Walking away from the Chinese market would actually have very little financial impact on Kylian Mbappé. His endorsement deal with Xiaohongshu is reportedly worth around €2 million, while his deals with Mengniu, Eastroc Beverage, and other Chinese brands amount to only a few million dollars combined.
Even if he were to withdraw from the Chinese market entirely, he would only be giving up a few million dollars. Meanwhile, Forbes estimates Mbappé's annual earnings in 2026 at approximately $100 million.
In other words, the Chinese market accounts for only about 5% of his total annual income. It's simply absurd to suggest that the Chinese Communist Party has any significant financial leverage over him.
Judging by the political topics you choose to discuss, both on the international internet and on platforms within China's Great Firewall, you display a clear bias toward the political positions of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP).
What's more, you are quite skillful in selecting topics where even an ostensibly objective and neutral discussion ends up supporting the CCP's narrative, such as the riots in Paris.
Yet when it comes to issues such as China's social security system, the results of the U.S. midterm elections, or the allegations surrounding Jensen Huang's supposed spy lover, you either remain completely silent or express views that align with the CCP's position.
Take, for example, the controversy over Mbappé calling Mao Zedong a dictator. You cannot discuss this issue on Chinese social media platforms, but on Twitter, your position is clearly sympathetic to the CCP.
In fact, your situation is remarkably similar to Elon Musk's. Neither of you displayed any obvious political alignment when you had no business interests in China. But once you established business interests there, you began exhibiting subtle political biases that most people would find difficult to detect.
Judging by your selective engagement with political issues, I don't believe you are unaware of what the CCP is really like, or of what the historical record and contemporary political realities actually reveal about China and the wider world.
That is precisely why I find your behavior so hypocritical and driven by self-interest.
You clearly have plenty of other opportunities to earn an income. It's simply that, under your current circumstances, this particular arrangement serves your interests best when you weigh the costs against the benefits.
And your carefully calculated choice of political topics serves another purpose: it allows you to maintain your credibility and preserve the option of easily reintegrating into the Western world should you eventually decide to stop profiting from your business interests in China.
In other words, you appear to be carefully balancing the financial benefits of accommodating the CCP today against the need to preserve your reputation and opportunities in the West tomorrow.
What evidence do you have to support the claim that Mao Zedong acted out of good intentions when he committed all these acts?
I have read Li Rui's diaries and the memoirs of Mao Zedong's personal physician.
I am also familiar with Mao's long history of political campaigns and persecution: from the purge of alleged members of the Anti-Bolshevik League (AB League) in Jinggangshan, to the Yan'an Rectification Movement, to the Great Leap Forward, which depleted China's grain reserves.
Then came the Anti-Rightist Campaign of 1957, when Mao deliberately lured intellectuals into speaking out, only to turn around and persecute them. This was followed by the Great Chinese Famine, during which approximately 40 million people starved to death despite generally favorable hydrological and climatic conditions.
Liu Shaoqi warned Mao, "When people resort to cannibalism, history will record both your name and mine." Yet Mao subsequently had Liu politically destroyed, and Liu eventually died as a result of persecution.
Then came the Cultural Revolution, during which so many scholars who had returned to China after studying or working abroad were persecuted to death. For example:
Zhao Jiuzhang: Earned his doctorate from the University of Berlin in Germany. After prolonged political persecution and public denunciations, he died by suicide in 1968.
Yao Tongbin: Earned his doctorate from the University of Birmingham in the United Kingdom. He was beaten to death on June 8, 1968.
Rao Yutai: A physicist who studied in the United States. He died by suicide on October 16, 1968, following political persecution.
Zhang Zongsui: Earned his doctorate from the University of Cambridge in the United Kingdom. He died on June 30, 1969. University historical records attribute his death to political persecution.
Jian Bozan: Studied at the University of California in the United States. He and his wife died by suicide in December 1968.
Fu Lei: Studied in France. He and his wife died by suicide on September 3, 1966.
Lao She: Taught and lectured in the United Kingdom and the United States. After being subjected to public humiliation and political denunciations, he drowned himself in a lake on August 24, 1966.
Fu Lehuan: Earned his doctorate from the University of London in the United Kingdom. After political persecution and public denunciations, he died by suicide by drowning in 1966.
Chen Mengjia: Taught and conducted research at the University of Chicago in the United States. He died by suicide on September 3, 1966, following political persecution.
Wang Chongmin: Conducted academic research in France and the United States. Unable to endure the persecution any longer, he died by suicide on April 16, 1975.
Yu Dayin: Studied at the University of Oxford and other institutions in the United Kingdom. She died by suicide on August 25, 1966, after being subjected to political denunciations.
What I see is a clear and consistent pattern throughout Mao's political career: a willingness to employ any means necessary to preserve his own absolute power, regardless of the human cost.
So how is it that, in your interpretation, Mao's underlying intentions suddenly become benevolent?
On what basis can you possibly argue that all of this was driven by good intentions?
Honestly, I really envy civilized countries like yours. Maybe we could become online friends.
The problem with China is that its ancient history has created a deeply ingrained inertia toward centralization. People in positions of authority, like teachers, also enjoy a natural privilege of power over students.
There are many reasons for this, and I’ve actually posted a thread on Twitter explaining the situation.
My English is actually pretty terrible, especially when it comes to grammar.
Back in school, I was bullied by my teachers—my Chinese teacher said my Chinese was bad, and my English teacher said my English was bad.
Luckily, in real-world communication, grammar isn't actually that strict.
The CCP is an authoritarian government that has long sought to blur the line between the ruling party and the nation in its domestic propaganda. However, the CCP is merely a political party within China and does not represent the Chinese people, as it was not brought to power through legitimate elections.
In the eyes of the Chinese people, the concept of "China" is far closer to a 5,000-year-old civilization than to the current regime. Unfortunately, far too many people domestically have been brainwashed by the party's closed-loop propaganda; they are unaware of the outside world and know even less about the sheer amount of wrongdoing this party has committed.
As for the debt crisis, I am simply one of the few ordinary Chinese citizens who see the reality clearly, so I cannot predict exactly what the CCP government will do. However, under the Mundell-Fleming impossible trinity, the CCP has chosen exchange rate control and an independent monetary policy, meaning capital in mainland China cannot flow freely across borders. Consequently, they are likely to enforce strict exchange rate controls while printing even more currency.
In fact, based on my own estimates, China's current M2 money supply is roughly 1.5 times that of the United States. You can imagine just how crazy the CCP's money printing has been. Yet, due to strict capital controls and the collapse of state-led consumption under the heavy burden of debt, the domestic economy is trapped in severe weak consumption. The vast majority of people lack secure disposable income to spend, and even those with savings deposit their money in banks to hedge against future risks. As a result, China is currently mired in deep deflation.
I also worry that if the CCP finds its public finances completely unsustainable, it might choose to invade and plunder Taiwan to solve its internal crisis—naturally under the slogan of "reclaiming lost territory." Even though the CCP has surrendered far more land to other countries, domestic censorship suppresses those historical facts and focuses exclusively on Taiwan to incite historical hatred. Naturally, the general public only knows about the Taiwan issue, and looking around, a vast number of people even believe that attacking Taiwan is a righteous cause.
As for myself, I am currently planning to leave this country, though the journey ahead remains difficult.