Why can’t those who “dare to question” government be questioned? If they are ill informed what’s the harm in calling them out? If they raise noise rather than voice they should be questioned.
Surjit Bhalla's description of an entire generation as “entitled” is deeply disappointing.
To dismiss young citizens who dare to question those in power as arrogant or ill-informed is condescending behaviour disguised as "analysis".
What Mr Bhalla sees as entitlement, I see as courage.
His own estimates suggest that nearly 7 million eligible voters may be missing from electoral rolls without adequate explanation. Yet this is somehow presented as statistically insignificant. Since when did the possible disenfranchisement of millions become such a trivial issue ?
One may disagree with the Opposition's demands or the methods of protesters. But questioning those in power is neither arrogance nor entitlement.
If anything, this generation deserves credit for refusing to remain silent in the face of the most powerful.
In my opinion democracy should fear an indifferent generation far more than a questioning one.
Dissent is one of democracy's greatest strengths.
His work was funded by Ford Foundation and McArthur Foundation. How many million years would it take to those "100 workers" to match billionaires like Henry Ford and John McArthur? Or is this calculation meant only for the non-white billionaires? Saving Indian souls - backed by western business - is a very old game.....
“You cannot become voice of nation by gathering cadres of 14 parties and assembling a crowd of 8,000 in an area of 1.5 kms.”
- HM Amit Shah tells Rahul Gandhi
@abhiwhy Leading to where? If you can’t suggest that right now, there is no point pf having this intuition as almost every event can suggest something.
#ExpressExclusive | On the SIR controversy, Abhijit Dipke argues that CJP’s demand is for free and fair elections, not a rejection of the electoral process.
Watch full video: https://t.co/bz8xnNcsku
A classic FAFO incident:
1st video: Cockroaches saw a car with Bhagwa flags and started abusing the occupants while hitting the car.
2nd video: Car occupants got out and taught them a lesson which they may never forget.
The second video is getting viral and the first video is not.
The occupants of the car are being branded as criminals because of this paid journalist who didn't say a word about cockroaches hitting the car and blamed the whole situation on the car occupants.
STATEMENT OF SOLIDARITY WITH THE YOUTH OF INDIA
Dhaka, Bangladesh | 10 October 2026
To the youth and democratic forces of India,
We stand in firm solidarity with the young people of India demanding electoral accountability and defending their democratic rights. Recent detentions of peaceful protesters, organizers, and journalists in New Delhi, alongside internet suspensions and restrictions at Jantar Mantar, directly threaten fundamental freedoms. Concerns regarding electoral integrity and institutional independence require transparent answers, not barricades and censorship.
This struggle is not yours alone. From Dhaka, we stand with you as friends bound by a common demand for accountable power, democratic institutions, and human dignity.
We know this struggle intimately, because we have lived it. In July 2024, our student led movement against recruitment quotas transformed into a nationwide uprising against 15 years of authoritarian rule. The state responded with live ammunition. The United Nations later estimated that as many as 1,400 people were killed during the uprising and its suppression. We deeply remember and honor the solidarity shown by Indian students, writers, and independent voices during our uprising.
We recognize India's rich traditions of democratic resistance. The women of Shaheen Bagh defended equal citizenship through a Delhi winter, while generations of students at JNU and Jadavpur University have sustained organised dissent. These remain invaluable democratic inheritances. Today, we once again see the courage of young Indian women on the streets. In Bangladesh, women were also at the forefront of the July Revolution; their courage and sacrifices helped secure our victory.
Hindutva majoritarianism, fascism, and every form of religious supremacy must not define the future of South Asia. We reject authoritarianism, communal hatred, and political intolerance in India just as we reject them in Bangladesh. Our shared future must rest on communal harmony and social justice, irrespective of religion, caste, gender, or class. No society is truly democratic while minorities live in fear, dissent is criminalized, and citizenship is conditional on identity.
We call upon Indian authorities to respect the right to peaceful assembly, disclose the whereabouts and legal grounds for detaining protest organizers, immediately release those held for exercising their rights, and ensure journalists can report without intimidation or equipment seizure.
Today, many young leaders have been unjustly detained. Sharjeel Imam and Umar Khalid continue to be kept behind bars for years without trial. We regard all of India's young protesters and prisoners of conscience as comrades. Their courage inspires young people across South Asia.
Our struggles are interconnected, extending to unresolved issues of border killings, water sharing, environmental protection, and national sovereignty. We seek a South Asia where nations treat each other as equals, governments remain accountable, and sovereignty is never an excuse for domination.
To the democratic people of India: from Dhaka, and from the unfinished democratic aspirations of our July generation, we stand with you. Stand firm, protect one another, reject communal hatred, and refuse to surrender the future of South Asia to fascism and division.
Inqilab Zindabad.
STATEMENT OF SOLIDARITY WITH THE YOUTH OF INDIA
Dhaka, Bangladesh | 10 October 2026
To the youth and democratic forces of India,
We stand in firm solidarity with the young people of India demanding electoral accountability and defending their democratic rights. Recent detentions of peaceful protesters, organizers, and journalists in New Delhi, alongside internet suspensions and restrictions at Jantar Mantar, directly threaten fundamental freedoms. Concerns regarding electoral integrity and institutional independence require transparent answers, not barricades and censorship.
This struggle is not yours alone. From Dhaka, we stand with you as friends bound by a common demand for accountable power, democratic institutions, and human dignity.
We know this struggle intimately, because we have lived it. In July 2024, our student led movement against recruitment quotas transformed into a nationwide uprising against 15 years of authoritarian rule. The state responded with live ammunition. The United Nations later estimated that as many as 1,400 people were killed during the uprising and its suppression. We deeply remember and honor the solidarity shown by Indian students, writers, and independent voices during our uprising.
We recognize India's rich traditions of democratic resistance. The women of Shaheen Bagh defended equal citizenship through a Delhi winter, while generations of students at JNU and Jadavpur University have sustained organised dissent. These remain invaluable democratic inheritances. Today, we once again see the courage of young Indian women on the streets. In Bangladesh, women were also at the forefront of the July Revolution; their courage and sacrifices helped secure our victory.
Hindutva majoritarianism, fascism, and every form of religious supremacy must not define the future of South Asia. We reject authoritarianism, communal hatred, and political intolerance in India just as we reject them in Bangladesh. Our shared future must rest on communal harmony and social justice, irrespective of religion, caste, gender, or class. No society is truly democratic while minorities live in fear, dissent is criminalized, and citizenship is conditional on identity.
We call upon Indian authorities to respect the right to peaceful assembly, disclose the whereabouts and legal grounds for detaining protest organizers, immediately release those held for exercising their rights, and ensure journalists can report without intimidation or equipment seizure.
Today, many young leaders have been unjustly detained. Sharjeel Imam and Umar Khalid continue to be kept behind bars for years without trial. We regard all of India's young protesters and prisoners of conscience as comrades. Their courage inspires young people across South Asia.
Our struggles are interconnected, extending to unresolved issues of border killings, water sharing, environmental protection, and national sovereignty. We seek a South Asia where nations treat each other as equals, governments remain accountable, and sovereignty is never an excuse for domination.
To the democratic people of India: from Dhaka, and from the unfinished democratic aspirations of our July generation, we stand with you. Stand firm, protect one another, reject communal hatred, and refuse to surrender the future of South Asia to fascism and division.
Inqilab Zindabad.
@sanjaymanjrekar@abaruah64 Unauthorised protest by definition will not be peaceful. Understand the difference without virtue signalling. Ab agar koi commentary se chhutti ho gayi to rona mat.
@rishilectual Tujhe kya lagta hai bhai, detain hone se pehle inka koi control tha kon log kaha se aa rahe the unpar? Na neet ke waqt koi control tha na ab. To yeh pretend karna band kar k ab jo hoga woh cjp ki responsibility nahi hai.
Never thought I'd see the day the Indian opposition will RT Shri Elon Musk Ji Ki. Our opposition is Left. Musk is as Right as it gets. Hor dus kinne achchhe din chahida tainu!
The same people called Starlink a national security risk last year. Was his entry the scandal or the delay is the scandal? Ek hi sahi hoga na.
Tesla drove in on his conditions because Trump Chachu forced India's hand. Starlink is different. Cars need showrooms, satellite links need security clearance. India will set conditions, Starlink will negotiate, and that's how it works everywhere. China hasn't let him in. Sovereignty is not a monthly internet subscription plan.
Yes, the government is in a tight spot at home ATM. It has seen how a Meta algorithm can feed the fire of dissent. It would want X on its side. Smart of Elon to press the crony nerve at this crucial moment. The government better be equally smart to equal.
My guess is Starlink will eventually be in, once India finalises the framework for this new comm compounder. Even the Indian telcos are still waiting for the final go-ahead. It's natural for Starlink to eye the first-mover advantage. For the government, it should always be Advantage India. No matter which party is in power, some things remain non-negotiable and this issue is not even in that category. Outside the conditions of guardrails, everything else will be negotiated. India is not China. India is not Ghana either.
Like Tesla, Starlink would find few takers though if prices remain in that zone. India remains a value for money and price-sensitive market. Jai ho!