Biological psychiatry, a total failure. Thomas Insel, the director of the US National Institute of Mental Health from 2002 to 2015, said in an interview in 2017: “I spent 13 years at NIMH really pushing on the neuroscience and genetics of mental disorders, and when I look back on that I realize that while I think I succeeded at getting lots of really cool papers published by cool scientists at fairly large costs - I think $20 billion - I don’t think we moved the needle in reducing suicide, reducing hospitalizations, improving recovery for the tens of millions of people who have mental illness. I hold myself accountable for that.” https://t.co/YpqYhDZNLb
As ever Denise offers insights others miss. Her unique take on the Minnesota Coronary Experiment is worth a gander if you have firm views on seed oils etc. (one way or t'other)
The Minnesota Coronary Experiment is a really bad study and I wish it would fall off its pedestal.
It did find that people whose cholesterol dropped had higher death rates, but it also found that high blood pressure and smoking were associated with lower mortality (which was oddly ignored in the 2016 Ramsden re-analysis). If we trust the cholesterol finding as legit/generalizable, we'd have to somehow defend high blood pressure and smoking as being protective too. Lest we be pickin' cherries.
The much more likely reality is that 1) the data got whacky because so many participants were lost to follow-up (83%!) and didn't have their mortality data included in the final analysis, and 2) the patient population itself was a confounder. The vast majority were residents of state mental hospitals, which at the time were largely schizophrenics, which is a condition well-linked to disordered PUFA metabolism. Ditto for other psychiatric conditions people would have been committed for back then. Probably one of the worst populations you could choose to selectively pour a bunch of linoleic acid into; they have unique vulnerabilities to excess omega-6 and tend to have low baseline omega-3 and low antioxidant status that would just get worsened through the type of trial diet given.
On top of that, the study didn't document or report on antipsychotic use, and a lot of the first-generation antipsychotics (the ones available during that era) are now known to have caused cardiovascular problems and sudden death. This was one of the issues in the Finnish Mental Hospital study (medication use was unevenly distributed across the two hospitals) and could easily have been a problem in the MCE too, but we can't know for sure because again, not documented. Mystery variables are really unfortunate in this case.
The Sydney Diet-Heart Study isn't much better; everybody raised their linoleic acid intake from baseline, the control diet wasn't actually controlled, and participants tended to spontaneously change other health-related behaviors (smoking, drinking, etc.) after they enrolled.
The only truly excellent study from that era, as far as pure seed oil/linoleic acid trials go, is the LA Veterans Trial. I think that one gets ignored in favor of lower-quality trials because it doesn't initially look like a clean win for either camp (less cardiovascular disease deaths for the seed oil group, but more cancer deaths; if you want to tout one of those findings you have to acknowledge the other one too). After spending way too much time trying to make sense of the data though, I really don't see a plausible way to blame the excess cancer deaths on seed oils (working on a blog post on this), so the best and longest trial of that era really does come out in favor for seed oils. Which I know lots of people don't like to hear.
If data feels emotionally triggering then it's probably a good time to examine whether we're looking for the truth or whether we're looking for confirmation of a favored narrative.
Agree again. I was mostly thinking above of just the bottle of "vegetable oil" which are invariably bought specifially for frying which ain't great .. and then there's veg oils in processed foods; which also ain't great for the extra reason you cite as in found mostly in junk foods. I too make some use of cold pressed organic PUFA rich oils like organic "grizzly" varietal rape a friend makes but only ever cold in dressings etc. But not everyone takes a Masters degree in nutrition so the simple "avoid seed oils" message, while simplistic, has its practical uses! :)
Lenoci also had multiple previous for violent assaults. And attacked and paralyzed Marc P within hours of reporting the alleged (oral) rape of the kid to the poice: before their investigation had even really begun. (Which finally did conclude over a year later, determining there was not enough evidence to try the now paralyzed Marc P)
Those are not the full facts. This dude Lenoci invited neighbour "Marc P." into his house, a man he assumed had raped his 6 year old step-son: apparently intending to murder him. In the event, he beat Marc P. so such an extent that he is alive but now in a semi-vegetative state, with inability to communicate, feed himself or move independently. Appparently the Marc P. dude has a past conviction for child sexual abuse but police investigated the case regarding Lenoci's stepson and found insufficient evidence to prosecute. Views will differ on the appropriatness of such extremely violent premediated vigilantism and likely hinge around assumptions made regarding the supposed guilt or innocence of the man now paralyzed.
Also Lenoci had multiple previous for violent assaults. And turns out his paralysing of Marc P took place the very next day after he'd gone to the police to report the alleged (oral) rape of his stepson. Police had gotten his promise that he would not go near Marc P pending their investigations. It was more than a year later, after Marc P had been paralyzed, that the investigation finally concluded that there was not enough evidence to try him.
This seemed unlikely so I checked and indeed the above is not an accurate representation of the full facts of this story. This dude Lenoci invited neighbour "Marc P." into his house, a man he assumed had raped his 6 year old step-son: apparently intending to murder him. In the event, he beat Marc P. so such an extent that he is alive but now in a semi-vegetative state, with inability to communicate, feed himself or move independently. Appparently the Marc P. dude has a past conviction for child sexual abuse but police investigated the case regarding Lenoci's stepson and found insufficient evidence to prosecute. Views will differ on the appropriatness of such extremely violent premediated vigilantism and likely hinge around assumptions made regarding the supposed guilt or innocence of the man now paralyzed.
People standing at the bottom of a hill with a friend judged it less steep than people standing alone.
The longer they'd known their friend, the less steep it looked.
A good metaphor for life: even the hardest challenges can feel easier with a good friend by your side.
Whatever about one's politics, interesting comments from Dr Vinay here on the "powerful headwinds" he & colleagues in the "MAHA" movement continue to face when attempting a range of long overdue bipartisan policy reforms in the areas of pharma, food & agriculture.
Vested interests don't readily divest themselves of power & wealth.
@sydl_sydl@grok More important is if bro still has similar hairs showing on this toes, esp by midlife. If such hair was visible on the toes before butisn't now, can be a sign of sub-optimal vascular health: poor blood flow to the extremities. Not a keeper! @grok agree?
Great tweet. Very true. The tacit (and occasionally explicit) assumption for the keto diehards is that every detectable blood sugar excursion is evidence of pathology and everything that prevents such is a cure/super healthful. So all sorts of elaborate downstream edifices of dubious physiological reasoning get built upon that questionable foundation. Which is never questioned or questionable.
Know an old lady, retired owner of a hair salon, who would occasionally use a sizeable vintage machine that looks like it was made about a century ago that does this: basically a high voltage device (with various fittings on the end) to electrify the scalp supposedly as a baldness treatment. So this ain't all that new!
@MattWalshShow Since you claim to favour a high bar for robust evidence: remind us all please of the "evidence" for your assertion that this trial 'obviously" only occurred because "they"/'the left"/'the establishment" determined to take Brand down? We'll wait ...
Yes that's the (somewhat clichéd) dichotomy to which I just referred: the agency piece: men failing to impact their environment. But, again really repeating myself, those with high esteem don't often tend to lack agency/impact in their worlds: & those who are showing poor agency/impact, tend to have esteem issues.
@SBakerMD Wow. OK. Might be good to make a clip on that some time. What do you think? Pretty sure I'm not the only one who assumed you were never not top tier healthy. Transformation stories always more interesting for more people than the ever fortunate flexing (speaking generally).