@AlfonsoFuggetta su alcune cose può essere vero, basta che non ci si illuda di poter applicare la stessa metodologia a progetti complessi, o di poter passare da prototipo a production senza conoscenze tecniche. per chi le ha però basta qualche accorgimento (v. tweet sopra) per fare il salto
@AlfonsoFuggetta “una pagina web” non dà metro della complessità dato che evidentemente non è una pagina statica ma una webapp gestionale con un qualche database e una discreta quantità di javascript. la si può anche fare con sonnet ma è meglio pianificarla con opus
@AlfonsoFuggetta non c’è bisogno di mettersi sulla difensiva; le ho solo suggerito cosa cambiare nel suo approccio per ottenere dei risultati decenti. “basta dirgli cosa vuoi, fa tutto lui” è ovviamente una favola, ma basta davvero poco per ottenere qualcosa di buona qualità con sforzo minimo
@Cr1st14nM3s14n0 e perché questa cosa non dovrebbe valere anche per claude code standard? per funzionare il tuo codice lo deve mandare da qualche parte; volendo il tuo repository ce l’hanno già
@ooobenblief@ParkerFoxtrot@Kulambq if “first” requires the result to be notable and influential then sure, the beatles were first. i’m using “first” to mean who did it first. we just disagree on the definition. and i don’t see the point in continuing this discussion
@ooobenblief@ParkerFoxtrot@Kulambq the claim was “first to do x”, now you’re arguing “first to do X well/influentially,” which is a different claim. also “used it incorrectly” is circular, adler used a leslie on vocals for the same purpose. you’re just defining correct use as use that became famous
@ooobenblief@ParkerFoxtrot@Kulambq adler was not a guy in a bedroom, he was a well known producer and released a single. it didn’t have influence because it flopped, which is the point: he had the idea first but he didn’t have the platform, so he doesn’t get credit and the beatles (wrongly) do
@ooobenblief@ParkerFoxtrot@Kulambq i said they were not the first to do stuff in absolute terms, i said nothing about cultural impact. that’s a completely different topic. also definitely not a case of parallel innovation, they were influenced by the work of adler before them
@ParkerFoxtrot@Kulambq sure, but this means motown already had it figured out, they just didn’t get the credit because they were doing it in a garage instead of abbey road with unlimited free studio time
@ParkerFoxtrot@Kulambq we could get into an argument about the blurry line between musician and producer, but it was geoff emerick’s innovation and not the band’s
@janbamjan so this explains why when i asked claude to guess my age and degree it reasoned like this (and gave an incorrect answer of course). the prompt is leaking