind is permanently eliminated.
@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider Reducing Paradise solely to physical intimacy is a misconception. Islamic theology teaches that Paradise encompasses all dimensions of fulfillment.
@Darjilingbro@Javedakhtarjadu@khanhaider Childhood in this world is a stage of physical weakness, dependency, and limited cognitive awareness. An infant cannot fully comprehend beauty, intellectual fulfillment, deep emotional bonds, or the grandeur of their Creator.