Isaiah 9 cannot explain why a raised mark on the Prophet’s ﷺ back was identified as the Seal of Prophethood. That clearly points to a lost text or tradition, since nobody would infer such a bodily anomaly as a sign from Isaiah 9 alone.
Low IQ people can scream 'MAGICAL' 🤡 🤣.
@Farid_0v@AlmahdiWesam No. This is only the intercession Muslims believe in: intercession effective only by Allah’s free permission. Polytheistic intercession assumes leverage over the one appealed to. That is impossible with Allah.
@AlmahdiWesam I am so relieved to hear you say that. 😄
I thought I was going crazy talking to all these people telling me "the government will be on his shoulder" from Isaiah 9 is a reference to the Seal of Prophethood. 🤦♂️
@burm_ab@AlmahdiWesam@MarcellussKdr_ The Quran consistently uses the word 'Torah' to refer to the Book given to Musa(as). Since it had an "explanation of all things", it certainly spoke of the Last Day and Heaven and Hell, unlike the later, human-authored Pentateuch.
@astronomer345@AlmahdiWesam@alUkbari@IjazTheTrini Talk of a “magical Torah and Gospel” is a low IQ straw man. By then, the real Torah and Injil survived only in small Jewish and Christian subcultures dismissed as heresies by the mainstream. The isolation of Mecca and Yathrib helped preserve them.
@baciarnaut Neither I, nor you, nor anyone else, has any idea what type of text the Jews during the time of the Prophet PBUH had. That area of the world was completely isolated and filled with texts and traditions that contemporary Jews and Christians did not deem orthodox.
@Farid_0v@AlmahdiWesam The intercession claimed by polytheists was very different from the Islamic concept thereof, since it was believed by them to be effective independently of Allah's permission -- they thought Allah had to obey the intercessor.
This is a well known distinction in major tafsirs.
No one familiar with the Talmud would ever claim Eleazar is being divinized there.
And even you end up returning to the standard view: that some Jews in Yathrib divinized Uzayr.
So what is gained by introducing Eleazar at all? Better to stick with saying Uzayr = Ezra, no?
@TahirMuzza26350 @AlmahdiWesam@astronomer345 @theMuslimbaker @praise1143@Deenresponds@muslimorthodoxy Allah indicates to us that the original Torah was present in Madina, while every book we have now called 'Torah' was written after Musa(as); so the real Torah is now a lost book.
In the seventh century it existed wherever it existed; the Hijaz was one of those places. SO WHAT?
@TahirMuzza26350 @AlmahdiWesam@astronomer345 @theMuslimbaker @praise1143@Deenresponds@muslimorthodoxy Idiot, Allah tells us about the original Torah, while the Pentateuch is not it since it was obviously composed long after Musa(as).
We DON'T need to point to any document now, because 99% of ancient texts disappeared, and this is one of them.
@TahirMuzza26350 @AlmahdiWesam@astronomer345 @theMuslimbaker @praise1143@Deenresponds@muslimorthodoxy The real Injil survived only among tiny groups. The teachers of Salman al-Farsi(ra), all far from the Hijaz, belonged to a sect so small that each struggled to find him his next teacher. One of them knew the Prophet ﷺ would be in the Hijaz, which was likely part of the Injil.
@astronomer345@AlmahdiWesam@praise1143@Deenresponds@muslimorthodoxy After the destruction of the Second Temple, it seems some Jews who still possessed the real Torah migrated to Arabia, probably because the real Torah, unlike the Pentateuch, told them that the Prophet ﷺ would arise there.
Allah knows best.
Now what's the issue?
2/2
@astronomer345@AlmahdiWesam@praise1143@Deenresponds@muslimorthodoxy The original Torah was never widespread. Even before the Exile, it had been lost for ages until rediscovered in the Temple under Josiah. After the Exile, most Jews no longer had it, and from around the second century BC the Pentateuch became dominant.
1/2
The coolest thing about being an American right now is if I pay my taxes I'm not paying for better infrastructure, roads, or social services. I'm paying for some guy across the ocean to shoot a kid in the head with a sniper rifle. Oh, and I'm paying for his health care too.
The Qur’an clearly treats the Torah revealed to Musaؑ as present in Madina. The Pentateuch, however, is plainly a later collection of narratives written long after Musaؑ. So the Pentateuch is not the Torah, but a human work later presented as divine.
What's the problem?