@jacksantucci As the number of authors expand, the number of potential referees should respond proportionally. However, the number of people I know personally has expanded less so I do send a larger fraction of referee requests to people whose work I know less well.
@jacksantucci I am just finishing 10 years as EIC of JDE. I do not think it is demonstrably harder. My yield on referees has been roughly constant even as the number of papers submitted increased by a factor of 3.
@YujungHwang3 Years ago I would tell students not to use a procedure they didn't fully understood or couldn't code. Of course, overtime we tended to be more trusting of packages and the theory underlying them. It saves time, but we lost something too. Seems like that rule should apply here.
@YanagizawaD Years ago I would tell students not to use a procedure they didn't fully understood or couldn't code. Of course, overtime we tended to be more trusting of packages and the theory underlying them. It saved a lot of time but we lost something too. History does tend to rhyme.
@JohnHCochrane Comments tend to be a lot of work and may be low impact. But every paper is in a way a comment on the literature and I have had some success in asking authors to turn "comments" into good "short papers" that can then go through a normal review process.
@paulnovosad I asked chatgpt if there had been any useful comments on the original article. It pointed to the datacolada post. I think serious adjudication increases the incentives for quality replications; it is not clear the "comment" approach does that. AI can then take it from there.
@paulnovosad I would consider them for the JDE. We do not publish comments per se or condition on whether the paper overturns the previous result. We do ask that the paper make it clear why the question is worth reexamining in a different frame or setting, given current knowledge.
@leightjessica I have been looking into this issue at the JDE. I think we can improve instructions and do a better job of explaining how linked and non-linked tables and figures are treated. I'd like to see it modified to accept subdirectories. Other suggestions from the hive?
@JustinSandefur @marcfbellemare @eeshani_kandpal @thom_katherina Interesting paper but if I am reading it right the .03 is a transfer elasticity in Table 3 not an income elasticity. Divide by the transfer share of income (.1 to .2) to compare it with previous estimates--so .15 to .3.
I am not sure what possessed me to get an extended warranty on my refrigerator purchased in 2019 but my experience with @New_Leaf_SC after my KitchenAid was "condemned" last month has been incredibly frustrating.
Brown grad student Henrique Pita Barros tests a low-cost intervention to connect displaced persons and members of their host community in Mozambique https://t.co/fF7gipn50V