The fact that Confederate flags are still appearing in seminary dorm rooms is, in fact, deeply concerning.
Should a USSR flag flown by a Russian-American seminarian be tolerated because he says it's "his culture and history"? Of course not. Because it represents much more.
This doesn't mean Boxie is accusing Francis and Leo of racism.
Had Clarence Thomas been ordained he would just now be at bishop retirement age.
If he left seminary because of white seminarians rejoicing over the death of MLK Jr., how many more may have left over similar things?
I think if we give Bishop Boxie the most charitable read here, the racism he refers to is at the bottom of the funnel, preventing African American young men from becoming priests and therefore being part of the candidate pool for bishops. (The alternative would be that the Vatican is racist, since they pick bishops.) But of course there are just not very many African American Catholics as a percentage of Catholics overall, and I believe others have run the numbers and shown that among bishops the representation is very close to what you'd expect based on the share in the Catholic population, and actually higher than the share of priests.
The state of female discourse especially online since the overturning of Roe just boils down to waging unprecedented levels of total war against nature, teleology, existence, and God
@Gawain90@trad_west_ How does this rule out racism (historical or present) as a factor? It's like saying that the reason why most of the UK are not Catholic is because they are mostly Atheist and other denominations. Well yes but that hardly asks why they refuse to convert. Lets not be silly.
@TLM_Ryan@CarsNCatholics@vaticanaccess@WashArchdiocese Good thing I'm not necessarily doing so. I am calling for this to be properly studied. Refusing a proper study of it would be (at best) an indicator of intellectual laziness.
@TLM_Ryan@CarsNCatholics@vaticanaccess@WashArchdiocese And it's a worthwhile and reasonable assurance. However, I think it's best to not base support for propositions on mere "assurances", as reasonable as they may be.
@TLM_Ryan@CarsNCatholics@vaticanaccess@WashArchdiocese No worries. From what I can gather you do have some videos that (at the very least) touch upon the population changes (percentage wise) since Vatican 2, which is still valuable, so thanks.
@CarsNCatholics@vaticanaccess@WashArchdiocese@TLM_Ryan Thanks, I'll take a look. Does he actually properly rule out, as insignificant, racism as a cause? Or is the reasoning merely "Modernism happened here. Therefore modernism is the sole significant cause"? Because if that is the case, then the question remains unanswered properly.