BENEFICIAL BLOODSUCKING
"Making People Better: Saving Us from Ourselves Through Moral Enhancement"
Parker Crutchfield, Associate Professor, Dept. of Medical Ethics, Humanities, and Law at Western Michigan University
Blake Hereth, Assistant Professor, Dept. of Medical Ethics, Humanities, and Law at Western Michigan University
July 31, 2025
ABSTRACT
The bite of the lone star tick spreads alpha-gal syndrome (AGS), a condition whose only effect is the creation of a severe but nonfatal red meat allergy. Public health departments warn against lone star ticks and AGS, and scientists are working to develop an inoculation to AGS.
Herein, we argue that if eating meat is morally impermissible, then efforts to prevent the spread of tickborne AGS are also morally impermissible. After explaining the symptoms of AGS and how they are transmitted via ticks, we argue that tickborne AGS is a moral bioenhancer if and when it motivates people to stop eating meat.
We then defend what we call the Convergence Argument: If x-ing prevents the world from becoming a significantly worse place, doesn't violate anyone's rights, and promotes virtuous action or character, then x-ing is strongly pro tanto obligatory; promoting tickborne AGS satisfies each of these conditions. Therefore, promoting tickborne AGS is strongly pro tanto obligatory.
It is presently feasible to genetically edit the disease-carrying capacity of ticks. If this practice can be applied to ticks carrying AGS, then promoting the proliferation of tickborne AGS is morally obligatory.
cc: @trentloos
Source link:
https://t.co/DKsfm1Iu8v
Post by Brandon Luu, MD:
@KCBcapri79 @CorpsicleHearts @EndWokeness And your evidence to the contrary? Going back to Uvalde the shootings of children have been members of the LGBTQ community, or so they have claimed themselves.
@dom_lucre Im more conservative leaning, but a white dude. Few years ago when everyone was buying guns I stopped in a FFL in suburban PA. About 6 customers and I was the only white guy. Honestly warmed my heart seeing people exercise their rights. So no, it doesn't offend
@dsemenzcrim @IP_BMJ@NJGVRC Where exactly is the data showing increase in concealed carry to increase in gun violence? What's the definition of gun violence?