@train_collector@muslimorthodoxy@GuntarioDotCom The Islamic Dilemma is an internal critique, so when you grant the Islamic paradigm (to derive a contradiction from it to ultimately prove it false), part of that paradigm includes the Islamic belief that the previous scriptures are corrupt. You must grant that for it to work.
@sickkas@SeerahDawah@Jay_49erTikTok Nah you just don't understand how essence works and are misusing it in place for the "you" (player) which is why you think your analogy isn't heretical. bruh
@sickkas@SeerahDawah@Jay_49erTikTok 1 person (you) controlling 3 dependant, functional and distinct agents (the characters) is not analogous to 3 persons sharing a 1 divine essence, so it DOES entail Modalism. The fact that you are ignoring this tells me you are just in denial of how terrible your disanalogy is
@Edenlife9 https://t.co/MaCBhF8bIq
Its not that he doesn't care about religion, its that he doesn't care for the Man-God bullshit in Christianity. Here is him actually being interested in a conversation with a Muslim preacher.
@sickkas@SeerahDawah@Jay_49erTikTok Dude, I know you didn't actually say that verbatim in your previous reply. I'm telling you that is what your analogy ENTAILS. It doesn't actually reflect the Trinity like you claim it does, but rather reflects the heresy of Modalism.
@sickkas@SeerahDawah@Jay_49erTikTok It is disanalogous to the Trinity though. The Trinity is 3 distinct persons sharing 1 divine essence. What you’ve given as an analogy is one person expressed through 3 distinct, dependent, functional agents - not 3 persons.