A client walked in with a demand draft for the full loan amount...the bank refused to take it. He was shocked. Like most borrowers, he believed he could pay the bank and save his house right up to the auction day.
@barandbench Can’t really blame the homebuyers. They are paying EMIs on flats that are nowhere, RERA and NCLT haven’t helped much. So they keep coming to the SC.
@sharmanagendar He was appointed HC Judge in 2001 (BJP Govt). He was made CJ in 2013 (Congress) and finally he was elevated to SC in 2017 (BJP Govt). Now, make your point.
@LawBeatInd@rakesh1dwivedi@LegalTalwar Fair question. But a Collegium member’s objection goes nowhere, dissents are never published. That’s exactly why the minutes should be public, so nobody has to wait for retirement to be heard.
@LawBeatInd Electoral Bonds shows he could rule against the Govt. But Justice Kaul’s point is about appointments, not judgments. One judgment is one case. Who sits on the bench decides thousands of them.
@LiveLawIndia@1Simranbakshi Agree with Justice Oka. As long as cases can be moved from bench to bench by hand, every reassignment will be questioned...we’re seeing it now with Justice Kaul. A published, computer-run roster protects the CJI as much as the litigant.
@barandbench@RitwikinCourt Disparity in bail between co-accused is a real problem, but the fix is to correct that order on appeal, not take a whole sessions division off the case. That sends a message to every district judge in Haryana. Right that the SC stayed it.
@AankhiGM One thing she and I fully agree on...publish the collegium minutes and the dissents. Then nobody has to wait for a retired judge’s book to know how our judges were chosen.
Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul’s book says CJI Chandrachud was taking Govt’s view on names before the collegium even discussed them. If that’s true, this isn’t gossip about judges. It goes to who decides who sits on our constitutional courts. A few thoughts...
@AankhiGM None of this means the collegium is fine. It isn’t. Judges picking judges behind closed doors was always going to end like this. But handing it back to the executive is worse...look at EC. The UK moved to an independent commission back in 2006. We should learn from that.