Let me make this absolutely clear on behalf of Muslims. We are not against this protest and we are not against students holding the government accountable but we are against Muslims becoming part of this movement because for us, the risk far outweighs the reward.
Yes, Muslim students take NEET, education matters to us, we study in the same colleges, aspire to become doctors and suffer from paper leaks just like everyone else. The difference is not in how much we are affected but in how the state responds to us. Most liberals fail to understand that your identity as a Hindu offers a degree of protection that our identity as Muslims simply does not.
You can attend a protest, raise slogans and challenge the government without facing the same level of suspicion, whereas we don't even have to participate. Merely standing nearby, watching from a distance or finding ourselves in the vicinity can be enough to get us detained or treated as criminals.
You should continue your struggle because at this stage, only you have the social and political space to sustain it and bring about meaningful change. We genuinely hope you succeed. We'll amplify your voices, support your demands and cheer you on from a distance because that is the only form of participation that doesn't expose us to the same risks.
Our presence on the ground may even end up hurting your movement because the authorities are far more willing to use force when Muslims become visible. Instead of strengthening your cause, our involvement can become the excuse they use to justify a harsher crackdown, which makes it a loss for us and for you.
That is why I believe Muslims should stay away from these protests. If you genuinely want your movement to succeed, convince Muslim protesters to return home instead of encouraging them to stay. This is your battle to fight and I sincerely hope you win it.
For more than a decade, many of you looked away while we resisted with whatever limited resources we had. Now you've finally recognised the nature of the system you're confronting and you've chosen to fight it. Let us step back while you carry this movement forward because iin the current environment, our participation creates more risks than opportunities.
When this struggle is over and genuine change arrives, we'll stand together to rebuild what has been damaged and work towards a better future, but until then, fight your battle and send our people back to their homes.
Why do we keep spending all our energy proving we’re “good enough” instead of building our own community?
Imagine if we invested the same time into education, scholarships, legal aid, businesses, and uplifting the underprivileged among us.
The brutality unleashed by the police on protesting students near Jantar Mantar is deeply disturbing. Yet, for many of us, it painfully revives the memories of an even darker chapter—the horrific assault on students at Jamia Millia Islamia and Aligarh Muslim University in December 2019.
Inside university campuses, students were chased, mercilessly beaten, and subjected to violence that seemed intended not merely to disperse a protest, but to break their bodies and spirits. Those haunting images remain etched in our collective memory.
To add to the injustice, the committee constituted to investigate the incident eventually gave the police a clean chit, leaving countless students and citizens feeling that accountability had once again been denied.
A democracy cannot thrive when students are treated as enemies for raising their voices. Campuses should be places of learning and debate—not sites of fear and brutality.
so many contexts in which this one can be used and its just so beautifully written,
“Kuch to khizaan hai baais e barbaadi e chaman
Aur kuch baaghbaan ka haath bhi isme zaroor hai”