This is a comparison of performance between Lady Justice Christine Meoli who has admitted inability to conclude matters in time, and Lady Justices Teresa Odera and Teresia Matheka ranked amongst the best performing Judges.
Justice Meoli delivered 45 judgments, 27 final rulings and 30 interlocutory rulings.
Justice Odera delivered 109 judgments, 324 final rulings and 166 interlocutory rulings.
Justice Matheka delivered 157 judgments, 87 final rulings and 108 interlocutory rulings.
Evidently, Justice Meoli is unable to perform her duties as a Judge. She scored below 50% and can be ranked as a D+ Judge.
Interestingly, Justice Meoli is senior to both Justices Odera and Matheka and is deemed to be more experienced having served as Magistrate for long, having served as a Registrar of the High Court (remember her swearing-in Mwai Kibaki at night) and having been appointed Judge earlier than the two best performing Lady Judges.
Judges should not be ranked primarily on raw quantitative output. Cases aren’t fungible.
This methodology is so deeply flawed: it ignores complexity, quality, incentives, and context, and risks distorting how justice is actually delivered.
I refer to the statement that:
1. The 233-km highway project is financed through 25% equity and 75% debt, with NSSF contributing 40% of the equity.
2. NSSF will receive 40% of toll collections over the 30-year concession, while China Road and Bridge Corporation (CRBC) receives 60%.
Let me offer to add some information on how payment is made to the various equity and debt financiers in a PPP project. The road toll collected goes to first pay the “debt financiers” and then “equity shareholders” following the PPP Payment Waterfall.
Please be informed that a PPP payment waterfall is the contractual sequence in which money received by a Project Company (SPV) is allocated to meet its financial obligations, operating expenses, debt repayments, investor returns and other payments.
Typical PPP payment waterfall
1. Project revenue
Toll collections, electricity payments, water tariffs or government availability payments
2. Statutory payments
Taxes, statutory levies and mandatory deductions
3. Essential operating costs
Operations, maintenance, insurance, personnel and essential service providers
4. Senior debt service
Interest, principal repayments and senior lender fees
5. Reserve accounts
Debt Service Reserve Account (DSRA), major maintenance and lifecycle reserves
6. Subordinated debt
Repayment of shareholder loans and subordinated financing
7. Equity distributions
Dividends and returns to shareholders, subject to distribution tests
🤨🤨🤨Summary: Only 25% of the road toll is available for the two shareholders and they get paid only after the others have been paid.
https://t.co/bPqen2s2YI
These are the new fees after GRA ( formerly BCLB) was moved from the Ministry of Interior to the Office of the President.
We have a case against this in court.