@edu_andy24 It's ironic because it's so central to the love story. She discovers how empty a life in which he might hate her feels. He discovers he can't bear the thought of a life without her in it. It's the first time both fully confront internally how they feel.
@edu_andy24 I respect the choice of any artist, so long as it is genuine. And such feelings should be mutual. But for this scene in particular there is *so* much narrative potential behind it...
@HorEmperor Yes. This requires a softening of her attitude toward Ron/Hermione from basically Book 4 onward. Keeping the Malfoys alive is a harder problem--but not insurmountable. Suggest (paradoxically) leaning into Voldy's sadism. Something I am currently exploring.
@Sheepfarmer373@HorEmperor@Aloofcannon This is the toughest problem with the entire AU. If he loves her, then FF will bring him to her. If that happens before SS, then SS shouldn't happen. If it happens after, the impact of SS seems severely diminished. The artistic challenge will be making both work.