“Regarding the Use of AI-Generated Images in a Dr. STONE Anime Collaboration” (2/2)
When a manga adaptation becomes an anime, major publishers do not simply act on behalf of the copyright holders in exercising their rights.
They become members of the production committee, invest in production costs, and take part in producing the anime.
I don't know whether that was also the case when Dr. STONE was adapted into an anime.
However, that is how things work with many productions, so it may have been the case with Dr. STONE as well.
I want to emphasize once again that I simply don't know.
In any case, publishers generally have the right to be involved in the production and business of an anime.
That is why I sent your tweet links to my contact at Jump.
I do not believe that the original creator is the owner of the anime.
Here is the principle I follow when it comes to my work:
The owners of an anime are the creators who made it.
Is the original creator a co-owner?
Well, legally, or according to the terms of a contract, perhaps.
But when it comes to the very nature of art, I believe that the creators of a derivative work are its owners.
As a fellow creator, I believe it is my responsibility to respect them and support them so that they can create their work freely.
The same applies to the business surrounding derivative works.
It is their business.
An anime is not made to suit the original creator's tastes, to make them feel good, or to fill them with pride.
All that money, all that effort, and the dedication of so many artists are not invested simply to make the original creator happy.
The creators of the anime are the ones who should take pride in their work.
The viewers are the ones who should enjoy it and feel happy.
And most of the revenue belongs to the people who made the anime.
Of course, the original creator may receive some money and may also be excited to see their work adapted.
But those are not the goals of making an anime.
They are simply side effects.
That is why an anime or a film can sometimes hurt the original creator deeply, or even make them feel profoundly angry.
In my opinion, that is simply something we have to accept.
I do not want the creators of the anime or films based on my work to simply reproduce the original in order to spare me from being hurt.
I want them to ignore my feelings and my position, and to exercise their creativity to the fullest.
As long as I am the original creator, I will hold firmly to this position.
Even if they fail, even if I become angry or sad, I will protect their freedom as artists.
Rather than telling them to be careful, I will tell them to go ahead and take risks. Even to fail.
Seeing Dr. STONE characters generated by AI and used commercially certainly brings back very painful memories for me.
As I said in my previous post, I don't like it either.
But this is an anime Dr. STONE collaboration.
I have to put into practice the very principle I want to protect: a world in which creators are respected.
I have to respect the anime creators and the company behind the production.
Therefore, the central issue is whether the anime production company approved the collaboration partner's use of AI-generated images.
If it did, then I have no choice but to respect that decision.
Whatever I feel personally is something I must set aside.
And when I read the collaboration partner's statement, it seemed to suggest that this was a matter of having to press a button.
It sounds as though the anime production company had not approved it.
TRULY, WHAT A STRANGE WORLD WE LIVE TODAY.
A world where you have to press a button to prevent something from happening.
In this world, you press a button when you want something to happen. But when you don't want something to happen, you should simply have to do nothing.
Anyway, after sending your tweet links to Jump, I have no idea what happened next.
Neither Jump, the anime production company, nor the collaboration partner has informed me of any response or position they may have taken.
And I believe that is how it should be.
They might choose to do something out of consideration for the original creator, but it is not something I should demand or expect.
The anime business belongs to the anime industry.
However, all of this is entirely separate from the actions of readers who cherish the original work, its spirit, and its soul.
Readers who protest because they believe the original work has been damaged have every right to do so.
You have every right to say that you want to see an anime that properly respects the original work and brings the characters you love to life.
You have every right to protest when a business fails to respect the original work and the life of its creator.
These are rights that belong to you, not to me.
Just as the creators of an anime are its owners, consumers are the owners of its reception and appreciation.
It is not only admirable but truly extraordinary when readers care so deeply about manga, mangaka, creativity, and the human spirit that they become angry and speak out against AI-generated content.
I believe it is my responsibility to respect the creativity and business of the anime production company.
I am prepared to endure the pain, anger, and sadness that may come with doing so.
Respecting the extraordinary and remarkable love readers have for manga and human creativity is another one of my responsibilities. It is also my duty.
I promise that I will endure even greater pain, anger, and sadness for all of you.
It is also my duty to be moved by you, to thank you, and to swear that I will repay you through my creative work, forever.
And so, to everyone who expressed their anger over this collaboration:
I was truly moved.
Thank you so much, from the bottom of my heart.
I, Boichi, will repay you forever through creative works made with the human heart and human labor.
“Regarding the Use of AI-Generated Images in a Dr. STONE Anime Collaboration” (1/2)
Recently, we were faced with a situation in which a company collaborating with the Dr. STONE anime used AI-generated images in its advertising.
Many of you who love Dr. STONE on X took this issue seriously and spoke up about it.
The collaborating company also issued an official apology.
All of this was made possible by you. Yes, Truly!
Your presence, and the love you have for manga, mangaka, and the works themselves, is what made me decide to share my artwork on X again after eleven months.
https://t.co/51zorAqObJ
You are also the reason things are different now from the days when the internet was a jungle.
You are people who are willing to stand up against anything in the world to protect works created through human lives, human effort, and human dedication.
I sincerely thank you.
Thank you so much!
However, separate from my gratitude and the way this particular incident was handled, I do not oppose the use of AI by companies collaborating with anime productions.
To be clear, not opposing something does not mean supporting it in any way.
I am neither in favor of it nor against it.
My position is entirely personal and has absolutely nothing to do with the views of Inagaki-sensei, the original story writer of Dr. STONE, or Shonen Jump and Shueisha.
That is why, this time as well, all I did was send links to your tweets to my editor at Jump.
I made no other comments and took no further action.
Why do I hold this position?
And why do I refrain from making comments or taking a stance?
Why, when I once went so far as to stop taking medication for a chronic illness and give up meals in protest against social media companies' unauthorized AI training on artists' work and their use of it, do I take such a different position on this particular incident?
There are two reasons I want to share with you.
First, when it comes to collaborations involving my own works, if there is an agreement and prior consultation regarding the use of AI, I do not oppose it.
As I have said many times, I like AI technology and have an optimistic outlook on its potential.
What I do not like is being robbed and humiliated.
I do not like theft or humiliation, whether it is committed by a corporation or an individual, regardless of what technology is involved.
That is why, if there is an agreement and mutual understanding, I do not oppose it.
But that does not mean I like it.
I may not like it, but I do not oppose it either.
Collaboration businesses do not exist to serve my personal wishes.
A work is like a child and it does not exist to live for the sake of its parents.
It lives its own life.
And sometimes, things happen that its parents may not like.
Collaborations are undertaken for the benefit of the collaborating companies.
So, if someone asks me whether they can use AI for a collaboration involving one of my works, my answer would be, "I really, really don't like it."
But that is not the same as opposing it.
The second reason is even more important.
The company involved in the AI-generated images that sparked this controversy is not a collaborator on the original manga.
It is a collaborator on the anime adaptation.
As the original manga creator, I have no intention of taking a position or making any demands regarding this matter.
Once again, I want to emphasize that this is my own personal position and has nothing to do with Inagaki-sensei's views.
Furthermore, Shueisha and Jump are entitled to express their own views and make their own demands regarding collaborations involving the anime.
This is because publishers and magazines do far more than simply administer rights and share copyright revenue.
To be continued.