Associate professor Loyola University Chicago, School of Communication - Program Director Center for Digital Ethics and Policy - Media Ethics and Law scholar
The most interesting part of the red card saga isn't the ruling. It's how differently Americans and Europeans process the idea that they might have been wronged.
Europeans are fundamentally different from Americans in one particular way: they expect life to be aggravating and at times unfair. It's just a fact of moving through the world. I joke that in Europe, the customer is always wrong. You didn't read the fine print. The only pharmacy in town is closed every other Tuesday for three hours, and even if the times weren't posted, that's still your problem. Too bad if you want the bill, because the waiter's on his union-mandated half-hour smoke break, and you're just going to have to wait.
To quote the great Mark Knopfler: sometimes you're the windshield, sometimes you're the bug. There's something freeing in that. Things are less in your control, so there's less angst in managing your expectations.
In America, things couldn't be more different. We simply can't accept a wrong left unrighted.
The flight attendant sneezed handing you a drink on your one-hour flight? 15,000 frequent flyer miles. Didn't like your appetizer? A replacement is on the way, and the whole course comes off the bill. There's a reason our interstates are lined with trial lawyer billboards.
Europeans have turned complaining into a continental pastime with no expectation that the universe owes them a remedy for their grief. You gripe about the train being late, your friends nod solemnly and everyone goes back to their apéro. In America, we launch a full-blown investigation of the train system, sue the government (and its contractors) that allowed for the tardiness and hold a Congressional hearing on the state of national infrastructure.
So to an objective observer, the red card shouldn't have happened, and VAR was a travesty. To Americans, our star player shouldn't be unfairly banned from a match we couldn't afford to lose for a card he so obviously didn't deserve.
Who cares that FIFA used a little-used reversal to fix it. Who cares that other people are mad about it. We. Were. Wronged. It was unjust. It must be corrected. We would accept nothing less.
Europeans waxing poetic about the sanctity of the game are, of course, talking about a governing body whose last tournament host was decided via confirmed cash bribes — one that imposed dress codes on women, shrugged off widespread allegations of modern slavery and reconfigured the entire tournament calendar to suit the host country. Which is exactly the point. If you've made peace with all of that, at least enough to watch the tournament four years later, a probationary suspension isn't actually a scandal.
Maybe that's the real divide. Over millennia, Europeans have made peace with being the bug. Americans have never once considered it, and apparently, we're not about to start now.
@AndyHermanNFL Harsh red, but if you watch soccer more often than once every four years, you’d know this is where the line has been drawn recently. To relish the fact that Trump was able to strongarm Infantino into lifting the suspension, which is truly unprecedented, shows zero love 4 the game
@mboudry “Natuurlijk is er vrije meningsuiting, maar toch niet voor een decaan die een wettelijk sluitend argument geeft waarom oproepen tot genocide niet altijd vervolgbaar is.”
@FMuynck@Sietoebie Staat niet in de baan van de bal: “preventing an opponent from playing or being able to play the ball by clearly obstructing the opponent’s line of vision or” en maakte ook geen beweging naar de bal. Geen positie buitenspel dus.
@emilynussbaum Henk Hofstede, singer of Dutch band the Nits describes a pelgrimage he made to Greece to visit Leonard Cohen’s home in The Night Owl: “Here we stand with our backs against the wall of the house where the man once wrote Suzanne.”
https://t.co/uwj5MEyBgG
It’s time for once and for all acknowledge that fixers are essential workers for western media outlets. Covering conflicts wouldn’t be possible without them. The precarious work conditions and no bylines for them should end ASAP