@AndrewDarovich I think it comes down to the fact that you say this as plainly as you do: "if you cant do it without, you shouldnt be doing it with."
If that isn't gatekeeping of the most arrogant sort, what is? Who are you - who is any of us? - to stand and pronounce thusly?
I've considered it, for sure...and I note that even among ex-Origin people, many of those still working in a coding role openly admit to the use of AI tools. Richard Garriott has likewise said that he'd make use of them in any new game he might one day work on.
And I'm in the same camp as these. Granted, I don't code as much nowadays as I used to, but both in my career and in my hobbyist efforts, I make ready use of coding agents when I can...because it makes me more productive. I can build in days what might once have taken weeks, or build in weeks what might once have taken months.
Not that I couldn't code by hand what I now task an agent to do...but it would take longer. And my time is valuable to me, as assuredly as anyone's time is valuable to them.
Which, I think, is the core of why I disagree - and will continue to disagree - with you on this point, and why it's okay that you hold to a different view as well. We all make decisions about the value of every minute we have left in life, and how we want to spend these.
If you prefer to invest more of those minutes into any single task rather than automating the task so that you can put a portion of those minutes into something else, that's fine...but it's also fine if someone makes the opposite choice, because none of us places the same value on the same things to the same degree.
Look, you can call that take "not stuck up" all you want, and it's true that nobody likes to think of themselves as being in the wrong.
But it is, fundamentally, a very stuck-up attitude, and then one I disagree with. Not that you have to change your mind, of course; this is the internet after all. But in the same vein, do me the courtesy of not trying to change mine, either.
@AndrewDarovich It's always easy to be the armchair critic, I suppose. But in truth, it's both arrogant and (likely) false to say "they had time," when in plain point of fact they may not have had the time it would have taken to craft these sorts of things entirely by hand, unaided.
Does a thing have to be difficult to be worthwhile? You wouldn't be the first to make that argument, but it's not one I've ever agreed with.
And certainly a thing doesn't need to be insurmountably difficult to be worthwhile. The fact that the barrier to entry is lower shouldn't be something to lament; there's really no point to that sort of gatekeeping.
Cear Dragon's reverse-engineered "Ultima Forever" server now tracks multiple players and saves progress past the tutorial, so players can finally see each other in U4E's reimagined Britannia.
Maybe we’d have had these things…or maybe, they’d have been tried and abandoned as ideas. Coding a whole engine is objectively hard work…many might try, but few succeed.
It’s all well and good to idly fret about the robot doing the work, but the fact is: the robot a powerful tool of democratization in this area. It’s the bridge over the gulf between vision and technical talent in some cases, or it’s the capable assistant that accelerates the work of the already-talented in others.
But whether the robot is filling in for a lack of skill or a lack of time, it’s the fact that the robot is there that makes these attempts feasible now. There was no “years ago” in which we could have had these things; we’d have had them if there were.
Don’t be so quick to pour cold water on people’s passions because things have finally advanced to the point where all the ideas they had set aside for “someday” can now be realized in a fraction of the time it would otherwise have taken them.