@TalkinItYT@LGMjad@WagieCapital@blu5rose George approved that and for season one it wasnt a change that hurt the plot. But everything they’ve done to her since end of season two is terrible for sure.
@LGMjad@WagieCapital@blu5rose Yeah I hate George being out, I’d rather it be more accurate. Is what it is, but I still view season one as respecting the source material and enjoy some parts of the others, even if a lot of their changes are crap.
@WomanDefiner@Howlingmutant0 Better than original GOT off of 3 hours of total tv yeah you’re a moron. It doesn’t clear HOTD season one, but people can’t handle woman and black velaryons + will use s2/3 to discredit it. Just like the ppl already crying on the black guy in s2 of AKOT7K.
@rrainbow_77@ThronesUpdates Epi 7 this season was a real mess with pacing and the dragon fight for sure, season one should be separated from 2/3 cause George was actually involved.
@WagieCapital@blu5rose Yes all 6 30 min episodes were good, HOTD season one was on par in quality and 10 one hour epis, all the people with this take are book purists going off recency bias. I’m all for saying s2 and s3 have issues, and a lot of the changes suck, but saying it’s all trash is wrong.
@Yo_Its_Casper@PissedOffPossum@Evangelion217@buff_err@HBO Yeah Zach you were on point here all through the thread, if only they kept 10 episode seasons like S1, and George was still involved like S1. If we had both here we get the gullet to end season 2. Could have given Dareon a better build up so we see him earn his the daring title.
@NerdInWhileLoop It was one six episode season. I get it was great and faithful, but let’s not act like HOTD season one wasn’t comparable in terms of quality, and for the most part faithful to the book. George RR was fully involved at that point, once they stopped listening to him it got messy.
@Dan0985243737@NerdInWhileLoop People also want to take the 6 episode season 1 of Knight of 7 kingdoms and compare it to all of HOTD to this point, season one HOTD at least was on par in quality, and the book deviations to that point weren’t a mess like they’ve become now, especially in the last epi.
@ashxtarte@NerdInWhileLoop Definitley is part of the problem, doubling down on both the Alicent + Aemond kiss, and the Mysaria + Rhanerya in the same penultimate episode was not it.
@Nicko35Melo@NerdInWhileLoop Just needed 10 episode seasons, first two of this season should have been at end of season two, would have given more time to wrap up next season. Also could have given Daeron an episode to earn his name “the Daring” this season instead of just skipping it and having it be said.