@jbhearn I didn't so I looked it up and yes there are examples. I was just going off theory from what you said tbh. I thought I'd post this instead though. I guess most govts don't want to remove money becuase it makes the economy look weak even though your money gets more valuable.
@jbhearn I wasnt referring to MMT, just your own words. This was based on what you said about a shortfall in borrowing to cover govt spending resulting in an increase in money supply as the central bamk covers it. The extrapolation was that tax without spending could reverse this.
@brokk07@scottsantens@kimmonismus Won't somebody please think about the money. Forget the money and start to think about how we're all going to survive when 90% of the current jobs are taken by AI. Don't wait to long to think about it...
@tonywestonuk Deficits only really create money if they're not covered by borrowing. The fiscal rules is deficits need to be borrowed for. Otherwise its just govts borrowing from people via bond issuance. Just moving the same money around.
@jbhearn So the money can expand if govt spends more than they borrow, and can retract if they burn some excess tax returns later. Granted they'd need a tax surplus (a different issue haha) but this can happen.
@jbhearn Its not like you have to find the exact bank notes to return?! You have a number on the ledger at central bank, the govt sends that amount in tax receipts.
@jbhearn Isnt that what they mean when the govt says budget black hole? They've spent more than They've taken in tax or borrowed as bonds yet? Its a deficit sitting with the central bank they need to clear by borrowing or taking more tax...
@jbhearn But tax goes to govt and used for spending right? Thats what you said? Govt overspends without borrowing adds to the money supply. Tax without govt spending can decrease the money supply right? Bit like a bank loan creates money and when I pay it back its destroyed?
@jbhearn You literally said thats possible? Obvs if you can't pay it back it increases so doesn't get removed again I get that. But you could pay it back later out of taxes. It's not impossible and clear the excess money. Or am I missing something?
@jbhearn How can tax not affect money in circulation? Tax goes to govt, govt pays the £1b on the bank books right? I dont see the diff between paying all £10b in spending from taxes now and having £9b in taxes, having a £1b deficit at the bank like you said,and pay the other £1b later?
@muserL12@officialMrsRose@refnationUK Absolutely! I totally agree. And thats thr nuance thats missed quite often these days with the left right politically tribalism.
@officialMrsRose@muserL12@refnationUK No I'm saying that even 'right leaning people/govts' can have 'left leaning' perspectives or policies on certain issues. Defining a person as simply left or right is not very accurate. And even Conservatives themselves dont just fit into one ideology.
@muserL12@officialMrsRose@refnationUK The question is if you think the government or it be left to individuals to act on that compassion. Should disabled people receive government support or rely on charity is a very blatant example. Govt support for the disabled is a left leaning approach that most would support
@officialMrsRose@refnationUK This the problem with the right-centre-left thing is that people can vary by certain issues. The other problem is people thinking they need to take the same right-left position on every issue and ignore nuance. I also don't think what is right or left is all that clear these days
@axaxaxasfml@EnarialP@SpiriTGhouled I disagree it is rare from my experience. Most dont. I think maybe once in my last 20-30 visits to restaurants have added this. Pubs don't even expect a tip and I rarely tip if I have a sit down meal in a pub. It's just not expected.
@EnarialP@axaxaxasfml@SpiriTGhouled Occasionally places will add a service charge which means you definitely don't need to tip. I think in some places it can be removed. But this is pretty rare.