Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺

The most obscure position in philosophy is proving that the intellect is identical to all intelligibles - without multiplicity, alteration, or change.

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@ArabianSword 🙄

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@CfvGgr40332 @allzsoleil @El_Zagrosi صحيح، ألا أن هذا لا يطعن في باقي ما طرحت، فهو (وإن صح في موضعه) لايهدم البناء من أصله، بل يبقى سائر الكلام على متانته.

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@allzsoleil @El_Zagrosi فقد ظهر منهم في اوربا جيل جديد إيزيدي بالنسب لا بالممارسة الدينة، وهذا يعني أن الذي يجمعهم الآن ليس العقيدة وحدها، بل رابط تراثي وتاريخي مشترك، وبنية اجتماعية طبقية خاصة بهم (پير، شيخه، مريد)، تتجاوز العقيدة ولا تنفك عن الهوية.

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@allzsoleil @El_Zagrosi يمكنهم أن يأخذوا بالهوية التقليدية، التي تجمع الدين والقومية في أصل واحد، لا بالهوية المعاصرة المعلمنة المنزوعة من أصلها الديني، وحالهم في ذلك كحال الدروز، فهم دين وقومية في آن واحد. لكن هذا لا يمنع أن تتطور الهوية الإيزيدية عن أصلها هذا، خصوصًا بعد الهجرات إلى أوربا... يتبع

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@KurdistanWatch The correct term is 'Madkhali,' not 'Makhdali.'
And Abdullatif himself publicly stated that while he indeed once held Rabi' al-Madkhali in high regard, but he no longer adheres to his teachings any more.

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@Jaban_alkurdi "It's a way out of the problem and making peace and stability"
Would you kindly elaborate on this statement?

What problem?
How would it achieve peace and stability in the area?

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@drhermis @daiki__q @Ramsen_ The Coolie camp (CC)

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@kluwtv @qewirze In addition Kurds and Arabs define identity differently.
It's almost opposite.
For Kurds, identity is biological, you're Kurdish by blood and origin.
For Arabs, identity is by culture and language.
Arab is Arab by language and culture, ancestry is secondary is secondary to them.

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@kluwtv @qewirze Your last sentence is the distinction here, no one chooses their origins.
Hating someone for that is like hating someone for being tall or born blind.
Pure ignorance.
The blame is on choices, ideas embraced, these are made willingly, where or to whom you're born isn't a choice.

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@hussein_st57834 @IKRPresident First premise is false equivalence (apples are not oranges, and vice versa)

Second premise is a prediction, predictions require evidence, without evidence they remain speculation.

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@JustA_User12345 @KurdistanWatch Things to note:
Turkey's actions are driven by which Kurdish group is in power
KRI and KRG is a legally recognized state/entity, Rojava wasn't.

Turkey views the KRI as allies, but they view the PYD/YPG as terrorists, KRI isn't aligned with the PKK, PYD/YPG are aligned with them

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@JustA_User12345 @KurdistanWatch Don't mean geopolitical powers?

Geographical is related to geography as location, existence of mountain ranges, trading routes, natural resources, which has nothing to do with the subject being discussed

What vacuum is being addressed here?
How do you think it'll be created?

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@JustA_User12345 @KurdistanWatch You're combining separate issues into one argument. It'll be more productive to evaluate each point on its own merits.
Otherwise, it will become difficult for you to reach a clear and accurate conclusion.

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@JustA_User12345 @KurdistanWatch In addition, Turkey presence is under article 51 of the UN charter, going all out violates article 2 p4 of the UN charter .

Moreover, Turkey has stated that it does not claim sovereignty over Iraqi land, and has no territorial ambitions.

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@JustA_User12345 @KurdistanWatch Not entirely correct, iraq is indeed behind in terms of military technology, however, it will not just stand and watch, they'll need to save face at least.
In addition, iraq already has a a military and security pact signed with turkey in 2024, in which iraq also banned the PKK.

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@JustA_User12345 @KurdistanWatch Not necessarily bad news.
KRG (kurdistan regional government), how can a government "dissolve" in a country?
That doesn't make sense.
If you mean Turkey occupying Kurdistan region of iraq then that's impossible without risking war with iraq and facing international sanctions

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@Las10929489 @Karitani22 @KurdistanWatch If this scenario would happen somehow, though highly unlikely, it might lead to an armed conflict between the wining party and the loosing party's armed forces.

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@Las10929489 @Karitani22 @KurdistanWatch Correct, these parties possess significant influence as well as military power.
Suppressing one of them simply means the other will dominate in it's place.

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@Las10929489 @Karitani22 @KurdistanWatch And we need to keep in mind that both parties have gained significant power and support over the past 20+ years.
Even if a new party emerges, it won't be able to compete with them.

[Ali | علي | ܥܠܝ | 𐩲𐩡𐩺 @__Ali_H]

@Las10929489 @Karitani22 @KurdistanWatch Well, frequent transitions of power between leadership or a single leadership remaining in power for prolonged time isn't necessarily a positive or a negative thing, what matters here is the actual outcomes.