Matthew Ó Súileabháin

*shrug*

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

@SimplySubstance The H3 podcast team and fans

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

Thats always very noticeable so please point taht out with screenshots?

There's a difference between people praising the same things and working from a drafted copy, which happens in other circles.

But i really dont think thats the case here? I have seen the film, its easily an 8 or 9 out of 10, its one of LISA'S best.

There doesn't have to be something big conspriacy. Surely the negative reviews are indication that it doesn't work for some, but theyre a minority?

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

Okay, I'm gonna remove any snark and reply to you in the interest of calm discussion:

You're coming at this advert with a lot of your own experiences. Your view of it potentially being harmful in terms of POC people interacting with white relatives is absolutely a valid point. I think that was clumsy on their part.

My argument was against Grahams blatantly racist point asking how could white white grandparents POSSIBLY have grandkids of other races. As if adoption or mixed race families didn't exist.

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

@WellerVision @big_simp So, wait, good reviews of the film are apparently paid shills, but bad ones are honest?

Surely that just means both of you want the film to be bad instead of actually waiting to see it and forming your own opinions?

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

@Glay_Golden @Glinner Its about people with grandchildren, who can obviously be adopted, are you dense?

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

@Glay_Golden @Glinner Adoption and biracial people exist you fucking morons

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

@bluefocus1974 @prodbyqd @jk_rowling I've given you my reply to this question, you not agreeing & refusing to accept the evidence is not my problem. Bye bye!

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

@frizdriedmelone @RubyBoblet @MaeveHalligan Becuase the original argument DOESNT MAKE ANY SENSE

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

Okay, lets engage with you:

If a male wants to breastfeed it would be due to them either

A) Being a trans man (assigned female at birth) who has given birth to said baby

Or

B) a trans woman (which you are transphobically referring to as a male) also wanting to help feed a baby as a parent

You seem to keeping referring to some sort of sinister component, which shows an issue/perversion with you and nobody else tbh

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

You dont go into any detail about WHY the story felt risk free or hollow, you just keep saying it was - how?

The scene with her soaring on the bird (and how it ends!), the backstory with her parents, her clashing with teh queen... like theres so much depth and so many great character moments.

Would love for you to elaborate why any of those or others felt "hollow" to you?

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

@butchstudies @Ladykorg @jk_rowling So are you just disagreeing with vast swathes of science and proof?

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

@frizdriedmelone @RubyBoblet @MaeveHalligan Women obviously were and by many regards still are?

As are queer people and trans people?

What answer were you expecting here?

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

@bluefocus1974 @prodbyqd @jk_rowling This is your exact reason, can you not read these screenshots? What are you not getting?

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

You're entitled to not like the film, but your review reads very odd, as if you only hafl watched the film? You keep saying things like "oh they clearly only want you to see how pretty the puppets are" as if they have personally offended you? Very odd

Also, you dont go into any detail about WHY the story felt risk free or hollow, you just keep saying it was - how?

The scene with her soaring on the bird (and how it ends!), the backstory with her parents, her clashing with teh queen... like theres so much depth and so many great character moments.

Would love for you to elaborate why any of those or others felt "hollow" to you?

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

@butchstudies @jk_rowling >

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

A) Consider me educated

B) This actually supports the idea that involving trans parents is a good thing!

Trans men who have given birth can lactate, and apparently trans women (using the same process as adoptive or non gestational mothers) can too

Surely if you dismiss trans women from that you're dismissing adoptive/non-gestational too?

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

@RubyBoblet @MaeveHalligan Absolutely not addressing my point in any way?

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

@bluefocus1974 @prodbyqd @jk_rowling Why are your phrasing the idea of someone trying to genuinely breast feed their baby as that? By your logic all breastfeeding mothers "want a child to suck on their nipples" - are you psychotic?

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

@fatima_gunning This is a pretty clear and factual point relating to the topic. What aren't you getting?

[Matthew Ó Súileabháin @SureLook1963]

@nottodaykunts @jk_rowling