There’s something almost endearing about watching someone so utterly convinced of their own intellectual superiority while displaying such an impressive inability to distinguish facts from personal resentment. You’ve managed to dress up a rather spectacular tantrum as rugby analysis, apparently hoping nobody would notice the complete absence of objectivity. How terribly embarrassing for you. Nobody is defending foul play, darling, but apparently distinguishing individual misconduct from collective guilt requires a level of critical thinking you’ve yet to demonstrate.
And calling the 2019 World Cup a ‘cakewalk’ because it doesn’t suit your narrative? How convenient. South Africa beat the hosts, Japan, defeated Wales in the semifinal and comprehensively dismantled England in the final. Funny how those achievements suddenly become insignificant when the Springboks are involved.
As for your precious 2011–2015 All Blacks, nobody needs to diminish their achievements to acknowledge South Africa’s four World Cups. Perhaps it’s time you learned to do the same.
The real toddler tantrum here is watching a grown man desperately rewrite rugby history because he can’t stand who keeps winning. 🙄
This is just plain dirty play. Nasty stuff from Marx. The Springboks on-field thuggery has been creeping upward since 2025 in this second Erasmus era.
- Wiese 4 weeks for head butt vs Italy
- Etzebeth 12 weeks for eye gouge vs Wales
- De Jager 4 weeks for dangerous shot vs France
- Wiese again 4 weeks for dangerous clean out.
They’ve realised that matching the 2011-15 All Blacks is off the table so effectively decided to go down swinging. Toddler tantrum type stuff.
And always remember: Rassie’s one World Cup was the cakewalk. Japan, Italy, cooked Wales and England. Jacques got the tough one.
And that’s precisely the problem. When even former Irish internationals can acknowledge Rassie’s concerns, surely it’s time World Rugby started listening instead of treating every question as an attack. The apparent fear of speaking openly says plenty about the lack of trust in the system. Accountability and consistency shouldn’t depend on who’s asking the questions. Hopefully this whole debacle finally forces some much-needed change. 🇿🇦
@WorldRugby@mark_keohane@Brendennel, how spectacularly embarrassing that the actual footage is available, yet some still seem incapable of distinguishing a legitimate question from an accusation.
Rassie questioned why certain incidents weren’t picked up by the TMO and whether the problem lay with the technology or the review process. He did NOT accuse anyone of match-fixing. Yet somehow, that is the narrative being pushed.
And while we’re discussing accountability, what about the Irish journalist whose question prompted Rassie’s response in the first place? Why is the context of that exchange being conveniently overlooked? Rassie didn’t manufacture the discussion out of thin air. He was responding to a question put to him by the media.
Apparently, journalists can ask provocative questions, selectively interpret the answers and generate headlines, but when Rassie responds or raises legitimate concerns, he’s suddenly the problem. How wonderfully convenient.
@WorldRugby, where is the consistency? Where is the transparency? Why does questioning officiating become such a scandal when Rassie Erasmus is involved?
And to those with influential media platforms, perhaps familiarise yourselves with the difference between asking a question, expressing concern and making an accusation before publicly misrepresenting someone’s words.
The footage is available. The context matters. The double standards deserve scrutiny.
Correct the record. Hold everyone to the same standards, including the journalists who help create these controversies. Surely basic fairness and journalistic integrity aren’t unreasonable expectations?
@mark_keohane@WorldRugby@Brendennel here is the clip. Rassie asked a question He never said it is MF He even asked if it's technology not good enough. Please correct this on your massive platforms or not. Your choice @BadIngram write your way please
You declare your opinions to be ‘facts’, provide absolutely nothing to substantiate them, then resort to calling everyone ‘shitty losers’ while lecturing others about maturity. The irony is clearly lost on you. And dragging John McEnroe into it doesn’t magically strengthen your argument. If your claims are factual, prove them. Otherwise, you’re simply demonstrating the very petulance you’re so desperately trying to attribute to others. Quite the embarrassing little performance, KW.
SPOT ON! 👏👏 The hypocrisy is so glaring it’s practically blinding!
Johnny Sexton approaches a match official after a game he wasn’t even playing in, calls him a ‘fucking disgrace’, and ultimately serves a reduced suspension. Meanwhile, Rassie questions missed infringements, officiating consistency and decisions affecting player safety, and receives a six-match ban.
And we’re supposed to believe there’s absolutely nothing worth questioning here? Give me a fucking break! 🙄
Yes, their disciplinary circumstances were different, but that doesn’t automatically make every difference in punishment beyond criticism.
The moment Rassie opens his mouth, the rugby world erupts in outrage. Yet when others publicly criticise or directly abuse officials, suddenly everyone’s desperate to explain the mitigating circumstances.
Nobody is suggesting officials deserve abuse or that Rassie should be above disciplinary rules. We’re demanding TRANSPARENCY, FAIRNESS and CONSISTENCY.
And the most fucking laughable part? The same people preaching respect for officials are often the first to ridicule, insult and question them when decisions go against their own teams.
The selective outrage is absolutely astounding. You couldn’t manufacture this level of hypocrisy if you fucking tried! 😂🇿🇦
Rugby fascism is when Johnny Sexton walks up to a ref in a game he’s not even playing and calls a him “a fucking disgrace” and gets half of Rassie’s ban.
Like most acts of fascism, the perpetrators & beneficiaries tell you there’s nothing to see here until it becomes undeniable.
It must be exhausting trying to sound like the moral authority on rugby while displaying such a spectacular lack of self-awareness. Perhaps master the art of practising what you preach before delivering another sermon from that imaginary moral high ground of yours. 🙄
Oh, Stephen, how terribly generous of you to offer advice from that towering pedestal of selective outrage. 😂 How fortunate we are to have someone who can declare Rassie a disgrace while simultaneously crowning Galthié a ‘warrior’ for criticising officiating. Apparently, the difference between courage and whinging depends entirely on which country’s passport you hold.
And nobody is disputing the result, Stephen. We’re questioning the consistency of officiating and accountability. Those are separate issues, although I appreciate that distinguishing between them might interfere with your preferred narrative.
As for your little dig about intelligence and vocabulary, it’s rather amusing watching someone attempt intellectual superiority while resorting to playground insults.
Perhaps try applying the same standards to everyone before delivering another sermon on sporting integrity. The hypocrisy is becoming more entertaining than your rugby commentary. 🙄🇿🇦
@WorldRugby
Sonny. Here is some advice. SA lost the game, they didn't deserve to win, Rassie's reaction was a disgrace and he was lucky not to get a long ban, I don't care about clicks though you should have as no-one what you say, it seems, about anything. Galthie is a warrior. not a whinger Just re-read if some of my words are too long
Well, congratulations, Sherlock. 😂 You’ve managed to discover that professional athletes in 2026 benefit from 31 years of advances in sports science, nutrition and conditioning. Truly groundbreaking stuff. Someone alert the Nobel committee.
Of course today’s players are faster, stronger and better conditioned. That’s called progress, not proof that the 1995 Springboks were inferior for their era.
And claiming refereeing has ‘never been better’ while conveniently dismissing legitimate concerns about consistency is equally laughable. More scrutiny doesn’t automatically mean better officiating.
Perhaps learn the difference between progress, consistency and historical greatness before attempting to lecture everyone else. 🙄🇿🇦
@WorldRugby - Need I say more…
The standard of refereeing has never been higher.
The only thing that has changed is the scrutiny it is under.
Today's Italian team would destroy the 1995 Springboks. The game has moved on. Its faster, stronger and more intricate.
Stop pretending things used to be better.
@shanclaire84@SierraCharlieBr@SimonZebo Thanks for the tag, Shan! ❤️👏 Funny how even a former Ireland international can acknowledge that Rassie has a point, yet some people still refuse to entertain the possibility. 😂 Credit to Simon Zebo for speaking his mind. 🇿🇦
Another one who thinks repeating ‘meltdown’ constitutes an intelligent argument. You do realise that questioning decisions and demanding consistency isn’t a meltdown, don’t you? Or is that distinction a little too complicated? South African supporters are perfectly entitled to challenge double standards, regardless of how uncomfortable that makes you.
And @WorldRugby, perhaps you’d care to notice how quickly legitimate questions about consistency are dismissed as ‘meltdowns’ whenever South Africans raise them. We’re constantly lectured about respect and accountability, yet apparently expecting those same standards to be applied equally is too much to ask.
Perhaps bring something factual to the discussion instead of recycling someone else’s playground insults. 🙄🇿🇦
@WorldRugby, perhaps you’d care to take a look at the extraordinary hypocrisy on display here. We’re repeatedly lectured about respecting rugby, controlling our language and maintaining standards, yet this is the sort of personal abuse directed at South African supporters for daring to question consistency and equal treatment.
Apparently, calling someone ‘evil’, ‘hate-filled’, a ‘loser’ and comparing people to ‘stuck pigs’ is perfectly acceptable when the target is a Springbok supporter.
So, World Rugby, are these standards supposed to apply equally to everyone, or does respect suddenly become optional depending on who’s on the receiving end?
We’re not asking for special treatment. We’re asking for consistency. Surely that shouldn’t be such a difficult concept to grasp. 🙄🇿🇦
@BadIngram What an evil, vitriolic, hate filled loser you are!!
You and other clowns like Rassie think you are all above the law when you open your big mouths and spout stupidity and arrogance, but when taken to task for it start whining like stuck pigs!
See ya loser!
You’ve confused having an opinion with having an argument. An easy mistake to make when you’re so spectacularly short of evidence. Nobody is questioning your right to an opinion. We’re questioning the rather embarrassing absence of anything remotely substantial to support it. You demand a lifetime ban, make sweeping accusations about Rassie, insult Springbok supporters, and then retreat behind ‘I’m entitled to my opinion’ when challenged. How wonderfully convenient. And judging by World Rugby’s handling of certain disciplinary matters, they appear perfectly capable of confusing personal opinions with impartial judgment themselves. As for someone throwing this magnificent little tantrum lecturing others about petulance, the irony is simply delicious. Perhaps when you’ve finished congratulating yourself on having an opinion, you could try substantiating it. Baby steps, KW. Baby steps.
You’ve managed to stumble upon the concept of previous disciplinary records and are now proudly presenting it as though you’ve uncovered some groundbreaking legal principle. How terribly exciting for you. 👏😂 Nobody disputed that previous offences can influence sanctions, sweetheart. But do enjoy your little moment. Now, perhaps explain how that automatically settles the question of proportionality between two different offences. Different charges, circumstances and disciplinary findings still matter. Consistency doesn’t mean identical punishments; it means applying standards fairly. And dismissing a factual response as a ‘dissertation’ doesn’t magically make your argument any more intelligent. 🙄
‘No, YOU’RE having a meltdown.’ What a devastating intellectual contribution. 😂 I challenged an argument with actual points. You’ve responded with a playground comeback and apparently think you’ve accomplished something. If you’ve got a factual counterargument, by all means, surprise me. Otherwise, thanks for demonstrating precisely why I made my original comment. 🙄
@MariusinDubai 😂😂 Marius, apparently a little common sense is enough to cause absolute chaos around here! And judging by some of these replies, it’s in desperately short supply. 🤣🇿🇦
How terribly sweet of you to pop in and demonstrate, with such unearned confidence, that intellectual subtlety really isn’t your strong suit. I appreciate that anything requiring a little critical thought must feel rather overwhelming, but confusing condescension with a lack of substance is quite the achievement, even by your standards.
Perhaps try addressing the actual arguments instead of distracting yourself with my appearance. Although, judging by that response, I can understand why discussing my hair is considerably easier for you.
@BadIngram There seems to be something wrong. Every time you reply, it's just niceties with no substance. Am I missing something? You look fantastic BTW. New haircut?
Oh, James, An All Blacks supporter using England’s victory over his own team as an excuse for South Africa winning the World Cup. How wonderfully desperate. 😂 England were apparently brilliant enough to demolish your precious All Blacks 19–7, but suddenly too exhausted to face the Springboks? How convenient. South Africa dismantled England 32–12. That’s not an excuse, that’s a result. Imagine being so desperate to discredit the Springboks that you’re celebrating the team that knocked you out. Four World Cups to three. Cope harder. 🇿🇦🏆🏆🏆🏆
Nice little trick lumping Australia and New Zealand together to make the numbers look respectable, Ben. 😂 OMG imagine having to combine entire continents just to manufacture a ‘dead heat’. South Africa has FOUR World Cups on its own, despite missing the first two tournaments. NZ needed nine attempts to win three, and Australia hasn’t touched the trophy since 1999. The Springboks have won FOUR of the EIGHT tournaments they’ve competed in and are the only nation to have won back-to-back titles twice. But sure, let’s play geographical gymnastics so everyone can pretend they’re keeping up. Shame, boet, when one country sits alone at the top of the mountain, no amount of creative accounting changes who’s king. 🇿🇦🏆🏆🏆🏆
The beautiful William Webb Ellis trophy is already down under in the southern hemisphere. But the real question is, will it leave in 2027? Australia & NZ have a combined 5 men’s World Cups. The Europe & Africa continents have 5 combined. It’s a dead heat!
At this point, Warry, I’m beginning to wonder whether either of them knows who’s actually steering the ship. Because the selective outrage, inconsistent standards and apparent lack of accountability at World Rugby are becoming an absolute embarrassment. Perhaps both gentlemen could start by remembering that South African rugby deserves the same respect and fair treatment as everyone else.
I see we’re still struggling with the rather basic concept of hypocrisy. Let me simplify it for you. You’re perfectly entitled to vilify Springbok supporters, Rassie Erasmus and anyone associated with South African rugby, but the moment we dare challenge your nonsense, suddenly we’re the problem? How terribly convenient. Apparently, free speech is a privilege reserved exclusively for you and your little echo chamber. The sheer arrogance of appointing yourselves the moral authority while behaving exactly as you accuse others of behaving is quite something. Do try to keep up with your own double standards. 🙄
@WorldRugby
World Rugby, pull your heads out of your arses and take a good, hard look at what’s happening! The relentless vilification of South Africans, our supporters, our players and our coach is becoming absolutely disgraceful.
We are sick and tired of the hostility, the selective outrage and the double standards. Criticising South Africans has practically become a spectator sport, while the same behaviour from others often receives nowhere near the same condemnation.
Where is the accountability for those spreading hatred and making sweeping accusations against an entire nation?
South Africans deserve the same respect, fairness and protection as everyone else. We will not be bullied, intimidated or silenced simply because we refuse to bow to the mob.
Enough is enough, World Rugby. Start showing some backbone and apply the same standards to EVERYONE! 🇿🇦
Oh, David, how terribly observant. You’ve managed to obsess over how an argument was written without disproving a single word of it. Perhaps when you’ve finished playing AI detective, you could attempt something genuinely impressive: challenging the actual facts. But I suppose that’s considerably harder than pointing at a screen.
Well, this is quite the masterpiece of selective reasoning. 😂 I must say, the confidence with which you’ve managed to misunderstand virtually every aspect of this situation is almost admirable. Almost. Let’s work through your little production, shall we? I’ll try to keep it simple.
Firstly, Rassie was responding to a question from an Irish journalist concerning Sam Prendergast’s disciplinary situation. He wasn’t wandering around making unsolicited declarations for your entertainment. I realise context can be a nuisance when you’re trying to manufacture outrage, but unfortunately, it still matters.
Secondly, your theatrical little ‘but the circumstances were different’ is particularly amusing. Different circumstances can warrant different assessments. That’s rather the point of considering context. Astonishing that something so elementary apparently requires explaining.
Thirdly, nobody is arguing that South Africans should be entitled to say absolutely anything without consequences. The issue is whether disciplinary standards are being applied consistently. I appreciate that fairness and freedom from consequences might sound interchangeable when you’re determined to misunderstand both, but I assure you they’re not.
Fourthly, your imaginary South African complaining about being ‘banned’ is another delightful invention. Questioning whether a sanction is proportionate or consistent isn’t the same as believing sanctions shouldn’t exist. One can accept accountability while scrutinising its application. Two thoughts at once. Quite ambitious, I know.
Fifthly, casually invoking Ben Smith’s name doesn’t magically transform this collection of assumptions into a coherent argument. If there’s a substantive point worth discussing, perhaps try presenting it rather than expecting everyone to be impressed by a name-drop.
And here’s the truly exquisite part: you’ve written both sides of an imaginary conversation, deliberately made one side sound ridiculous, and then congratulated yourself on your intellectual triumph. 😂
That’s a textbook straw man argument, dressed up as clever commentary.
Perhaps the next time you feel inspired to lecture an entire nation about rational discussion, you might consider actually engaging with its arguments rather than inventing more convenient ones.
Still, congratulations on winning a debate against yourself. I imagine the competition was absolutely fierce. 👏😂🇿🇦
Me: Wow, Rassie said something inappropriate!
🇿🇦: Dumpster Fire
Me: But the circumstances were different
🇿🇦: We say what we want
Me: You probably shouldn't
🇿🇦: I can't believe we got banned for saying what we want
.
I totally get what @bensmithrugby was talking about