The GATES OF HELL SHALL NOT PREVAIL, a 🧵
You will often hear Roman Catholic apologists cite Matthew 16:18 "and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of Hades will not overcome it" as a prooftext for errors will not befall the Roman Catholic Church. Or does this refer to the salvation extended to members of Christ's Church? Lets see what the Early Church taught... 🧵/1
@Anevs23@Godsavedme4real What i find interesting is you seem to assert works as distinct from resistible grace enabled cooperation (RGEC).
And yet you appeal to James 2 to support RGEC. Which uses the term "works"
It seems you want to have your cake and eat it too
@Anevs23@Godsavedme4real I don't dismiss any of Christ's words.
I just don't pit them against each other. jesus never says you must persevere under resistible grace empowered cooperation.
that doesn't even make any sense one could arrive there.
@Anevs23@Godsavedme4real your understand of Gal 5:6 is errant and contradictory to the rest of scripture.
james being a different author is 100% relevant bc you can't just use him interchangeably with Paul and "his gospel" to try and undermine it
@Anevs23@Godsavedme4real there is no "biblical picture" that distinguishes some "initial justification" before God referring to a forgiveness of sins that can be forfeited.
we can discuss James 2 all you want but let's first dispense with the idea that anywhere else in Scripture is trust insufficient
@Anevs23@Godsavedme4real There are no soteriological implications because this is about a MAN declaring righteousness to other MEN through his works.
Youre ignoring the distinctly Jewish audience and verbiage that James starts with.
@Anevs23@Godsavedme4real James 2 is a completely different author and audience
And Galatians 5:6 is just a prooftext.
Jesus Christ is perfectly clear in all the gospel that belief, trust, is sufficient
@Anevs23@Godsavedme4real James 2 is pastoral exhortation not soteriological. If you want to go through the relevant part of the passage we can but lets not pretend like a document that didnt even have spaces has divinely inspired verse breaks.
@Anevs23@Godsavedme4real Nice try but your grace enabled obedience goes by a more simple name: works. Now lets look at Romans 3, 4 and 5
You've already said as much when you implied faith working through love is MORE than placing your trust in Christ
@Anevs23@Godsavedme4real Faith working through love does not mean you forfeit eternal life if you dont do X works or that it somehow contradicts all of scriptures witness that its faith, or belief that is the sole basis for the righteousness of God to be credited to us.
And yes scripture does separate
@Crucilore@ImprecatoryOne If Peter was talking about water, he wouldn't have had to specify that it is not the removal of dirt, which according to you is what the floodwaters did
@Anevs23@Godsavedme4real "expressed through"
The faith that works through agape is expressed in what we are literally told: faith.
To deem this as insufficient for justification is to fundamentally misunderstand faith, justification, and even grace.