TreeTree

I'm not there.

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

@FOXSports @USMNT Wondering how many tickets they need, one or two…

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

@payinblood Wow never seen this stage backdrop before. Thank you.

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

@fangshimin 方老师春节好。谢谢你一直以来坚持的书写。

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

@acufilmnews The two figures move away from each other by their body language. In the original photo the two are very close to each other.

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

@fangshimin 哪里没有热度啦。一直在关注。

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

Emotions may be cheap but feelings are not. That's why Dylan means so much to me, compared to the other musicians in the same category. His songs make me feel things differently, rather than simply "touch" me on an emotional level.

[HarryHew @harryhew]

LEONARD COHEN: "A song that is useful, that touches somebody, must be measured by that utility alone. 'Cheap music' is an uncharitable description. If it touches you, it's not cheap. From a certain point of view, all our emotions are cheap, but those are the only ones we've got."

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

Two other points Dylan made in the interview. The first one reminds me of what he had said about feelings and emotions. The second one calls for self-reflection which is the most important thing I've learned from his songs.

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

@Music__Mentor

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

Bob Dylan is a liar. But he does not deceive himself. Many people go in the opposite direction. It is very hard for those to appreciate the lies Dylan has told before they stop the self-deception.

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

@jeffslate @bobdylan @WSJ Very inspiring interview. Thank you for the good questions you asked. I also love the liner notes you wrote for Bootleg Vol. 14.

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

"It’s a path, and destiny put some of us on that path, in that position. It’s not for everybody." I love the way Dylan talks about fate and destiny. His mind is wide open and spirit free. But he is very sure of his own position and how he gets there.

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

"You’re the master of your fate. You manipulate reality and move through time and space with the proper attitude. It’s not an easy path to take, not fun and games, it’s no Disney World. It’s an open space, with concrete pillars and an iron floor, with obligations and sacrifices."

[Bob Dylan @bobdylan]

Read Bob Dylan’s new interview about The Philosophy of Modern Song, just posted by the Wall Street Journal:

https://t.co/zUht3a9up0

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

@Daan20211008 对啊，年龄有啥重要的。心态开放，勤于学习，不断自我改变就是年轻的。李老师自诩年轻，还恶心吧啦的自称小孩子啥的，还不是得跟那帮子老方黑抱团，一点儿独立人格都没有。

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

玩弄文字游戏，将自己的无能说成是方舟子的专横，将李老师的心虚说成是方舟子逼人自证，正是李老师这些人让人看不起的原因。不能作为一个独立的个体为自己的所作所为负责任，事事赖到别人头上，这不是李老师的粉丝们所标榜的“年轻”，而是狡猾孱弱，是很“中国”的毛病。30的人打“年轻”牌，恶心不恶心。

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

方舟子当然是可以被质疑的，也应当被质疑。这也是他为自己的选择所付出的代价。被方舟子拉黑这件事情指向的并不是“方舟子不可质疑”，而是你的质疑没有让他不得不回应的价值。李老师其实也不必回应方舟子的质疑，像他一开始声明的那样，但他后来忍不住一条条的回应，说明了方舟子的质疑是犀利且有力的。

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

眼下境况不陌生，是方舟子每回打假都会出现的“统一阵线”的要求。这个“统一阵线”并非志趣相投携手共进，而是集体吞噬个体，对独立人格的否定。否定了方舟子自主行为的权利，也在根本上否定了个体自主意识的存在。他们认为民主大讨论可以被草包韩寒点燃，可以被方舟子熄火，唯独不认同人们自主讨论的意愿

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

而方舟子的启蒙，除了专业范围的科普打假，精髓就是对“独立人格”这个中国人很陌生的概念的身体力行的科普。简单的站到自己所反对的立场的对面拳打脚踢，一样是被立场裹挟，很容易就变成自己所反对的人。而每个人都拥有独立的个体意识，勤于思辨，自己做选择并为之负责，任何专制存在的根基会不攻自破。

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

而方舟子的启蒙，除了专业范围的科普打假，精髓就是对“独立人格”这个中国人很陌生的概念的身体力行的科普。简单的站到自己所反对的立场的对面拳打脚踢，一样是被立场裹挟，很容易就变成自己所反对的人。而每个人都拥有独立的个体意识，勤于思辨，自己做选择并为之负责，任何专制存在的根基会不攻自破。

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

玩弄文字游戏，将自己的无能说成是方舟子的专横，将李老师的心虚说成是方舟子逼人自证，正是李老师这些人让人看不起的原因。不能作为一个独立的个体为自己的所作所为负责任，事事赖到别人头上，这不是李老师的粉丝们所标榜的“年轻”，而是狡猾孱弱，是很“中国”的毛病。30的人打“年轻”牌，恶心不恶心。

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

@usernamepazword @WeiyuanOttawa 哈哈正是。一个长年在千军万马中独自逆行的斗士说话要是客客气气有商有量的，早被吃干抹净了。

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

方舟子当然是可以被质疑的，也应当被质疑。这也是他为自己的选择所付出的代价。被方舟子拉黑这件事情指向的并不是“方舟子不可质疑”，而是你的质疑没有让他不得不回应的价值。李老师其实也不必回应方舟子的质疑，像他一开始声明的那样，但他后来忍不住一条条的回应，说明了方舟子的质疑是犀利且有力的。

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

@Daan20211008 哈哈，我都不知道他还说过这些。我只是断断续续的看他的内容。

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

沉默并非字面意义的沉默，因为思维方式一旦改变必将牵引个人其他层面深刻的改变和不可避免的对身边的人的改变，即“火把的传递”。我个人理解这也是方舟子的意义所在。他的对话对象不止是对面的对手，更是像我一样被启发的观战者。很显然他的诉求并非个人的输赢得失，但人非草木，既从他受益，怎可坐视。

[TreeTree @TreeTre39161040]

算我一个。没时间穷究细节所以不参与此事的具体讨论，只为支持方舟子说几句微不足道的话。方韩大战是里程碑意义的盛事，中文世界真正的启蒙，改变了许多网友的思维方式。许多热烈讨论就像发生在昨天一样真切。不过十年的时间就被携私报复的小人歪曲污蔑至此。我们见证过历史的人虽沉默，还没死呢。