@sergeenko_i Calling it a partnership ignores the obvious risk: giving a predatory state unrestricted access to Europe’s markets, technology and infrastructure is not integration. It’s inviting a wolf into the house.
@TaliadellaRocca@Megatron_ron You can’t persecute people for preserving a religious tradition, then claim to be its rightful heir. That’s not continuity; it’s selective appropriation.
@TaliadellaRocca@Megatron_ron The Mongols destroyed the Song, whose elites saw serving the realm as a public duty. The Ming defeated the Mongols, yet turned officials into tools of imperial power. It restored Chinese symbols, not Song political values. Same land, radically different political traditions.
@TaliadellaRocca@Megatron_ron Byzantine patriarchs could challenge emperors; Muscovy subordinated the Church to the ruler. Mongol-Horde practices shaped its autocracy. Ming China saw a similar rupture. Both claimed civilizational continuity, but their political traditions had fundamentally changed.
@TaliadellaRocca@Megatron_ron Old Believers expose the contradiction. Moscow claimed to defend Byzantine Orthodoxy while persecuting Christians who preserved older rites. What kind of Byzantine legacy is that? Inheriting religious symbols doesn't mean inheriting Byzantium's church-state tradition.
@rinalu_ You're taking Putin's imperial mythology far too seriously. The Third Rome was Moscow's own claim, not an inheritance granted by Byzantium. Meanwhile, the Golden Horde profoundly shaped how Muscovy actually governed. Institutional history matters more than imperial cosplay.
@TaliadellaRocca@Megatron_ron The problem is that the Mongol conquest fundamentally reshaped Muscovy's political institutions and governing practices. Byzantine influence was largely religious and cultural; the Horde profoundly shaped how Moscow actually governed. Sophia's marriage doesn't erase that history.
@RickyKay2020 Russia talks about friendship, yet Georgia left the CIS, Ukraine abandoned its institutions, Moldova is moving toward withdrawal, and even Armenia froze its CSTO participation. If this is Russian friendship, who needs enemies?
@EddieGonzales Russia may inherit Orthodox Christianity culturally, but its political tradition was also deeply shaped by the Golden Horde: centralized power, ruler-centered authority and coercive rule. Religious symbols don't make political behavior Christian.
@OneAmericaowoj Advocates for traditional families, yet lives in a same-sex household.
Advocates for putting locals first, yet lives in Switzerland.
Advocates for Germany First, yet eagerly signs up for someone else's political project.
AfD is a model of saying one thing and doing another.
@ricwe123 Ask Armenia how reliable Russia is as an ally. Moscow abandoned its security commitments when Armenia needed them most. Russia's partners often discover that their interests come second to the Kremlin's.
@TaliadellaRocca@Megatron_ron Byzantine symbols and legal texts don’t prove Byzantine political succession. Byzantine law had reached Rus’ centuries before Sophia’s marriage. Muscovy’s actual political system was shaped by local Rus’ structures and Mongol-Horde influences.
@LizzaBig@Megatron_ron Marrying a princess from the fallen Byzantine Empire did not make Moscow the Third Rome.
By that logic, every royal marriage in Europe would have inherited an empire.
@VicV13270@Magnus_Man_03@clashreport So what? The Ming defeated the Mongols and claimed to revive Chinese civilization, yet its political elite became tools of imperial rule, not partners in governance—much like the Orthodox Church in Muscovy. Cultural continuity doesn't mean political continuity.
@VicV13270@Magnus_Man_03@clashreport You're clearly trying to put Muscovy on a pedestal. Strip away the historical rhetoric, and its institutions, political culture and values tell a far more complicated story. A truly great civilization doesn't need self-serving myths to manufacture its prestige.