I promise you that not one of these pontificators have read ANY of the founding texts/pronouncements/policies by self-proclaimed Zionists, early or late. Still less Lord Montagu, the lone Jew in Cabinet, warning of the dangers of Zionism to Jews.
I understand where this line of thought comes from but i don't think it's useful at all. Putting aside existing literature, what's happening in Palestine is dependent on and structured by capitalism sure but we still have to describe it as something, if not genocide then what?
This is….. For one, “genocide” is not a “liberal term,” nor does it reduce our struggle to a humanitarian crisis (I mean, what?!) Genocide implies both the existence of a culprit and the need for punishment; two conditions that make the argument presented in this video invalid. Secondly, I’m not sure if this is an attempt at criticizing/highlighting the uselessness international law, but what comes across is a needless effort to complicate/problematize a framework that is already made marginal by the ruling class: maybe you think the word “genocide” as it relates to Gaza has become mainstream, because of the bubbles we inhabit, but the truth of the matter is that the majority of the world’s powers are yet to officially acknowledge genocide, (because acknowledging it means having to do something about it etc.), and so the argument in this video is inadvertently in service of the status-quo, not a disruption to it. We don’t need to do all this.
a lot of people have learned the wrong lessons from Corbynism. part of the reason the Brexit & antisemitism wedges were so effective were because they were used to turn the Labour left against itself - often in cripplingly vicious & destructive ways that we're still unpacking
Another way to kill a language, that you didn't mention in your book: get Gove to create the Year 6 language curriculum, where he'll stuff it full of decontextualised 'grammar', and use that as a metric for 'expected levels of writing', divorced from meaning, effect, audience
I used to respect Dr Dave Rich, even when I disagreed with him. But then I cross examined him in court.
He admits he: is a Zionist; wants to maintain a Jewish demographic majority in “Israel”; supports racist Israeli legislation.
He’s openly racist. He’s not a credible expert.
Feels almost redundant to point out how racist and intimidatory behaviour like this gets barely, if any, attention compared to, say, dismantling a components factory providing tools for enabling genocide.
The moral arc of the universe is long but it bends towards Jeremy Clarkson spending decades denying global warming only to sink his fortune into a farm just as global warming really starts to kick in
The media and political outrage around the Zionism Is Racism motion is because a major UK party adopting this stance takes the public conversation much closer to being completely immune from the main tool used to destabilise the left: spurious accusations of antisemitism.
“As a Palestinian, I am the direct subject of Zionism. I’m an expert on it, in fact, because it is practised on my body”
Mohammed El-Kurd defines Zionism in under 5 minutes. He says everything that needs to be said👇
The British media is currently discussing whether or not Zionism is a form of anti-Palestinian racism. But so far, I’ve not seen one outlet host a Palestinian person to ask them what they think.
This is egregious racism, which we wouldn’t accept for any other group.