@PresbyInn The Rosary is way more effective when you sufficiently meditate on the mysteries and you do that best with the Scripture. Try it today and see the result today.
https://t.co/XvUJSpYKWU
@needGod_net Ryan says to believers, “Christ died for you, therefore you can live in whatever sin and still inherit heaven.
St. Paul says to believers, “I warn you, as I did before, that those who live like this [in sins of the flesh] will not inherit the kingdom of God.” (Gal 5:21)
@needGod_net True. And if you get cut off from Christ for bearing no fruit as He warned in John 15, your condemnation is sure.
“He [the Father] cuts off every branch in me that bears no fruit” (John 15:2)
@needGod_net True that Grace is not God lowering His standard. It is God conforming us into the image of Christ that we might *become* the righteousness of God. Grace enables and perfects God’s standard *in* us who could not. This is why it is necessary to be restored if we fall from Grace.
1. What Hebrew canon? According to which Jewish sect? And when was that canon definitively established?
2. Was Esther, Judges, or Chronicles written by a prophet? No. So by your arbitrary standard, are those books uninspired too?
3. Did Christ explicitly identify Song of Solomon, Ecclesiastes, or several other Old Testament books as Scripture? No. So are we going to discard those too?
Notice how Protestantism functions here. You appeal to your own private judgment as the highest authority to determine what is and isn’t Scripture, what is and isn’t essential, and what is and isn’t apostolic.
No accountability. No binding authority. Just an appeal to one’s arbitrary personal preference.
If Protestants like this were actually honest, they would say, “I don’t like Maccabees, so let me invent some arbitrary criteria to justify removing it from the Bible.”
@needGod_net Ryan vs St. Paul:
Ryan: Your sins could never cut you off from the kingdom of God.
St. Paul: “I warn you, as I did before, that those who live like this [in sin of the flesh] will not inherit the kingdom of God.” (Gal. 5:21)
Ryan has opinions. St. Paul is an Apostle of Christ.
Trent Horn no longer works for Catholic Answers.
Additionally he has had an incredibly difficult year in his personal life.
His mom passed away and his wife had cancer.
If you can, please consider supporting him here 👇
eu amo o catolicismo e sou grata demais a Nossa Senhora.
teve uma noite que eu tava n merda, afundada na depressão, crise do tag o tempo inteiro, não conseguia dormir, aí abri o tiktok e tinha uma live de um padre rezando ave maria. e eu dormi ali com aquela live +
This is bad theology. We can actually love God and neighbor through the grace of God in our hearts. And as long as you don’t reject this grace through mortal sins, Christ will keep working in you through it to perfect your love.
“And I am sure of this, that he who began a good work in you will bring it to completion at the day of Jesus Christ.” (Phil 1:6)
“For God gave us a spirit not of fear but of power and love and self-control.” (2 Tim 1:7)
Protestants are not winning arguments against Catholics in 2026. With modern tools and resources, it's being made clear that Protestantism is not rooted in facts or reason but in the disordered will of individuals who choose what they want to believe and then pretend to be convinced that it is so.
I know Protestants will deny this (they have to) but they just have no facts to support their claims. Comments below will just be individual opinions. Their Bible arguments are shallow and easily refuted. They ignore their constant losses in discussion and the endless divisions among their own groups. Their "pastors" are living easy while they try to defend the ideas they've been taught by these con-men -- ideas that are ruining their lives. It's just a ridiculous system to try and defend.
The Catholic Church is very strong in the 21st century. Seeing the quality of young priests being ordained, it looks like it will be getting stronger over the next generation.
“yes, we are free to accept or reject”
It sounds like you are now affirming the exact point you previously called false. No one denies that God chooses us first and draws us to Christ, yet as you just admitted, we remain genuinely free to accept or reject Him. That drawing is a loving invitation, not forced.
The regeneration of the heart happens by Grace and that Grace comes through faith and is given in our baptism into Christ.
I hope you can see the problem your own answer creates for your position. How can someone fall from grace if they were never in grace to begin with? How can someone get cut off from Christ without already being in Christ? It makes zero sense and any honest person can see this.
You just claimed that I would fall from grace if I get baptized to be saved (even though Christ says so in Mark 16:16, Peter in Acts 2:38). But this proves that you have no issue with the idea that people can lose Grace due to something they do. Your issue is when that action is a sin of the flesh, even though the Apostle Paul EXPLICITLY warned against them under the penalty of losing heaven.
But I will not force you to accept God’s warnings and will only pray you do. Just remember that the first fall was the devil deceiving Eve to ignore God’s warning. It is still that same ancient serpent that is prowling around today, looking for who to devour:
“Be alert and of sober mind. Your enemy the devil prowls around like a roaring lion looking for someone to devour.” (1 Peter 5:8)
What is particularly false about my first words? St. Paul himself warned the Galatians that they would fall from Grace and be cut off from Christ (i.e rejecting Christ) if they try to be justified by the law. Do you know better than St. Paul?
I ask again, would the Galatians have truly fallen from grace if they had ignored Paul’s warning and tried to be justified by the law, or was Paul bluffing?
You are justified only by God’s Grace which you are free to either accept or reject. Sexual immorality is a rejection of Grace. St. Paul warns against this explicitly.
But it’s good to know that you agree that those living according to the flesh are not of God and will not inherit heaven no matter how much faith they claim to have.
Christ’s sheep will never perish. These are those walking by the Spirit. They will follow Christ’s commands in bearing good fruits and will not gratify the flesh according to St. Paul (i.e never following a strangers voice) because they are walking by the Spirit.
Those who reject the Spirit by choosing the flesh are, in that state, not Christ’s sheep, because the Spirit of Grace is what makes one His sheep. They will perish/not inherit heaven according to St. Paul.
But Grace can always be restored like the prodigal son returned to the Father and was forgiven:
“For this son of mine was dead and is alive again; he was lost and is found” (Luke 15:24)
There are enough verses in Scripture that warn that those in Christ can be cut off from Him (aka lose their salvation). Ignoring them, doesn’t make them disappear.
Question: Would the Galatians have truly fallen from grace if they had ignored Paul’s warning and tried to be justified by the law, or was Paul bluffing? What do you think?
(This is an important question for this conversation and I hope you can give a direct answer. And btw, the Catholic Church gave you the Bible and have been reading it for 2000 years. We are in no need for your personal and novel reinterpretation which you seem to have mistaken to be God’s word itself).
Today we feel threatened by the uncertainty of widespread violence and by the unspeakable suffering that continues to afflict so many of our brothers and sisters. Yet, despite this darkness, God’s gift continues to shine before our eyes: Jesus Christ, the Son of God, alone is the light that can rescue us from sin and undo its disastrous consequences in our personal and communal lives. He reveals who we truly are: sons and daughters of God, invited to share in the joy of His salvation and in the gladness of knowing that we are brothers and sisters. #ApostolicJourney #Peru
One week of praying the rosary daily !!! The inner peace I feel is wonderful,, and the revelations I’m making and spiritual growth in just this week have been exponential n I can’t wait to see what a month of praying my rosary daily will bring me 🥹🤍🤍