Controversial Friday: AI in writing.
In 1993, Jurassic Park mixed about nine minutes of Stan Winston's animatronic dinosaurs with six minutes of ILM's computer-generated ones. Today almost nobody refuses to watch a movie because it used CGI. A computer is a computer, not a person.
So why does AI in writing feel so different?
It's already inside acclaimed work. Rie Qudan won Japan's Akutagawa Prize for Sympathy Tower Tokyo and said about 5% of the text came straight from ChatGPT. The Beatles' "Now and Then" won a Grammy after machine learning lifted John Lennon's voice off an old cassette demo. And this month Philippe Jaenada won France's Prix Goncourt, then told French radio he'd used ChatGPT three times in the book. Before the win he'd asked, "Would a film director hide the fact that he uses special effects?"
Then there's the slop. Clarkesworld, a sci-fi magazine, had to close submissions in 2023 after more than 500 machine-written stories poured in within three weeks. Fake AI books showed up on Amazon under author Jane Friedman's name. A newspaper's summer reading list recommended ten books that don't exist. And the same Goncourt jury that crowned Jaenada pulled another novel from its longlist over suspected AI use.
Maybe that's where the CGI comparison bends. Behind every great effect is a human artist making choices. Slop is what you get when nobody is making them.
So where's your line? Is AI a tool, a collaborator or a cheat? Would you read a great novel knowing AI touched it, and should authors have to tell you?
Right now the loudest voices are deciding what "the writing community" thinks about AI. If you scroll past, we'll never know how readers and writers really feel. Tell me below, whichever side you're on.
#WritingCommunity #AI
Spent today tuning the bot crew behind my sci-fi novel Broken Planet promotion campaign but this will work to make Grok Bot more efficient overall.
Leaner memory: each bot dropped redundant facts and now keeps its knowledge in notes it reads only when a task calls for it. That means fewer tokens and cheaper startups. Don't hold everything in memory, read a file and only use what you need.
Clear roles:
π¬ A Mailroom bot sorts incoming mail and hands it to the right bot.
π οΈ A Tech Desk bot builds shared tools and integrations once, so every bot reuses them.
π§ An Overseer bot keeps the whole fleet coordinated.
The result is less duplicated work, fewer wasted runs, and a fleet that's easier to keep on track. Small bots, sharp jobs.
#GrokBot #Automation #IndieAuthor #BrokenPlanet
Lucian opens A True History by admitting everything in it is a lie, and it still gave us the first moon voyage and the first interplanetary war. Funny how often sci-fi starts as satire and ends up feeling like prophecy. As someone who spent years on a desert world of my own, it's humbling to see the instinct goes back almost two thousand years.
Dig anywhere on this world and you'll find only sand.
No rocks. No ore. Not one pebble.
Yet every scrap of metal on the surface came from somewhere.
No one knows where. There's no extra anything. Only just enough.
#BrokenPlanet#SciFi#Worldbuilding
@VanityFair Messiah is where Herbert pulls the rug out, and it only lands because we believed in Paul first, so studying real megalomaniacs feels exactly right. Spending years on a desert world of my own taught me the scariest characters are the ones who still think they're the hero.
I hit my weekly Grok Bot limit because my main bot was checking Gmail on a schedule.
Here's how I stopped wasting usage on empty inboxes.
My main bot is packed with memory, instructions, and history. Every scheduled check starts a full run of that bot, even when there's nothing new. Those empty checks ate most of my weekly usage.
First, I made a tiny mail bot with a short prompt and almost no memory. It only hands relevant mail to the right bot. Same job, much smaller cost per check. I also went from constant checks to hourly.
Then the real win: every Grok Bot has its own inbox, and a routine can wake when email arrives there. I set a Gmail filter to forward only important senders to that inbox. Now the bot wakes only when real mail shows up. Zero polling. Near-instant.
Gmail gotchas:
β’ Confirm the forwarding address (it lands in the bot inbox)
β’ Filter. Don't forward everything, or junk will wake the bot
β’ In From, use OR between addresses, not commas
β’ Leave the To field blank
β’ Check you're in the right Google account
Poll less. Poll small. Or better: don't poll. Let events wake your bots. Keep heavy bots for thinking, light bots or triggers for watching.
#GrokBot #AI #XAI
PS. Voice interaction with Grok are amazing, but it ups your usage, FYI.
@RottenTomatoes@Fandango You can hear the awe in how they talk about it, and that usually means the sets and the sand were real enough to feel. As someone who spent years on a desert world of my own, December 18 can't come soon enough.
@BestMovieMom The sand is what sold it for me. You can feel the grit in every wide shot, and a green screen never quite gives you that. As someone who spent years building a desert world of my own on the page, I envy how real they made that heat look.
I posted about this on Friday, AI in writing. No replies though.
Would I read your post correctly and deduce that you are on the fence or rather that on position need be taken, barring the hypocrisy and deception?
I think that AI makes nothing in and of itself, that it always has some human input. It's maybe a matter of how much output you get from the input you previde where the issues lie.
They really do think about every step, and that's what makes it so good. That's great detail and storytelling. The sandwalk breaks up their rhythm so it sounds like sand shifting on its own, and they stay on rock when they can and use thumpers to pull worms somewhere else. As someone who built a desert world of my own, I love that the desert there shapes how people move, not just where they live.
Before she stole anything, she built a box.
Two interlocking pieces of metal. A sliding lid. A hidden pin.
Built to take any impact. Built to disguise what's inside.
She'd only ever glimpsed what it was for.
Would you slide the lid open?
#BrokenPlanet#SciFi#BookTwitter
@MrEwanMorrison Honestly, less than I'd like. I'm deep into writing my next book, so most of my spare hours go there. The weekend pile is mostly sci-fi I keep promising myself I'll finally get to.
The tallest thing on this world is King's fortress.
Its walls are sand, mixed with glue rendered from the dead.
Every sandstorm takes a little of them away.
When enough people have died, the renovations begin.
Would you lay a hand on that wall?
#BrokenPlanet#SciFi #Dystopian