@nimishdubey Has to be situation dependent, right? I'm not saying people should sing praises of, say, a third innings declaration ton against a tired attack. But if your team needs 500 batting first in Asia on a wicket that's doing nothing on the first couple of days, I'll certainly value it.
@nimishdubey Yeah, exactly. That's precisely what I am calling out. Because Test match runs or wickets don't come by easy even in favourable conditions. The Sachin/Gavaskar narratives are incredibly silly too.
@nimishdubey Also, people on the internet clearly have an issue if the player they dislike makes runs on flat pitches. Look at the Gill detractors in recent times, for instance.
@nimishdubey Agree that runs in tough conditions should be valued more. By ruthlessness I mean the sheer consistency to pile up runs at will when they were on offer easily, the way say Steve Smith did at his peak.
@diktelbazaar@beingictfan Thanks! I'm still working under him though haha. Just doing more Hindi stuff nowadays. Still on a couple of English shows per week.
Why do people think scoring runs on flat tracks is a bad thing? It's how most of the greatest Test batters of all time have built their careers. If anything, that ruthlessness to score when there are runs on offer also separates the greats from the rest.
@_sectumsempra18 Yeah, plus people obsessing over raw averages. Like if he retires say a year ago, is he really a better player? Because at that point, his average is like 49+ with 8.5K+ runs.
@_sectumsempra18 Yeah lol. Even as a player, how many have 9K runs or 30 hundreds in the format? Hilarious how some actually believe he was an 'average' player in this format.
@beingictfan But on the other hand, Damien Martyn was the opposite - exceptional in low-scoring games but couldn't cash in on roads like his peers did. Unfortunately, he also wouldn't be an all-time great either.
@beingictfan For instance, Khawaja was almost impossible to dismiss on flat pitches, but he struggled on tougher decks. That doesn't mean I'm saying he is an ATG. But the former means he has had a very solid career.