@AhmedSheriffdin 1- I was questioning that assumption that assumption. What is the evidence for it?
2- What is worship here? Is it any act done with the belief of independence from Allah?
@hashimiyy_@abdul_now@idkyihyef@AhmedSheriffdin@HarounKanj You claim "substance is essential" to meaning and you "know" the meaning of milk in Jannah. If the substance differs from this world, why call it milk? If the substance doesn't matter, then it isn’t "essential." You can’t hold both positions.
@AhmedSheriffdin 1- The post starts with a claim about their belief about those deities acting *OUTSIDE* the decree of Allah. What was the evidence presented for that claim?
2- Suppose they believed those idols did NOT act outside the decree of Allah, does that make them pure monotheists?
@hashimiyy_@abdul_now@idkyihyef@AhmedSheriffdin@HarounKanj Thanks for this, but that does not solve the problem. Every single word you mentioned in that definition is "habitual" not "rationally necessary". So what are the *essential conditions* required to preserve calling this liquid "milk"?
@hashimiyy_@abdul_now@idkyihyef@AhmedSheriffdin@HarounKanj I read the post and did not find the answer, you provided a definition that I'm questioning. If there is sth that had all the properties of cow milk but it was created directly by Allah without being secreted from a mammary gland, can you still call it "milk"?