@martinmbauer Hes not dismissing a properties
Hes dismissing a comparatively rudimentary way of describing the properties
Genuinely I do not understand how smart people are not getting this
@StozekStyczny@wtgowers Makes sense that its your first hearing of it.
Gorard and wolfram worked closely together and this idea has shaped their understanding of the world and deeply informs this idea he's talking about here
Look into it and report back cause I am very curious how it lands now
@StozekStyczny@wtgowers In the sense of the fly's perspective. No "code information".. thats just description through anthropomorphisation
I mean the flys literal and legitimate and exactly replicated representation
Are you familiar with wolfram's ruliad?
@StozekStyczny@wtgowers Let me ask you a basic question cause I am exasperated.. haha
You seem to have a problem with simulating information and scale.
Is the fly's interpretation of wind useful to us or no?
@StozekStyczny@wtgowers Another thing tho... how can we say thst these properties are at all useful when compared to possibly other superior properties
Of course tho too, if the fly literally conveyed to us his representation, we would be more likely to understand it. But not easily
@StozekStyczny@wtgowers Yes
Because the properties that it predicts are properties this intellect already knows in exact detail. Without calculating anything at all
For us to truly understand how and why the fly represents the wind, we have to know everything yhere is to know about the fly
@StozekStyczny@wtgowers Fine, I wasnt specific enough
Gorard is not right by accident. He is very likely smarter than both of us.
It seems so obvious to me that a sufficiently god-like intellect does not need NS and possibly cannot even understand the use of it without sufficiently god-like empathy
@arcsincall@wtgowers It does
But as intelligence changes, so to does perception of events
NS is very possibly useless or near useless or not relevant to a superior intelligence.
How does a fly perceive and make meaning of the wind, for instance
@StozekStyczny@wtgowers Fair enough but like, maybe it is useless
I mean, you are using another human abstraction designed for and by humans.
How do you think a caterpillar represents humans? Does it even represent humans in any sense meaningful to us?
Similarly....
@StozekStyczny@wtgowers Its not that a superintelligence *cant, its that it may not have any desire or motivation to.
"Quantum approximations" being an effective way to interpret things may only be an artifact of human perception
@arcsincall@wtgowers Thats true. But either way, a superintelligence is obviously looking for meaning. Here, the tweet is the meaning. In fluid dynamics... is NS the meaning for the superintelligence? Unlikely I say
@arcsincall@wtgowers The tweet is a condensed message. It has an explicit pattern meant to elicit meaning, by people, in a very localized set of circumstance. Thats the point
The tweet and the screen do not represent the more randomized set of broad natural actions
Unfortunately, if you know the system--it is not hard... merely a couple little facts--we actually have socialized healthcare and others ARE actually obliged to pay for it.
2 things:
-you have a right to seek medical care
-You are not responsible for the bill.....eventually
Kaitlan. There’s no such thing as “free healthcare”. WE are paying for other people to see the doctor.
And AOC isn’t just dumb…she’s a liar. Everyone already DOES have a right to see a doctor. Anytime they want to. They’re just not entitled to have us pay for them.