Sure they do. All of them. In fact, all patients on all meds complain about negative effects to pharmacists. There are no positive effects for anyone of any med. That's the Keto diet cult mentality. It's a story-line. A belief system. More importantly, what's your carotid intima media thickness number today v. last year? You've got absolutely no idea. You literally don't want to know if your ideology is working to keep you safe. It's all too common when following the likes of Ken who refuses to post any artery scans of his own before proclaiming himself to be healthy based exclusively on an ideology. It was 2 years ago when Ken posted labs and they were a train wreck then. I shudder to think how his health has deteriorated in the meantime. Here's the link to learn something about yourself. No Rx needed. Maybe it's time to swap your ideology for data. https://t.co/xM4WjeQoxJ.
Ken, this is a ridiculous statement designed to preach an ideology to enrich yourself. I take a bunch of drugs that I don't need to take but *choose* to take. You cannot fathom that type of thinking, can you? Neither can your groupies. I'll give you just one example since it's near and dear to your heart. I actively choose to pee glucose into the toilet everyday. I actively choose to love on my kidneys while doing it. It's called an SGLT2 inhibitor. Every biohacker who knows anything about anything is on one. But in your dopey world it's an evil anti-diabetes drug that people take because they don't know how to eat. Ridiculous. Literally ridiculous. No wonder you're too scared to post any artery scan online. The gig would be up if your groupies knew how clogged up your arteries were. You post nothing to show you are healthy and you brag about what you don't take? It takes a special kind of gullible to think you are healthy, Ken.
I'm 57 years old and I take zero prescription medications.
People get told that hitting your 50s means a pill organizer on the kitchen counter for blood pressure, cholesterol, blood sugar and reflux, like it's just normal aging. It's not normal aging, it's decades of eating food humans were never meant to eat.
How old are you, how many prescriptions are you on, and how many have you come off by changing to a Proper Human Diet?
What uti side effect would that be? The one you read on a label that affects practically nobody? Maybe a few women who don't drink enough water and no men? Your anti-pharma diet ideology is on display. I eat oat groats, lentils, and sweet potatoes. HDL 85 TG 45. I could kick the ass of any Keto zealot in an OGTT. Life is about assessing risk v. reward on any decision. You don't make decisions that are based on N=1 feedback. Like Ken, who refuses to post any artery scans, you're a "believer". You have never gotten a CardioRisk CIMT scan of your neck arteries to know your stroke risk. You don't want to risk having your LDL-denying fantasy meet with reality. Neither does guru Ken.
@benbob888 Oh please. You've never done a CardioRisk CIMT scan of your neck. Stop pretending otherwise. You're a "believer". A diet cult member. You know it and everyone else knows it. But hey, go ahead, prove me wrong. Post your actual scan results. Good grief!
Ken's a comedy character who refuses to post any scans showing his arteries are clear. And you're too scared to know the truth by getting your own arteries scanned. Only I don't have the patience to explain the diet cult members the risks they are taking by refusing to get scanned.
@benbob888 Such an insightful comment. Ken is laughing all the way to the bank preaching his cult ideology to guys like you. Try being a grown up. Go get your arteries scanned to actually see your risk. Ken sure as heck won't do it!
The level of nonsense spoken by Keto diet cult members is laughable. I don't give a flying hoot who a drug was developed for. Neither does any biohacker. My diet is super clean. Why the heck would anyone think that lentils and oat groats are bad for you? That you believe that they are, while blowing your LDL through the roof means nothing more than you need to keep a living healthcare directive up to date for when the stroke you could have prevented leaves you a vegetable in a wheelchair. You cannot fathom the idea of wanting to take certain drugs when there is no "need" to do so. Being a diet cult member requires you to believe in childish stories that big pharma is evil. It's a comedy routine. You've never once assessed your personal risk of a stroke by getting your neck arteries scanned with https://t.co/xM4WjeQoxJ. You'd rather die than risk having your beliefs meet reality.
Lol. You're a funny guy. You know what I know about you (other than you being a diet cult member)? You have *never* done any artery scan to check for soft plaque that could kill or maim you for life. You know it and I know it. That's because cult members don't look at their personal risk. They instead "believe" they are safe. Your guru Ken Berry refuses to post any artery scan showing that his arteries are clear. His appeal is to unintelligent people. It's ridiculous that Ken defines good health by what he doesn't take. Public figure Ken, like Mic the Vegan, needs to put up or shut up:
https://t.co/F7GfskkFab
I'm 59 years old and take a bunch of drugs I don't need to take but choose to take. It's called intelligent biohacking. I look a lot younger and healthier than you do, Ken. Your HDL/TG ratio sucks next to mine. And I eat oat groats and chick peas. Your presumption that no meds equates to good health is ridiculous. It equates to an ideology designed to make money from gullible people. Where's your artery scan results?
@shashiiyengar@KenDBerryMD Your arteries are as clogged up as Ken's. The sad thing is that you're in such denial about it that both of you refuse to get a scan from https://t.co/xp1DgiuDLV to know the truth. Please keep your will updated.
Ken isn't worried about it. To Ken, its just another chapter in a children's story book. Every chapter tells a story that helps him make the most money from gullible people.
Even IF there was some kind of detrimental effect to post meal glucose spikes then the question to be asked would be; (a) does it make sense to eat Ken's diet and blow your LDL through the roof or (b) does it make sense to only eat healthy carbs taken with acarbose?
I take acarbose with every meal. Not because I'm diagnosed with diabetes but because I'm making a biohacker bet on it doing better things as opposed to not taking it.
@tater_tot111@KenDBerryMD@deniseminger The nonsense about seed oils belongs in a children's comic book. Just post your scan results next to Ken's:
https://t.co/OrBwthoo7D
Fair point on method. Adherence wasn't randomized, so the low-adherence breakdown is observational and can't prove anything on its own. So let's stick to the randomized comparisons.
1. The randomized cancer difference wasn't significant. Cancer deaths were 31 vs 17 (pโ0.06). It came from a follow-up paper, so it wasn't a pre-specified endpoint, and cancer incidence wasn't significantly different either (15.8% vs 12.3%).
2. Total deaths, also randomized, were basically identical: 174 vs 177 (RR 0.98). If the diet caused extra cancer deaths, they were balanced out by fewer deaths elsewhere.
3. Other randomized trials didn't replicate it. Ederer pooled five cholesterol-lowering diet trials, including LA Veterans, and found no significant cancer effect (RR 1.08, 95% CI 0.71โ1.69). Leave LA Veterans out and the other four point the other way (RR 0.62).
The adherence data still matter for one reason. If the oil caused cancer, you'd expect the most cancer in the men who ate the most of it. The excess sat mostly in men who barely ate it. That doesn't prove the oil was harmless, but it's the opposite of the pattern you'd expect if it caused cancer.
So one non-significant, unreplicated signal is the weakest evidence there is that seed oils cause cancer.
Ken, look at which trials are actually in each group in Ramsden 2010.
The "mixed" group that cut heart attacks and heart deaths by 22% includes LA Veterans. That diet used corn, soybean, safflower and cottonseed oil, with 14.8% of energy from linoleic acid. It counts as "mixed" only because the soybean oil added 0.7% of energy as omega-3 (ALA). That's a seed-oil diet. So your own source shows a seed-oil diet cutting heart events.
The "n-6 specific" group is just three trials: Rose (54 men), Sydney and Minnesota. Minnesota makes up most of the 9,569 participants, and you've already agreed it's too messy to stand on. Sydney depends on a margarine whose trans fat content nobody ever measured, so we're both guessing there.
Even with those trials included, none of the figures you quote reached significance. Events were 13% higher (RR 1.13, 95% CI 0.84โ1.53). Deaths were 16% higher (RR 1.16, 95% CI 0.95โ1.42), a result Ramsden himself only says "approached" significance. Inconclusive results from three flawed trials don't add up to "probable harm."
So the most your argument supports is this: oils that are almost pure linoleic acid, with no omega-3, haven't been shown to protect the heart. That's much narrower than "seed oils deserve every bit of their bad reputation." Soybean and rapeseed oil are seed oils, and they're the kind of oil that put the omega-3 into Ramsden's "mixed" group.
Saying linoleic acid alone hasn't been proven to protect the heart is fair. But no proven benefit is not proof of harm. Cochrane's 2018 review of omega-6 trials found no difference in deaths (RR 1.00).
"Seriously taken person who makes that claim" ...that's a tough question to answer since I consider most of them baffoons and I suspect I'm not alone in that opinion. MVX is a pure longevity issue. All-cause mortality. Who lives longest? It says nothing about non-fatal events.
Malcolm Kendrick would be a name. Credible? I'm not sure. Norwitz would be a big draw. So would Feldman. Both allege to be buddies with Bill Cromwell and Norwitz has written about MVX (and Feldman has hosted him) but it's apparent to me that an intelligent host could separate Norwitz & Feldman from Cromwell to identify where the Keto gurus fall short in their thinking about all-cause mortality. Given how slippery Norwitz is, you'd have to do a lot of homework ahead of that conversation though. Starting, of course, with my own letter critiquing Norwitz's letter! Re-watching the 2024 Cromwell presentation and also rewatching your conversation with Cromwell and Feldman from a while ago. Cromwell understands that metabolic vulnerability isn't the same thing as metabolic health. The Keto gurus don't understand that. Cromwell also understands that the MVX studies never analyzed one diet v. another.
Furthermore, the MVX researchers (Jim Otvos et al) got a patent using an MVX formula that included ketone bodies and then never used that formula in the studies because they found the six markers used in all the studies to be more relevant. Not many people know that fact. If you watch the Cromwell video from 2024 at KetoCon he specifically addresses the U-shaped curve re: high LDL. Basically saying, once you adjust for metabolic vulnerability, the lower your ApoB the longer you live.
One potentially interesting combo might be Bill Cromwell and Valter Longo. It'd be high brow comversation behind a caption: "Who lives the longest and why?" There might not be the same extent of potential disagreement but a Longo might argue that low protein and plants rule the longevity day whereas a Cromwell might not care about that so much, and might argue that optimizing MMX (a sub-index of MVX) is the more potent issue regardless of diet. And he'd add the IVX piece that is missing from Longo's work. Does it matter is your IGF-1 is 250 aged 70 if your MVX is 20? Now, there's a great question!
Ken, dear, credit for conceding the 22% figure and Minnesota's problems. But look at where that leaves your argument. Your original post said seed oils "deserve every bit of their bad reputation." What's left is "these trials didn't clearly reduce total deaths." Those are very different claims. A null result is not evidence of harm.
Minnesota: agreed, the full randomized group showed no drop in deaths. But the investigators planned for at least three years of follow-up, and the average participant got about one. A trial that short can't rule out benefit, and it certainly can't show harm. It tells us very little either way.
Sydney: the rise in polyunsaturated fat among controls doesn't answer the main objection, which is what was in the margarine. Trans fat was never measured, and the authors admit this is a limitation. If the intervention may have included a known heart toxin, you can't pin the extra deaths on linoleic acid. It was also 458 men, and the all-cause difference was at the edge of significance.
LA Veterans: your own numbers make the case for me. Fatal atherosclerotic events fell from 70 to 48, a significant difference. According to the AHA's summary, the diet cut heart attack, sudden death or ischemic stroke by 34% (p=0.04), and total cardiovascular events by 31% (p=0.01). The primary endpoint fell 20% but missed significance in a trial of 846 men. Total deaths came out similar because non-atherosclerotic deaths were 85 vs 71.
On cancer: 31 vs 17 deaths, pโ0.06. But 10 of the 31 were in men with 0โ10% adherence, men who barely ate the diet. When Ederer pooled five diet trials, including this one, there was no significant cancer effect: RR 1.08 (0.71โ1.69) for cancer deaths. That's hard to blame on the oil.
The wider picture: Cochrane's 2018 review of omega-6 trials found little or no difference in all-cause deaths (RR 1.00, 10 trials, 4,506 people), and a possible reduction in heart attacks. That points to "neutral on deaths, possible heart benefit." If seed oils were as harmful as your original post said, the pooled trials would show excess deaths. They don't.
"Not a clean win" is fair. "Deserve every bit of their bad reputation" isn't something these trials support.
Separately, any chance of an artery scan from you anytime soon? You did say you'd get a scan a couple of years ago and your followers do want to see how clean your arteries are. Mine are in the description box of the video linked below, and I'm not a public figure like your good self. Wouldn't you want to show that you personally benefit from your ideology?
https://t.co/qM2ta0gCed
Ken, dear, once you read the details of both trials, neither supports your opinion that "seed oils deserve their bad reputation."
Sydney Diet Heart Study: 458 men who had already had a coronary event. The "seed oil" group got safflower oil plus a safflower margarine from the 1960s, when margarines were partially hydrogenated. The American Heart Association calls it a trans-fat-rich margarine. So the test was probably "seed oil + trans fat vs usual diet," not "seed oil vs animal fat." Trans fat is one of the clearest heart risks we know of. Blaming the harm on linoleic acid alone doesn't hold up.
Minnesota Coronary Experiment: run in mental hospitals and a nursing home during mass discharges. About 75% of patients left in the first year, and the average time on the diet was about one year. That's far too short to change atherosclerosis. The diet was also extreme: imitation meat, milk and cheese made with corn oil, giving about 13% of calories from linoleic acid. No guideline recommends that.
The "22% higher risk per 30-point drop" isn't a randomized result either. It's a correlation inside the trial, and illness and frailty lower cholesterol on their own (reverse causation). The extra deaths were also limited to people over 65.
Now look at all the evidence, not two flawed 1960s trials:
โข Cochrane 2020 (15 RCTs, about 56,000 people): cutting saturated fat for 2+ years cut cardiovascular events by 17%. Swapping in polyunsaturated fat was a "useful strategy."
https://t.co/uO4yBjo92H
โข A pooled analysis of 30 cohorts (68,659 people) measured linoleic acid in blood and tissue, not food diaries. Higher levels went with 22% lower cardiovascular death.
https://t.co/lArYrVhv9B
You're right that LDL isn't the whole story. But the wider evidence points away from seed oils being harmful, not towards it.
Lowering LDL isn't the same thing as keeping people alive.
When NIH researchers recovered the missing data from the Sydney Diet Heart Study, the men told to replace animal fat with safflower oil, a seed oil, died at a higher rate: 17.6% vs 11.8%.
In the Minnesota Coronary Experiment, corn oil lowered cholesterol about 14% and saved no lives. Every 30-point drop in cholesterol went with a 22% higher risk of death.
Both were randomized, controlled trials in Humans.
Seed oils deserve every bit of their bad reputation.
Sydney Diet Heart Study:
https://t.co/ksSAuaBrMA
Minnesota Coronary Experiment:
https://t.co/qXbkNEpoiS
Most Dangerous Cooking Oils (Avoid These)
https://t.co/lUStGQ0Dfo
@theproof v. anyone prominent who wants to argue that high LDL associates with improved all-cause mortality. What actually are the strongest longevity associations? Is it V02 max? High LDL? Low ApoB? High HDL? Or this other thing that not many people understand? Longevity debate.