I’ve spent years trying to become consistently profitable at trading.
The biggest lesson? It wasn’t about finding the perfect strategy. It was learning to consistently trade the one I already had.
I’m writing about the whole crazy journey.
Trading SOS: From Clueless to Consistent
For years I thought bigger winners were the answer.
Then my own data showed me that a high enough win rate with modest winners could work perfectly well.
Trade the trader you are, not the trader you think sounds impressive.
Unfortunately there will be no evidence that you really tried your best if you don't make it. The sleepless nights. The losses. The doubts. All will mean nothing if you don't win. That's why you have to make it. Success is your only option bro
The journey of learning to trade is certainly a tough one, but I think it's so important to find joy in the process and celebrate the small successes along the way, even when they're not reflected in your P&L.
Because if you're solely focused on the financial reward at the end, it can be an incredibly long, lonely and depressing journey.
Sometimes the biggest achievements have nothing to do with making money, but everything to do with becoming a better trader.
Definitely. And I completely understand that during the learning phase, you need to put in a lot of hours.
But as you mature as a trader and realise that less is often more, I think reducing your screen time becomes really important.
After all, one of the reasons we get into trading is for the freedom it can offer. So surely we should make time to enjoy that freedom we've worked so hard for!
@_Littlebull Thanks very much. I learned that 10 - 20% drops on the S&P are normal for Q4 in mid-term years, so hoping to get some nice specials for long-term holds. What I don't want to do is try and be too greedy though, as I've not been very successful at trying to time bottoms!
I didn’t know how long learning to trade would take.
I just never thought it was a question of if.
That belief didn’t make the journey easy. It made me willing to keep going.
The biggest mistake I made last week was not waiting for confirmation that a key level was holding before entering a trade.
And that comes down to one of the biggest challenges traders face: impatience.
I'm getting much better at this, but I'm certainly not perfect!
Battling FOMO and impatience is something I continually have to work on, even after five years of learning to trade.
This is something that took me a very long time to figure out. But once I got better at cutting my losses quickly and aggressively, it made a massive difference to my P&L.
I completely understand why learner traders struggle with it, because it goes against human psychology. We're naturally wired to avoid pain.
But in trading, you have to learn to accept a little pain early to avoid a whole lot more pain further down the line.
And once you start mastering that, things can really begin to change. They certainly did for me.
I actually made a video about this yesterday, talking about how my unhealthy levels of screen time used to negatively affect my trading.
When you stare at charts for too long, you start seeing things that aren't there. You see what you want to see rather than what's actually happening.
And psychologically, after spending all day watching the markets, you almost start feeling like the market owes you something in return for all that time you've invested!
That can lead to forcing trades and making stupid decisions just to feel like you've achieved something.
That's why I introduced strict trading windows: two hours from the London open and two hours from the New York open.
Outside those times, I switch off my screens. It's been one of the best changes I've made, both for my trading discipline and my work-life balance.
And what you've highlighted there is exactly why I believe traders can learn a strategy in days or weeks, yet take years to become profitable, as I did. Or perhaps never become profitable at all.
Because learning a strategy is relatively straightforward. But mastering yourself, your emotions and your behaviour is, in my humble opinion, by far the hardest part of trading.
It's a really good point, Dan, and something I'm planning to make a video about soon.
One thing I've realised is that when we break our trading rules, it's often because our brain tells us, "I'll get away with it just this once."
And the problem is that sometimes we do! That's the wicked learning environment of trading. Because of the randomness of outcomes, bad decisions can occasionally be rewarded.
But I bet if you tracked every time you broke your rules, you'd find that a lot of those decisions came from thinking you could get away with it just once.
And when you look at the net result over a large sample of trades, I suspect you'd find those little exceptions have cost you dearly.
Ha, I know exactly what you're saying, and it's something I write about in my book.
Learning to trade is a very long journey (well it was for me anyway!), and if you're solely focused on the financial reward at the end, it can be an incredibly lonely, boring and frustrating experience.
That's why I've learned to find joy in the process itself and celebrate the small achievements along the way.
Because if you can't enjoy the journey, it's an awfully long time to wait for the reward!
That's really interesting, Andrew. Could you expand on that? I'd be interested to understand your reasoning.
I had an experience that might be useful to share here. It took me years to get my first prop firm payout, and I deliberately took just $250 so I could frame the certificate and celebrate a small milestone!
But stupidly, I hadn't read the small print. After my first payout, the firm moved my maximum loss limit up to my starting balance, leaving me with virtually no buffer. I subsequently blew the account very quickly.
So I can see what you're saying, but I think you have to be really careful about the individual prop firm's payout and drawdown rules.