This scene has multiple layers. It's a masterclass in writing because you need to unpack a lot that both Cihan and Alya have gone through and what they still want.
Let's start with Alya. She tells Cihan 'I told you if were together I'd be your ruin, and I became that. Walking into a second disaster knowingly is not something that either you or I could bear.'
This is her admission of guilt. Alya never says she wasn't wrong to leave. She knows she made a mistake by leaving Cihan that day, but her memory contains her return as well.
And on that day, before asking her to leave, Cihan tells her if you had talked to me, none of this would have happened.
So, in other words, despite being a victim of what happened that day, Alya seems to have taken it to heart that everything that followed was her fault.
Cihan hurting, him changing into a cold stranger, him hurting her by acting out is somehow all her fault. And that's incredibly sad because it's not true.
Had Alya turned up on the meydan that day, Feyyaz would have still attacked. Cihan knew that man escaped, he was warned. Boran would have still attacked too. Cihan knows that as well.
Notice Cihan's expression undergoes a small change when Alya says 'Oldum' because he's shocked. He realizes in that moment that she's been internalizing that guilt, she's blaming herself for sins that were never hers ro bear.
Next, Alya says 'That poor girl left here crying today and she will continue crying as long as I stay here.'
To which Cihan says 'That doesn't concern you.' Now, we know only a few scenes ago Cihan chews out Berfin for daring to think she could change his room without telling him.
Or so he says. Like Nare says, he isnt in that room anyway, so what does it matter if Berfin places a bunch of stuff there?
It matters because notwithstanding what Cihan says, him and that room are awaiting Alya's return. And he wont allow anyone to enter that room except her.
And both Cihan and Alya know it. Which is why Alya asks 'ilgisi yok?' with that 'oh really' kind of expression on her face.
That's when Cihan tries to flip the table on her and asks 'If it had something to do with you, would you stay?'
In other words, he's asking if you knew I won't let anyone enter that room except you would you stay? Or that if you knew this ring and all it entails are something I intend to get out of as soon as possible, would you stay?
So why doesn't Alya take this chance and say yes? Because remember she thinks she was Cihan's ruin already and on top of that she knows what he'll face when he breaks that engagement for her.
Which is why she's silent for a long time and then with teary eyes, she looks into Cihan's face and lies. She says she wouldn't stay.
Ans while Cihan says 'then it has nothing to do with you' to keep up his facade and hide what he's really thinking, he picks up on something in that moment.
A instinct that tells him Alya is lying, like she lied about getting married, which is why, that very night, he puts that disk in Alya's bag, leaving both their futures in her hands.
Because something in Alya's eyes tells him she wants to stay, but she can't say it. And he is finally beginning to see that.
And perhaps this is the turning point - Cihan finally recognises that Alya's refusal doesn't mean she doesn't want him; it means she too is burdened by guilt and fear to admit that she does.
So for once, Cihan chooses to trust what he sees in Alya's eyes over what she tells him.
He understands that her words are denying what her heart wants, and instead of forcing an answer out of her, he gives her the freedom to make the choice she can't bring herself to voice.
#CihAl #UzakŞehir
Cihan let Alya go but she told him she will stay by his side, our room is back AND the green sofa too, they hugged and are getting back together not because of the baby but because they love each other life is good again
The best part about Cihan fighting is Alya trying to stop him and him ALWAYS obeying IMMEDIATELY eventhough he has 10x her strength and could keep going but he CHOOSES to obey her