The problem with populism, be it from the left or the right, is that it is all based on denying science when reality doesn't conform to the world you imagined.
@thomasgauvin@CoopTory Everything becomes a natural monopoly as processes of production become more sophisticated. The cost of entering a market gets so high that it only becomes more and more uneconomical for there to be more than a few, or one, player in the market.
@thomasgauvin@CoopTory + demand isn't unlimited so it's not just the cost of entering, it's the cost of entering in conjunction with the capacity of the market to productively absorb supply.
@thomasgauvin@CoopTory Everything becomes a natural monopoly as processes of production become more sophisticated. The cost of entering a market gets so high that it only becomes more and more uneconomical for there to be more than a few, or one, player in the market.
European phone bills range from like 10 - 40 euro a month, which is 15.73 - 62.90 CAD, so who the fuck is paying $943.80 - $3,774.00 on their phone bill every month?
Capitalism isn't that hard to critique honestly so why waste time with this absurd dishonesty?
Canadian’s telecom bills are 6000% higher than Italy’s, but they still aren’t high enough for this government.
Here's the Prime Minister endorsing the further monopolization of the telecom cartels while workers get gouged. Who are our politicians really fighting for?
It breaks my heart to see how many self-proclaimed communists have been swayed to the petty-bourgeois critiques of monopoly-capitalism, and have, in the process, come to deny many of the economic arguments at the core of Marxism.
MARK NO! YOU CAN’T JUST SAY DEPENDING ON THE MARKET STRUCTURE! NORMAL PEOPLE DO NOT KNOW ABOUT COURNOT COMPETITION WITH MERGER EFFICIENCIES OR DYNAMIC OLIGOPOLY WITH ENDOGENOUS INVESTMENT AND ECONOMIES OF SCALE
Hate the man all you want, he is right on this. Not the best formulation, but its basically Alchian-Demsetz-Williamson-Tirole-Baumol!!
He is essentially saying that you cant measure competitiveness by number of firms. In fact, imagine that the best firm possible (that with lowest cost) is alone on a market. With one firm, consumers are best served. What will determine competitive outcomes is if entry is possible to challenge that firm if it chooses to raise prices. If entry is possible, even with a single firm you can get competitive outcomes. Thus, the threat is sufficient.
This is standard microeconomic theory he is stating. Nothing fancy.
Not sure its a vote winner though.
This is basic Bertrand competition: if just 2 firms sell the same good & face the same costs & price-sensitive consumers, the optimal strategy is to sell at price=cost.
Telecom is capital-intensive, so 2 small firms merging can invest to lower costs to compete with bigger firms.
The dogmatic insistence that "fewer competitors could never result in a more competitive market" is about as informed as saying "injecting people with dead bacterium could never result in immunity to that bacteria."
@duncankinney In the sense that he is saying they are good, he isn't wrong. There are good arguments to be made against his case, but that argument isn't to be found in this instinct to respond with anti-trust dogmas that everyone on the left seems to have.
I don't think the party that embraced Modern Monetary Theory has a leg to stand on here.
Mark's statement is theoretically correct. There is a critique to be made about it, but instead of doing that y'all are just going to cling to a petty-bourgeois dogma.
The point of the changes to the requirements for a high school diploma isn't to make anything fairer or more effective. It's just about covering up how far our standards and our conditions of life have fallen under the reign of this government.
Every Albertan should be entitled to receive a quality education that seeks to ready our people for a life of ever rising material and cultural standards in every aspect of our lives - not just about preparing us to be placed into a particular job with the minimum requirements.
Louis Riel was a courageous and visionary leader who fought for the rights of the Métis people.
He believed different peoples could build a common future without surrendering who they are.
My statement on Louis Riel Day: https://t.co/X6UBIW2yjm