@CitizenAmedia@Cuddly49905741 The idea that you need to do all this just to survive is the issue. Not everyone wants to live to work. Some people just want bare necessities. Why is there such pushback to this? Man works 80 hours and can’t afford a family. Ur insane if you think that’s normal or fair.
@The_BenC@RenfailSoL They are creations of Iluvatar, they do birth the same as us confirmed. What’s to say they wouldn’t develop their own sense of self and culture when not in the thralls of a dark lord. And the show questions whether or not they are predisposed to be used as tools of a dark lord.
Peter Jackson's films are regarded as masterpieces, and they were in no way, shape, or form true to the books.
Major Omissions
Tom Bombadil & The Barrow-wights: Completely cut from the film to streamline the pacing after leaving the Shire, meaning Merry never acquires his special Arnorian blade from the barrow.
The Scouring of the Shire: Omitted the late-stage conflict where the hobbits return home to find the Shire taken over by Saruman's ruffians, removing the books' message about home being worth fighting for locally.
Glorfindel Replaced by Arwen: The Elven-lord Glorfindel who rescues Frodo on the road to Rivendell is replaced by Arwen to give her a more active role in the first film.
Timeline & Plot Alterations
The 17-Year Gap Compressed: In the books, a 17-year delay passes between Bilbo's farewell party and Gandalf confirming the One Ring, during which Frodo turns 50. The films condense this into what feels like a few days or weeks.
The Army of the Dead at Pelennor Fields: In the books, the ghosts help defeat the Corsairs of Umbar at Pelargir, allowing human soldiers from southern Gondor to sail to the battle of Minas Tirith. In the movies, the ghost army arrives directly at the battle and acts as an all-powerful sweeping cheat code.
Elves at Helm’s Deep: Jackson added a detachment of Elves led by Haldir to fight alongside men at Helm’s Deep, an event that never happens in the novel.
Character Changes
Aragorn’s Arc: Book-Aragorn is confident, proud of his lineage, and actively wants to claim the throne of Gondor from the start. Film-Aragorn is reluctant, burdened by the fear of repeating Isildur’s weakness, and only embraces his destiny over time.
Faramir’s Temptation: In the books, Faramir immediately rejects the One Ring and sees its danger. In the movies, he captures Frodo and Sam and takes them toward Osgiliath first, temporarily being swayed by the Ring's power.
Denethor’s Portrayal: Book-Denethor is a proud, noble, and tragic steward broken by grief and despair via the Palantír. Film-Denethor is depicted as far more unlikable, petty, and crazed.
Théoden’s Possession: Théoden’s slow recovery from Saruman’s influence in the books is portrayed in the films as a more direct magical possession/exorcism scene.
---
So when you claim that Rings of Power is somehow "deviating" from the "source material", I laugh at how blatantly you are lying to yourself and to others. It's not about the source material for you. It's not about authenticity to you. If it were, you would be out there raging about what a slap in the face Jackson's films were.
No, your "outrage" is purely performative. Because at the end of the day, Rings of Power is an adaptation, just like Jackson's films. And they are going to change MANY things based on the creative vision. Some we'll agree with. Some we we won't. But at the end of the day it brings more fans to Middle-Earth, and that is a GOOD thing.
Gatekeep somewhere else. REAL fans support ALL version of The Lord of the Rings, and welcome new faces into the fold with open arms.
#RingsOfPower #RingsOfPowerS3 #TheRingsOfPower #TheRingofPower
@IronyEdward@furlan_mai31709@DiscussingFilm He had to distance those characters from their synder counterparts that had movies not that long ago, including an elseworld Batman sequel soon to be released. You’d be derping hard to assume he was never gonna include them eventually.
I just got an update on the petition I unironically signed to keep James Gunn & Peter Safran as DC studio heads… when I signed it only had about 2K signatures. This is serious business... #RestoreTheGunnVerse
I’m not going to go back and forth with you (it’s football season for God’s sake!), but I can’t believe you’re actually denying this interaction so I’ll jog your memory:
August of 2016, during the Olympics, at the (now shuttered) Intercontinental hotel, a couple blocks from the Fox lot off Pico.
We had just finished a night show that no longer exists where (among other things) we debated the Summer Olympics (it was a bad segment because we didn’t have rights to the footage, so we could only show still pictures of what we were talking about) & went to have a drink/meal with a colleague who was on the show with us.
The exchange I discussed happened in the lobby bar, at a table with said colleague, and then after I said what I needed to say to to you I went outside and bummed a cigarette off a valet.
We haven’t spoken in person since.
You know as well as I do this is 100% true, and verifiable, by the colleague that was with us and/or our then bosses who contemporaneously heard the story.
We actually also had the same agent at the time, and you and I both know he heard the story and could confirm it as well.
So, I’ll pull a page out of your book; I’ll bet you $1,000,000 I’m telling the truth.
I assume you’ll pretend you never saw this tweet & continue the grift. And that’s cool, but we both know what the facts are.
Also, let this be a reminder that while you have found an amazing lane where you often are actually the smartest guy in the room, this ain’t that lane. So my advice would be to tread carefully.
@RapsReport Do you think it’s likely either team wants to do business w the other after the whole summer debacle? Clippers org is a hardball organization, I don’t think they will sell any of their players for cheap.