@SimonDixonTwitt Possible with mining centralisation. Self custody doesn’t matter when only 5 large mining pools control all block production and say which utxos get included.
@AndreiFeoktist2@mattkratter All current Bitcoin hardware wallets should work. The fork didn’t change the signature algorithm. Just need to open the wallet with Shrike.
@oomahq@BitcoinBombadil Boomers constitute the largest population share, so they vote their privileges in. You would think that political parties capture the electorate, but it’s the other way around. It’s the electorate that captures the parties. One of the flaws of democracy.
Personally I've come to the conclusion that Bitcoin cannot hope to be global money like gold used to be because it's a human construct and there's a handful of people who can set its direction, which by necessity cannot please everyone.
I expect that over the decades a series of elites will try to wrestle control the largest and most valuable network, with a series of forks as reactions every time the elites subvert/degrade the main network further. Not unlike the dynamics of large organized religions.
5/
Meanwhile Number will still Go Up, as pleb money flows are replaced by institutional flows and BIC propaganda convinces public opinion this is the all for the best. But as Bitcoin gets captured by the BIC, it will become just another tool of the fiat apparatus and the FIC.
1/
When Bitcoin started, there was only 1 software package and everyone was a miner, node runner, and hodler. But as mining difficulty increased and w/ the creation of Stratum v1, these roles got separated and now most only hodl, a few run nodes, and even less mine.
4/
So within 10 years we should see Bitcoin adding tail emissions/demurrage (Pools win, BIC concedes), change its consensus algorithm to Proof of Stake (BIC wins) or both (BIC concedes at first but wins in the end). Plebs can complain but will still be ignored and called sybils.
I'm extremely skeptical about Blakecoin, but I'm sympathetic to the effort and I've been thinking about what tangible goals it should achieve in the next 1-2 years for me to stop considering a complete waste of time. Here goes:
1. At least 30 to 50 Ph/s of total hashrate in ascending trajectory
Siacoin seems to be the only relevant blake2b coin and has a bit less than 11 Ph/s now, but almost touched 100 Ph/s in 2018. This goal seems very low compared to sha256d but they cannot be compared apples to apples, with 50 Ph/s it seems like it would start to be difficult to trivially attack and sink Blakecoin like sha256d hashers can attack and sink bcash anytime they want.
2. At least half of total hashrate is in DATUM pools
The fatal flaw of Poolcoin is that Sv1 pool operators can trivially selfish mine, govern consensus rules, demand KYC for tx confirmation and other horrors that IMV will end up happening down the line. The only reason to restart mining from scratch with another PoW algorithm is to try to keep mining decentralized. If Blakecoin miners choose the Sv1 route again for pooled mining it will be all for nothing.
3. Plenty of hashrate rental options
Hashrate rental markets are what makes decision-making power available to node runners anywhere and can offset the inherent centralization forces of ASIC mining. Blakecoiners need to understand that the burden of securing the system lies on them.
---
If these 3 conditions eventually come true Blakecoin will have at least some legs to stand on and resist while being unaffected by the fatal flaw of Poolcoin.
The question of how to capture Poolcoin's network effects would still be an open problem, but as Poolcoin's centralization trend continues maybe Blakecoin only needs to resist and the problem resolves itself eventually, idk.
@oomahq@mattkratter@awbitcoin I don’t think people understand that the only difference between bitcoin and other crypto was decentralisation. If that’s gone, than bitcoin is just a worst version of ethereum that burns a lot of energy for nothing and doesn’t even allow smart contracts (yet)
@oomahq@NathanS31397389 p2p networks don’t work if the majority of users free ride. And yes, if you don’t run a node and don’t mine with your own block templates, you are just free riding. Satoshi knew all this but unfortunately left us too soon
@LukeDashjr@flaming_hodl I’m just trying to understand if it’s possible to implement replay protection at the chain level and how it would be done (honest technical curiosity)
@GrassFedBitcoin Seems pretty obvious that tail emission is what they offered in exchange for miners to ignore bip110. But don’t worry, eventually they’ll screw even the miners by moving to proof of stake. I’ll give it 10 years.