Research in ed. hist.; Founder & 20+ yr on board of a Sudbury school; Headmaster, Sac Chesterton for 2 yrs; 20+ yr career as Dir of Cust Ed at tech firm.
1) The story: once we started having children 30+ yrs ago, I took a great interest in education - specifically, how did we get here? 'Here' being the place where there were no schools, public or private, we'd ever send our kids to.
The problem has always been and remains: who does the something, and where? You’ve seen how the prosecutors and judges for much of the country are completely corrupt, such that the administration has to carefully venue shop to get any sort of case prosecuted.
So imagine they challenge this election. The accused will do everything in their power to simply get whatever cases are being brought before judges, and prosecutors who will never convict them. I am frankly pleasantly surprised that any charges have been brought against anyone for any crime at this point.
One of my older brothers, a professed Marxist, used to hang around with Unitarians in Long Beach, California. Since I played music with him often, I found myself invited to various Unitarian events. Nice folk, they throw a good party, but yes – spiritually empty. A club in lieu of a religion.
@tanyaelisabethh@JoshuaLisec A young lady we know, back when she was in school, dared to say out loud that what she really wanted was to be married and have some kids. The female teachers within earshot descended upon her with great concern. Wrong dream!
Modern schools are not designed to teach our children anything, starting in the first half of the 19th century when they were invented. This is not a bug, it’s a feature. All the curriculum in classes stuff is just for show. What they want, what schools are designed to do, is get kids away from their parents, from their community, and especially from their church. Strong families, communities and churches interfere with the states claims on your kids lives – on your life.
The greatest success of modern schooling is that it has convinced almost everyone that it simply *is* education. Yet all our founding fathers and the millions of well educated people throughout history did not learn in an age segregated graded classroom school. Our modern schools are a tragically failed experiment.
@OVTweetmarck Look at the bright side: for virtually everyone for as long as there have been people, “all your life” equals about 35 years for almost everybody, if you were lucky enough to survive infancy and childhood.
It seems that people of good will are in the position of Ransom on Perelandra, trying to decide what to do about Weston.
We are faced with sleepless evil that cannot be reasoned with.
As part of the effort to impose centrally controlled schooling, it was necessary to paint country people, who had their own one room schools under their own control, as stupid versus city people, who were schooled in age, segregated graded classrooms.
Why would you need to hire professionals, spend four times as much, and four times as long, educating your children if one room schools didn’t produce morons? So that particular lie became mandatory.
Regulating AI: imagine if current AI had been available at the time Obama care was passed. Instead of having 1000+ incomprehensible pages to analyze – which nobody did, at least before it passed – you could have the AI summarize it for you. Imagine how different the discussion would’ve been.
Could AI be dangerous? Sure – just like any advance technology is dangerous, in the hands of amoral morons and crazies. But it’s a real threat to people trying to hide behind mountains of documents and conversations. Those are the people I want worried.
We’ve elevated voting to the marker of not just citizenship, but adulthood. In fact, in a healthy society, it should be more like taking out the garbage – a job somebody needs to do, but which in and of itself has no bearing on a person‘s worth or maturity. One’s position in the home and culture and church are far more important and indicative of your humanity – something the anti-suffragettes pointed out and got shouted down.
We live in an area – the foothills of the Sierra Nevada’s – full of hobby farms and market farms. A lot of people have a few cattle. We have four. Since it’s mostly hobby stuff, you’ll see Longhorns, Highland cattle, as well as your typical Angus and Aberdeen.
We also own a half share in an Aberdeen bull. A mature ball is an impressive animal. He will be back by in January for a couple of months to breed the girls.
This is what a St. John’s education prepares you for, right?
@lampwright4 They do add a peaceful bucolic charm.
Our neighbors have their highland cattle as pets. We however, will eventually sell or eat ours. Circle of life, and all that. we do our best to make sure they have a good life by cow standards in the meantime.
Education reform: prior to the early 19th century, education described the efforts of parents and other concerned adults to answer this question: what sort of adult should this child grow to be? As such, the idea that education should be divorced from religious and moral education would’ve been unimaginable. Education necessarily must be integrated with family, village, and Church. We want our children to grow into adults who are solid members of their family, active in their community, and devout to their God.
Starting in the early 19th century, with roots running back centuries earlier, the question became: what kind of adult does the state need this child to become?
The first goal is to render the child instantly obedient to state authority. This is achieved by enforcing arbitrary divisions and rules. That’s what compulsory age segregated classrooms are for. That people take this for granted – that school simply means age segregated compulsory graded classrooms – is the one great success of modern schooling.
But no real education can take place in such a setting. Training, yes. Indoctrination, certainly. But the family, village, and Church are forcibly excluded from modern schooling. The student is forcibly disintegrated from the very institutions that give human life meaning.
@NE_good_life K through grad school needs to be nuked from orbit, just to be sure. Our public educational institutions passed the point of no return decades ago – it’s just becoming obvious to anyone with eyes now.
@FamedCelebrity It’s almost like with guns: we’re gonna start needing to hide grandma and tell the government we lost her overboard in the tragic boating incident.
The Great Un-Karening has begun, and decades of cultural engineering have finally run into something their architects cannot fucking control: human nature.
A seven-year-old conquers El Capitan, breaking his older brother's record, and some sanctimonious busybody responds by reporting his father to Child Protective Services. Apparently, raising children capable of extraordinary achievements now qualifies as suspicious parenting.
And that tells you everything about the suffocating bullshit we've allowed to masquerade as progress.
For years, the helicopter-parenting crowd, DEI bureaucrats, ideological school administrators, and professional grievance merchants have worked to remake childhood in their own miserable image. Courage became recklessness. Masculinity became toxic. Independence became neglect. Every hurt feeling became an emergency, and every whining control freak acquired a fresh excuse to interfere.
They built entire systems around rewarding fragility, policing behavior, and teaching children to view the world through the narrow lens of identity, victimhood, and institutional permission.
And now the machinery is encountering resistance.
Kids are reportedly refusing school Pride Day activities. Parents are defending their children's right to adventure. Twenty to forty neighborhood kids organized their own nighttime pursuit game, complete with strategies, head starts, and a mile-long course. Some neighborhood hall monitor called security.
The kids kept playing.
Fucking beautiful.
There's the nightmare for the self-appointed guardians of acceptable behavior: children discovering they can organize their own lives without a diversity consultant, a school psychologist, or some miserable asshole clutching a rulebook.
And every independent decision chips away at the authority these people spent years accumulating.
The Karens can scream. The bureaucrats can threaten. The ideological busybodies can keep issuing commandments from their increasingly ridiculous little thrones.
The generation they expected to mold into obedient, perpetually offended dependents is discovering the exhilarating pleasure of telling them to piss off.
They tried to rewrite normalcy.
Now they're watching the next generation reclaim it without asking their fucking permission.
(article below)
One of our five kids, the middle son, used to wander the neighborhood, barefoot (California, not a safety or health issue) when he was still pretty little. We are talking a few block radius from our house.
Some Karen called the cops on him a couple of times. Fortunately, for us, the cops were sane.
When I would take the kids to the park, I would let them climb around on the equipment unsupervised. This meant that they occasionally got in positions other parents - moms - thought dangerous. I even had a few approach me, as if I didn’t notice what my kid was doing. My response: it’s OK, we have spares. That usually put an end to the discussion. (no, we don’t have spares. But it was a funny thing to say.)
(by the way, it’s always nice to have a civilized conversation on Twitter. Thank you.)
I am effectively the only reader in a family of nine. The best part of my K through 12 education was the willingness, way back in the 60s and 70s, for the teachers to realize I wasn’t hurting anybody by reading a book at the back of the class, that I got OK grades anyway, and so they mostly left me alone. I hear those days are long past.
A certain kind of person equates superficial chaos with ineffectiveness – that people were learning via all kinds of slapdash methods was simply unacceptable, even if those people included Washington, Jefferson, Adams, Etc.. A little school here, maybe a little tutoring there, maybe an apprenticeship – read the lives of these early people, and it’s a mishmash.
Now it’s very well organized – and people mistake organization for effectiveness.
Not denying that smartphones, etc., have damaged many, many people, especially children. But I think the schools contributed to putting people in such a position that they could be damaged by those devices.
Maybe you had that one great teacher that turned you on to reading. I didn’t. I learned to read by ignoring the teachers, after the week or two it took for me to get the basics from them. The system has no place for a kid who simply loves reading and more importantly, can learn more from reading than he can from paying attention in class.
More to the point: compare and contrast the educational level of Americans prior to 1848(the year the first modern school was established in Boston) and now. Not only were our elites far more accomplished in general, common people could read the federalist papers in the newspaper and discuss them at the local pub! Now we with 100 times more people produce a far smaller percentage of both educated elites and competent common people than they did in 1800 without the “benefit“ of modern schooling.
To claim that modern schooling works is to set the bar so low it’s practically on the ground.