I just fundamentally, philosophically disagree with this. This is product-oriented critique of what's actually more of an entertainment and art form, and mainstream games crit should reflect a much, much wider range of opinions and perspectives (and, where applicable, scores).
A huge thing about the experience of playing TLOU that the show can't really capture is how haunted with the echoes of lives lived the world is. Here lived a baseball fan, things like that, everywhere in the ruined world.