As school gets back in session, the new leadership of Utah PTA has been busy visiting regions across the state, getting to know you and celebrating who you are! And so, it's time to introduce ourselves. For more information, please visit https://t.co/VvORPClWec. #PTA#uted
Can the @UTBoardofEd be partisan? Utah Supreme Court justices call state’s argument ‘thin' and ‘almost nonsensical’, but acknowledge ambiguity in the law, via @sltrib#uted#utpol https://t.co/pmgN4XHvlQ
Green says that the state does not see school board staff (like the state super) to be education employees. Instead, they're employees of the state.
Justice Petersen says that reading is "nonsensical" #uted#utpol
Smith says that SB78, the partisan school board bill, infects the entire system of running for and electing board seats with "partisan tests." #uted#utpol
Justice Lee now pressing attorney Alan Smith for examples in state law where the @UTBoardofEd is defined as being part of the education system #uted#Utpol
Justice Himonas out of the gate again. Says the board of directors of an organization are typically officers, not empoyees. Why would voters consider the @UTBoardofEd to be education employees? #uted#utpol
Court has now switched to "partisan test" prohibition. The law also prohibits a "religious test" and Judge Hagen suggests the state can't require school board candidates to declare their religion. #uted#utpol
Chief Justice Durrant brings up plain language. Suggests that voters in 1986 understood the constitutional language to mean that public ed would be largely nonpartisan. #uted#utpol
Justice Petersen asks, for the second time, for state's lawyer to state clearly what his argument is about employment in public ed. Wants to understand why state believes it doesn't include school board. #uted#utpol
Himonas notes that constitution says education "includes" k-12 and higher ed. He says the state is reading the word "includes" out through its argument. #uted#Utpol
State's lawyer barely gets a sentence out before Justice Himonas cuts in and questions the state's definition of "employee" of the education system. #uted#utpol
Utah's previous election system was struck down for different reasons, so lawmakers passed a bill making the state school board partisan beginning this year.
Law was challenged & a lower court already ruled against it, so this year's elections will be nonpartisan #uted#utpol