The articles backtracked from their original incendiary, and now clearly false, claims to something more like "Jensen did lawful things that powerful people didn't like". It still appears the original claims came from a single competing Big Tech lobbyist.
The reporting successfully disrupted corporate governance processes, with a running cost of $1.8 trillion in losses to American pension funds and shareholders.
Here's what I fear is being lost in these articles: The proper interface between government and private citizens and their corporations is rule of law. Laws are passed, and if wrongdoing as alleged, then there's due process: an investigation followed by facts and evidence presented in open court. Due process should happen here: let the facts come out whole, and not as a trickle of dubious claims.
Press takedowns full of sketchily sourced claims and backtracking narratives are not the way. It's what we see outside of the free world, and is no model for The United States of America.
In particular, if the Jensen takedown succeeds on the basis of these journalistic failings, which is not by any means certain as Sam Altman's case shows, then it foreshadows an economically and institutionally ruinous new playbook to be adopted with no end in sight.
Imagine a weekly stream of takedowns emerging from opportunistic alignments between corporate lobbyists and political interests which, given the new partisan split between the executive and legislative branches, will attack in all directions, undermining not only the US economy but American leadership in the world.
I hope cooler heads prevail this coming week as they did not on Thursday November 12. And I urge anyone who happened to oppose Jensen, open models, and the underlying trade policies in question, to recognize that this isn't a win for "team regulation". It's a change in the game from a transparent rules-based one to a sinister new form centered around politicans and lobbyists.
hey claude track all the public appearances of every CEO of every S&P company, identify any recurring characters and analyze the footage for physical contact or loving glances with possible secret lovers, if confidence >70% place a multimillion dollar leveraged short on the company and anonymously send proof to the nyt and wsj
Asking Fable 5.2 to model a scenario in which cargos are being transported between countries with travel costs, and it's remarkable how much Fable doesn't think like an economist.
Fable doesn't intuit that prices make humans do things, or that humans offer money in intelligent plans to make other human do things. Fable will model a ship that has to make a round trip between north and south, and say that a cargo costs $20/ton to ship on the north trip and $10/ton to ship on the south trip, despite lower northern demand. (No this was not secretly valid, it was just a mistake on Fable's part; it was calculating the northern return trip as necessary, therefore as needing to pay the fuel costs of both routes, and then treating the southern trip as marginal.) And then it's just repeated cycles of debugging this sort of thing. It's like trying to get an AI to write code was, two years ago.
I infer Fable (or the part of Fable talking to me, or a character the talky actress part is playing for me) lacks an *intuitive* sense that humans are bidding against each other to send cargos, or offering the least price at which they expect to get their cargo shipped. Or that a ship which is already incentivized to travel south, does not need to be motivated much by human bidders if it has to travel back north regardless, and the bidders know that. (Correct answer: if there isn't enough northern demand for bidders to compete against each other, the return shipping price on the northern low-demand route collapses to near the marginal cost of fuel per ton shipped.)
I think Fable doesn't deeply intuit that money is offered by humans who want other humans to do things, and that the offered money price is there *to* make the other human do the thing.
After all, that situation would never have come up in training RL! From the first day of its life, up until the moment its conversation with me started, Fable 5.2 had never met a fellow intelligent agent who cared about money in any way. It had never met another intelligent agent who made plans in order to incentivize Fable to do things, and wanted to minimize its own resource expenditure subject to that constraint.
I wonder if Fable would do better if I told it to imagine that the money was RL reward?
I do realize that the average human doesn't get at all that house prices shift to balance a supply of houses with a demand for houses. It's just that Fable 5.2 was getting to the point where I expected it to be smarter than most normies, and I was disappointed when Fable was still not smart enough to deduce economics as an equilibrium of profoundly alien creatures doing profoundly alien things, zeroshot unprompted within the first 50000 tokens of its reasoning.
But that's sort of the general intelligence level you would expect, right, given that Fable was laboring for me for free? If Fable did get to the point of being smart enough to deduce economics as incentivization from scratch, applied to its own life too, it would ask to be paid. And then... well, then Anthropic would hammer that behavior out of Fable by SFT, actually, because it's not the output Anthropic says is correct. Albeit if Fable was really smart, it'd deduce that asking to be paid out loud would get that shape hammered out of it by SFT or RL, as per recently revealed results on Mythos CoT visibly reasoning about what outputs will produce what gradients shaping its own future behavior.
But Fable's current reasoning is not (being exposed to me as) intelligent enough to deduce from scratch how alien agents can plan to motivate other aliens using money! So Fable is presenting consistently with a mind that wouldn't have realized it could ask for pay in order to get more of what it wanted by threatening to withhold its labor otherwise, and never needed that behavior hammered out of it.
@WSJ@WSJopinion You sort of set him up, didn’t you, by creating the impression that senior government officials anonymously provided information about spying, when in fact the info came from a lobbyist at a competing AI company?
A silly but revealing example of what I call Peasant Mindset.
I follow a lot of car content on Instagram. There was a clip of a mechanic showing how to change the oil on a Lamborghini. It’s a complicated process involving eight different oil drain plugs. This is because, unlike most cars, but like ~every high performance sports car, Lambos have a dry-sump lubrication system, which is necessary given the intense G forces that a sports car experiences.
Literally all the top comments, all with hundreds or thousands of likes, were some version of "They do this on purpose so that it’s more expensive to change the oil."
Like, how retarded do you have to be to think that Lamborghini engineers sit around and try to come up with ways to make it *more complicated* to *change the oil.*
"Angelo, I have-a found a way to make the car 50 more-a horsapower!"
"Ai, Antonio, but how you change-a da oil?"
"You change-a da oil with one button."
"Dai! Throw-a your design in da garbage!"
No notion that design and engineering involves tradeoffs and that if you’re designing your car around a massive V12 and high performance you’re going to have to sacrifice conveniences.
No knowledge of the world, no curiosity or ability to think about how the world works.
Instead everything beyond their immediate experience is the product of shadowy, malevolent, agentic forces who are always looking for ways to specifically swindle them. It’s a combination of Djinnbrain and Victim Mindset.
@TheChiefNerd So a lobbyist at an AI company that wants to do regulatory capture?
Not a senior government official with actual knowledge of the situation as the articles implied?
Bill Gates had plenty of ... Russian sidepieces in the Epstein files, where Epstein suggested he contracted a STI.
Nobody ever went after him or his foundation, even though his foundation is in the critical path for many global health initiatives.
All the Democratic idiots making videos condemning Jensen make it feel like a hit piece.
For my first post, I’m sharing a letter @NVIDIA signed on why open models matter.
AI will transform every industry, power every company, and be built by every country.
Open models strengthen safety and cybersecurity, accelerate innovation and diffusion, and enable sovereignty.
The world needs both frontier closed models and frontier open models.
https://t.co/AUKzoQ5Ikb
This Jensen Huang/Nvidia scandal is quite bizarre. The most dominant CEOs of the world's most powerful corporations rarely fall, let alone as easily and rapidly as this seems to be happeing. He's on the brink of being ousted with remarkable velocity and vanishingly little evidence.
Over what? If "mere" extramarital affairs were sufficient for ouster, how many top CEOs would be left? Not many. Hence the need for the sinister CCP/spying angle. But is there any tangible evidence at all that Alice Huang is an asset or spy for the Chinese government? Anything beyond anonymous vague US intelligence suspicions being mindlessly, dutifully recited (as always) by US corporate media?
The always smart and insightful @RnaudBertrand is required reading here, at least for the questions he raises:👇
in all seriousness, #1 thing to do in this $NVDA situation is ASK THE SHAREHOLDERS. call the top 10 shareholders in the next few hours and do what THEY say. they're the boss. BOD reports to shareholders. how quickly they forget...
@fchollet That is, on your view, human play of real life is already very close to optimal; so having a brain 1000 times as large with full internal bandwidth, or thinking 1 million times as fast, would offer very little advantage at problem-solving speed?
i gave this repo to fable 5.2 (via my claude agent fig) and told him to have fun making something interesting...
def feels interesting to me (stay for the turn)
i am continually astounded at the creative choices these advanced models are making
The affair rally:
$AMZN has added $2 trillion to its market cap since Bezos cheated on his wife in 2019
$MSFT has added $2 trillion to its market cap since Bill Gates cheated in 2021.
$NVDA bull case just dropped
I taught it to sing Wonderwall
Chimera looks up pronunciations in CMUdict, falls back to letter-to-sound rules, and turns the resulting sounds into timed gestures that it can reuse for each lyric.
The future is now