@metajewtoday The qualifier is the ืงืฉืื, not the answer. Bedorosov can soften the praise - one shittah reads it as criticism of Noach himself. I was asking why go there. Appreciate the pushback.
Something has always bothered me about Rashi in Parshas Noach. The Torah calls Noach "a righteous man" โ ื ื ืืืฉ ืฆืืืง โ yet Rashi brings opinions that read this as criticism: that he was only righteous compared to his wicked generation, and had he lived in the time of Avraham, he wouldn't have amounted to much. Why? Why can't we simply read it as praise?
Perhaps the answer lies in our Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur davening, where we say ืืื ืืช ื ื ืืืืื ืืืจืช โ "and You remembered Noach with love." Those who viewed Noach less favorably may actually be giving us hope. We are saying to Hashem: just as You saved Noach even though he may not have been the most outstanding person in Your eyes โ You found merit in him relative to his generation and saved him โ so too, look at us, Your precious children. We may not be the best out there; we have our struggles. But compared to the world around us, how wonderfully we shine.
I later found this Pshat in a Sefer called ืื ืืช ืฉืื!
Tagging @ShabbosReads in hopes that it gets more exposure!
I realized that my post earlier came out a bit messed up - reposting as one post
@ShabbosReads I'm not a big reader. Slow reader, actually - when I read Harry Potter, by the 3rd book I couldn't remember who Harry was ๐ค๐
But I spent a lot of time reading this over Shabbos/RH and it was worth every minute.
The Dance of Teshuva by Rav David Ebner z"l - essays & poetry, presented by 18Forty. For a slow reader like me, it was perfect. As the saying goes, good things come in small packages.
The first essay, "The Dance of Teshuva," could have ended the book right there and it would have been worthwhile for me. The idea: if teshuva is done by habit and not with heart, is it really teshuva?
The message is deep and makes you think. A lot. But it left me wondering the reverse: the second time we sin - if it's done by habit and not with soul and heart, does that make us better than we think we are?
Then "Between Man & Man." One line rang so loud I kept going back to it (notice the folded page): "Journeys, not destinations, are the only thing of importance."
We spend so much time focused on the end goal that we forget to focus on how we're getting there. So much happens along the way - it would be a shame to miss it all in exchange for the final stop.
And I'd be lying if I didn't admit that when I read "a ferd bleibt a ferd" (an ass always remains an ass), a few individuals immediately came to mind. Yes, on RH ๐
@DBashIdeas@18_forty 7/
And I'd be lying if I didn't admit that when I read "a ferd bleibt a ferd" (an ass always remains an ass), a few individuals immediately came to mind. Yes, on RH ๐
1/
@ShabbosReads I'm not a big reader. Slow reader, actually - when I read Harry Potter, by the 3rd book I couldn't remember who Harry was ๐ค๐ But I spent a lot of time reading this over Shabbos and RH, and it was worth every minute ๐งต
@DBashIdeas@18_forty 6/
We spend so much time focused on the end goal that we forget to focus on how we're getting there. So much happens along the way - it would be a shame to miss it all in exchange for the final stop.
3/
The first essay, "The Dance of Teshuva," could have ended the book right there and it would have been worthwhile for me. The idea: if teshuva is done by habit and not with heart, is it really teshuva?
2/
The Dance of Teshuva by Rav David Ebner z"l - essays & poetry, presented by 18Forty. For a slow reader like me, it was perfect. As the saying goes, good things come in small packages.
Itโs the official publication day of my new book!
I Read This Over Shabbos: Reading Jewish History in the Parasha
Iโm really proud of this book and hope you consider buying and reading!
Hereโs a link: https://t.co/Vq7qii2NWr