Abdul Samad

Theology, comparative religion, Islam in a contemporary context and Research #orthodoxy

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@khalid_nawaz1 @StudentOfAhmad @A_SJamal I'm taking due care to consider your points and will research further. No one says you have to respond to any of these threads.. 😂

https://t.co/ouHz96wgOo

https://t.co/VnPqQp6YaM

https://t.co/7Vee25VVkw

https://t.co/uSpcOm1JQM

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

#Ahmadiyya on the 73 sects https://t.co/YK31jVuyOx - The Author Abū Manṣūr ʿAbd al-Qāhir ibn Ṭāhir bin Muḥammad bin ʿAbd Allāh al-Tamīmī al-Shāfiʿī al-Baghdādī was a Shafi'i scholar of the Ashari creed, who believed that any claim to Prophethood after Muhammad is disbelief.

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@TheMindful @CollinRugg You are almost right, but confusing similarly named heterodox groups.

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@yossarian_lives @RmSalih You are tolkien nonsense

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@salamihawk @HolyoakeJ14576 @kennardmatt UN findings of war crimes in Gaza mean the UK can’t plead ignorance, if RAF intel materially contributes to IDF strikes with knowledge it would aid unlawful attacks, ministers risk complicity under ICC Art. 25(3)(d)/ customary aiding & abetting

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@KhadijaKhan__ @GBNEWS Imagine creating an identity based on the religion you claim to have left, whilst not comprehending that you were rejecting a heterodox offshoot that believes all Muslims are apostates, and then trying to speak as an authority on the subject on GB News.

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@KhadijaKhan__ Imagine creating an identity based on the religion you claim to have left, whilst not comprehending that you were rejecting a heterodox offshoot that believes all Muslims are apostates, and then trying to speak as an authority on the subject.

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@Amiran_Zizovi If you seek obscure illiterate positions it is possible to find them and quote them. It doesn't make it accurate or representative though.

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@KhadijaKhan__ Didn't see you jump on this response from an Ahmadiyya leader?

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@KhadijaKhan__ It's strange that an 'ex-Muslim' would be so outspoken about supporting the right of the Ahmadiyya to identify as Muslim.

Just out of interest were you from an 'Ahmadiyya' background?

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@jan_hupkens @politicsisfraud @EbnHussein1424 @Ahmadiyyafacts @KashifMD Pakistan has two Nobel prize recipients.

As for Abdus Salam his co-recipients were an Atheist and a Jew. So a victory for Ahmadiyya is also a victory for Judaism and Atheism?

Salam kept a bottle of Scotch in his drawer, also a victory for Ahmadiyya?

https://t.co/biOVNblcb4

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@jan_hupkens @EUPakistan @OlofBSkoog So by analogy you are saying what they add to the shahada by their actions negates their shahada?

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@jan_hupkens @EbnHussein1424 @Ahmadiyyafacts @KashifMD The Shahada affirms Muhammad SAW as the Messenger, and the Quran 33:40 makes clear he is the final prophet. This has been the unanimous understanding of the ummah. Denying that finality isn't a difference of opinion it is a departure from Islam itself

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@jan_hupkens @EbnHussein1424 @Ahmadiyyafacts @KashifMD If a person recites the shahada but adds disbelief to it they negate the testimony with disbelief. An early example were the Jews of Isfahan who accepted everything of Islam but said Muhammad SAW was sent only to the Arabs. They weren't considered Muslim.

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@khurramshah74 Allah guides and misguides.

In order to claim asylum a minority of people will falsely claim to have abandoned their faith and identity as homosexual, persecuted, atheist or Ahmadi.

Ahmadiyya has a low benchmark for Arabs.

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@KhalilAndani @MMetaphysician @SamShamoun @SamShamounClips "Winning a debate without real expertise is like declaring yourself the champion of an empty arena".

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@KhalilAndani If it over exaggerates the importance of obscure positions, it is unlikely to maintain a neutral academic path.

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@DMdSaifurRahman @MrAdnanRashid @khurramshah74 If you need an example the Jews of Ispahan recited the shahadah and accepted everything of Islam, but said that Muhammad SAW was sent only to the Arabs.

They were not considered believers.

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@DMdSaifurRahman @MrAdnanRashid @khurramshah74 Let me help. A believer recites the shahadah accepts the obligatory beliefs of Islam and does not negate it by adding disbelief to it.

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@khurramshah74 @MrAdnanRashid Khurram bhai, it's enough that the person you are referring to is your own relative and actual brother that the accusation returns to you.

[Abdul Samad @Studentofmirza]

@ImamNoonan I was just looking through this conversation and noticed you quoting a Jamaat-e-Islami linked text for evidence.

So essentially you are accepting the translation and interpretation. That's an interesting juxtaposition.