1/8: Origin of Authentic Hadith
Hadith did not begin when Bukhari and Muslim wrote their books. By their time, hadith had already been narrated, taught, and compiled for generations.
Read the first article below ⬇️
8 Things You Need to Know About Hadith
Many people doubt hadith because they do not understand where hadith came from, how they were transmitted, or how scholars distinguished authentic hadith from mistakes and fabrications.
This series aims to explain those questions.
Hadith of Fasting 6 Days in Shawwal
This hadith is debatable. Some scholars supported its authenticity and some opposed it.
It comes from about 4 routes from the Prophet (SAW), and each of these routes has problems. 1/
@Mukhtar11_ Yeah it’s always hilarious when some rando pops in, but we need to consider the wider implications of it like we did when studying Macbeth. Is the one replying to be considered a tragic hero or a villain?
Perhaps at the end of the day, all they really wanted was to be friends.
@Oneubon4563 So in the case of the second opinion, why would the Prophet (SAW) encourage them to go for 7 if it was revealed for 10 to him?
Wouldn’t that mean it got narrowed down or was that just a one off narrowing?