Syed313

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@sam3i_rehman @Shiahadithdaily You deleted your comment when I refuted you instead of acknowledging it. Indeed lying on Allah won’t save you.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@sam3i_rehman @Helter1979 Yes. It has multiple chains. Al-Hakim graded it Sahih (al-Dhahabi agreed),
and al-Albani authenticated another route. Even if you reject one chain, the report is narrated through multiple companions (Ali, Aisha, Ibn Abbas) in Musnad Ahmad, al-Tabarani, Abu Ya’la and al-Bazzar.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@sam3i_rehman @Helter1979 Just one of many narration.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@shiaLibPhil @lucus090909 Cursing Yazeed and mourning the Ahlulbayt is one of my most important aspects of the religion. Thank you for letting me know you’re “more” of a Tweleverist Shia than me, my stance has changed completely.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@Born_Stellar101 @Oxeofresistance No one said Imam Hussain was a greater martyr than Prophet (saw). The greatest sacrifice of Prophet (saw) was the sacrifice of his grandson that he loved so much. We mourn for Imam Hussain is because the Prophet mourned for him. Instead you celebrate on his death anniversary.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@Mohamed_Ali474u @furkan51214 @Oxeofresistance Open your eyes and read the verse you sent. “Of the Muhajirun/Ansar” means OF them, not ALL of them. Secondly it says “AND those who followed exactly” meaning that’s also a requirement. So no that verse proves nothing and does not “destroy your whole religion”. Try again.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@OmarSafwan14 Islam is seen as an extremist religion because of you wahabis and salafis who blow themselves up and slit the throats of non Muslims on live tv. Now that you people have already made a joke of Islam, the spotlights on everything any Muslim does including us.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@ibn_naasr @zozokssm @AgentOfAnarchie @classigantexz @dervisj51 I challenged your premise and instead of defending it, you just rephrased it as a question. First prove that an Imam ceases to be Imam if he isn’t publicly leading the masses. Until you establish that, your entire argument is just an assumption.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@shiaLibPhil @lucus090909 You want us to start talking highly of Yazeed and Muawiya or what? You want us to forget about the sacrifice of the Ahlulbayt? What a stupid comment.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@ibn_naasr @zozokssm @AgentOfAnarchie @classigantexz @dervisj51 Shias don’t believe in the Mahdi because he disappeared, we believe he disappeared because we believe the evidence establishes his existence. Refute the evidence, not a caricature of the belief.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@Corps_ops @mujahidayn No. Hajj and Arbaeen are two different things. We perform Hajj the same way you do, and it’s mandatory to atleast perform once in your lifetime. Arbaeen is the walk from Najaf to Karbala which is performed by millions of Shias. It is not mandatory but is highly recommended.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@Oxeofresistance @Hassan_alQadri “Rejected Tusi and Kulayni” The funny part is your screenshot doesn’t even show Tusi or Kulayni grading the hadith. It cites Majlisi. At least read your own evidence before trying to educate others. Also Majlisi grading is not marjah ruling you dumbass.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@Oxeofresistance @Hassan_alQadri The narration is understood as relying on a person’s outward claim, not as permission to marry someone you know is married. If your interpretation were correct, show me a single major Shia marja who permits mut’ah with married women.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@Oxeofresistance @Hassan_alQadri You’re assuming the narration means it’s permissible to knowingly do mut’ah with a married woman. That’s not how Twelver scholars understood it. The ruling in Shia fiqh is clear: mut’ah with a married woman is haram and invalid.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@Oxeofresistance @Hassan_alQadri As for the Mu’tah video. The reason you choose to not send the reference is because you don’t have it. Because the lying scholar of yours didn’t wanna give the exact reference because if he did, you would read it get the context and interpretation of the Hadith.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@Oxeofresistance @Ahmed_Qaraxy @classigantexz This man is still running from me btw. Made false claims against Shias, I asked for exact reference and then disappeared.

[Syed313 @SyedZ110313]

@Ahmed_Qaraxy @OmarSafwan14 @classigantexz Also, making takfir and declaring someone’s blood halal over a historical disagreement is a far more serious claim than anything I said.