🚨Ginamit ang Kaso ng Tatay ni Chel Against Him?! Pia Cayetano vs. Chel Diokno Showdown
Senator-Judge Pia Cayetano came in super hot, looking like she’s low-key auditioning to be the head of VP Sara’s defense squad.
She really brought out the dramatic legal jargon at pasigaw-sigaw pa about an unconstitutional “general search warrant" just because the prosecution wants to subpoena VP Sara Duterte’s bank, BIR, and AMLC records.
Pia also cited the landmark Stonehill v. Diokno case — literally invoking Atty. Chel Diokno’s own dad, former Justice Secretary Jose W. Diokno — just to argue na "fishing expedition" daw ang tumingin sa 20-years worth of financial records without witness testimony first.
🌷What Pia Cayetano actually said:
“A subpoena cannot be used as a fishing expedition. The Constitution requires that any compulsory process must particularly describe the records sought based on foundational evidence already presented. Without that, you are essentially asking this court to issue a general warrant — which is strictly prohibited under our Constitution."
☘️Chel Diokno’s Answers
But Atty. Chel Diokno stayed unbothered, calm, and collected, and gave a total breakdown on basic law.
Sabi nya:
1. A court subpoena ordering banks to submit documents is NOT a search warrant. Very invasive ang search warrant. Sa subpoena, walang physical intrusion or nanggugulo sa bahay, which makes Pia's general search warrant drama and Stonehill v. Diokno flex is not applicable.
2. How is it a "fishing expedition" when the request is SPECIFIC? It specifically targets the bank, BIR, and AMLC records of VP Sara and her husband. Everything directly aligns with Article II (unexplained wealth and SALN discrepancies)!
3. Under R.A. 1405 (Bank Secrecy Law), bank deposits are confidential *except* under specific conditions. Chel reminded the tribunal na the text of the law explicitly lists “impeachment cases” as an exception.
4. Chel cited the 2012 Corona trial, where the Senate routinely subpoenaed historical bank records. Chel even cited transcripts showing that Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano (Pia's own brother!) argued back then that pre-term bank records were vital "opening evidence" to uncover the truth.
🔸My Opinion:
Pia really tried to weaponize Chel's own family legacy against him, pero na-lecturan lang siya on the difference between respecting privacy and hiding paper trails of public funds.
If Pia wants to lawyer so hard for Sara, she should just ditch her senator-judge robe, step down from the dais, and sit directly at the defense table
Ayan na! Unti unti ng lumalabas ang kulay nya. Kitang kita sa reaksyon ng mukha nya na nandidiri sya sa mga supporters nya.😂 akala kasi talaga ng mga DDS binibigyan sila ng importansya ng mga Duterte e. Huuuyy mga tanga! TAE lang ang tingin nila sa inyo.
DUTERTE FATHER-DAUGHTER SKIPS HEARINGS
In a striking parallel, Vice President Sara Duterte has opted to skip her House impeachment proceedings, while her father, former president Rodrigo Duterte has also waived his appearance at the International Criminal Court (ICC) Appeals Chamber session on Wednesday.
Former president Duterte will remain in the Hague after the ICC denied his appeal over jurisdiction.
Meanwhile, the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) revealed in the House impeachment proceedings that it had flagged P6.77 billion in covered transaction reports and suspicious transaction reports involving Vice President Sara Duterte and her husband, Atty. Manases Carpio.
'DI TUGMA ANG HALAGA SA SALN NI VP SARA VS. HALAGA NG MGA TRANSAKSYON?
Sa impeachment hearing, pinagbangga ang datos ng cash at net worth mula sa SALN ni VP Sara Duterte sa halaga ng covered transactions and suspicious transactions ng kaniyang bank account base sa datos ng AMLC.
Hindi umano tugma ang halagang iniulat ng bise kumpara sa perang dumaloy sa kaniyang bank account.
Basahin ang kaugnay na ulat: https://t.co/pK9YEYeXgq
LIVE UPDATES: https://t.co/AQO83sJMFP
Meme @vicegandako, I love you but calling Raven “lalaki” on national tv is not sitting right with me. Misgendering shouldn’t be normalized, especially in front of a wide audience where it may reinforce that disrespecting transpeople is acceptable. #ShowtimeGotYou