New this week: free 1-24 podcasts covering League Two, League One and the Championship. I'll be doing about three minutes on every club.
Why now, and not August?
90 days of real competitive football, which means 90 days of every manager revealing how he thinks about his team and others in the division through his post-match interviews.
The placings will be determined by a Monte Carlo simulator (or a 'supercomputer' if your a local journo!) but this won't just be a team strength ranking.
We'll also be discussing the situations that bring out a team’s best or worst version.
Subscribe so each episode lands in your inbox: https://t.co/gXXuWBGtVd
What's being described here is the epitome of a blind spot.
Wanting to replace McNulty with someone else like McNulty is understandable, and a fair starting point. But it should be a preference, no more.
You don't see it all the way through to the extreme of appointing a guy with only one season under his belt two divisions down.
What it actually implies is that McNulty wasn't all that special, and anyone else with similar beliefs could do the job just as well.
@binaryfootball It’s been crap but not quite so sure it was a “bizarre appointment” at the time.
He was brought in on the understanding that his playing style was a continuation of the one we already had. Seems like he did a decent job at at Shields and young enough to have that hunger
@garybrierley@jacko_dale The word dinosaur should be made extinct from the football lexicon at this point. More wrong decisions have been made by clubs disregarding managerial experience in the past five years than right ones.
Bizarre appointment in the first place.
A 40-year-old left back who never played in the EFL and had only one season in management at Level 6, losing the one game that the whole season had built up to.
So Rochdale return to the EFL with a squad that has to step up a level with a manager having to step up two levels, and neither has any prior experience of working with each other.
Are we really at the point of devaluing precedent, prior experience and track record so much?
It was clear quite early that Watson was battling with imposter syndrome. Because, to make matters worse, it turns out he isn't really great with chaos and dealing with so much new and different all at once.
Be interesting to see if he ends up back at South Shields now — but this time as assistant to Mike Williamson, who he served as a right-hand man during failed tenures at MK Dons and Carlisle.
In which case, seven years would be a long time for two men to get from Gateshead to South Shields.
Rochdale AFC can confirm that it has parted company with Head Coach Ian Watson.
We would like to thank Ian for his hard work and commitment during his time at the Crown Oil Arena and wish him every success in the future.
The process to appoint a successor is already underway, and the Club will give a further update in due course.
#rafc
@MDarty_ I’ve had this before. Believe it not, not a single word of that was written with AI. Just prefer the em dash that I picked up from AI presentation style.
Tom Cleverley sounds a bit clueless here. A man bereft of answers.
He’s just witnessed his Plymouth side slip to an abject home defeat against struggling Peterborough. The in-house club reporter chucks out the word ‘spiralling’ and Cleverley visibly struggles to swallow it.
Then what follows is a series of stock phrases: hard work, training, analysis, fighting, tackling, basics.
He clearly hasn’t processed what’s just happened because he presumably didn’t see it coming and doesn’t really know where to start.
But it’s worth remembering: managers are not meant to have all the answers all the time.
In fact, you could argue this interview is reassuring for the fact that Cleverley isn’t trying to fanny it with a well-crafted response.
It’s raw. He looks dishevelled. But this might just be the place he needs to get to before the best answers start to reveal themselves.
The next 48 hours are going be crucial. With no game midweek, Cleverley has time to watch this game back, reflect on recent events and take stock until he achieves coherence.
It’s likely that Argyle’s performance has spooked him because it wasn’t contained to one single obvious problem that needs fixing. It was a collection of so many.
Cleverley is what I’d define as a project manager. Not someone wedded to a single playing identity but a coach who moulds his current game model to the tools at his disposal.
It also requires a fair amount of course correction, which means waiting for evidence of what’s wrong before you can truly understand what’s right.
There was a great example of his leadership style only recently. Argyle conceded an early goal in four successive matches in October. Four moments that gave them a mountain to climb.
How they started games became the project. Not just tactically. He looked into the warm up and various other pre-match routines. Left no stone unturned in pursuit of a stronger foothold.
However, in order for him to feel in control, the single biggest problem has to be obvious.
Let’s not forget, this time last year Argyle were second from bottom and Cleverley appeared to be a dead man walking. A humbling defeat in the Devon derby left him on the brink.
It was unthinkable that he would lose six of the next eight matches and still survive in the role. But the club stuck by him, arguably one of the best and most under-rated executive decisions made by any club in the past 12 months.
When Cleverley eventually figured things out and the puzzle pieces fell into place, Plymouth emerged as a different animal and went better than two points per game over the final 28 matches.
Repeating those standards won’t be easy — different squad, different set of problems — but Argyle are currently seventh and building on a much stronger base, even though it probably doesn’t feel like it right now.
I suspect their season might be about to get started on the back of whatever torture Cleverley is going through here.
How long have George and Ali been doing this now? Over a decade?
How many podcasts a year? How many editorial decisions per podcast?
That’s a lot of reps in the arena, Robbie.
If they do a best player list for 72 clubs, then get to Posh and refuse to bluff a view they can’t fully buy into, I’m taking that as a pretty solid signal that something isn’t quite right.
Fair play if you’ve made something out of it to get a result today, so long as this isn't a one-off and you know where the next result is coming from...
'It's wrong and we need to keep proving people wrong'
Robbie Savage had an answer for @NTT20Pod after they couldn't find a Posh Player of the Season so far earlier this week #pufc@GeorgeElek@AliMaxwell_
"I think McCann has more belief in the players than the players believe in themselves."
A fascinating few minutes on Doncaster Rovers and Grant McCann here, via football consultant and profiler Mike Holden (starts at the 20:19 mark) #drfc
Two podcasts to get stuck into before weekend.
My 90-day 1-24s with around three minutes on every club...
League One: https://t.co/57IPAPNoyX
League Two: https://t.co/UghKAdKQvE
The Championship follows early next week.
@d_robinson71 I think you’ve struck upon a real issue — people’s current perception of typology systems from prior experience.
Your last comment is no longer the challenge, it has already been done. It just doesn’t exist inside football yet.
Interesting thread.
And this is why new ideas and structure around emotional intelligence has to be the next frontier in football.
Success leaves clues and people will always pick up on the patterns eventually. An edge shared is no longer an edge. It simply dissolves into a necessary skill that everyone now requires to survive.
From what I can gather, Bloom and Benham were doing early xG virtually unchallenged through the 2000s. That’s how they made the money to buy Brighton and Brentford.
Then, thanks to social media, others figured it out in the early 2010s. By which stage, Bloom and Benham had bought their boyhood clubs and had branched out to making money inside the game.
Value and certainty in trading on Asian handicaps had turned to value and certainty in player trading. They’ve now had this world to themselves for about a decade now too.
So what’s left?
Develop the players you have.
Not just in the technical sense, which is obviously being done very well by many now, but by understanding how minds are wired and finding an edge in speaking directly to the human needs of untapped potential.
I hear a lot about emotional intelligence in football but I don’t hear too many people able to give a coherent answer of what it actually is.
I went to a conference recently. One technical presentation after another, plenty of excellent ideas around the application of data and logic.
Then the sporting directors and chief execs took to the stage and the benefit of their experience was unanimous: football is about human beings and emotional intelligence.
Not one presentation attempted to dig into the subject. A few anecdotes here and there but no frameworks or definitions.
Inside football, psychology remains a generic pile of do’s and don’ts. One size fits all. Mostly feminine talk about safe spaces and player support. Naturally. 80% of psychologists are women after all.
It’s mostly about player welfare, framed as the obligation that clubs have to the players they pay vast sums to.
Only when clubs see that there’s a competitive edge to be gained from truly understanding the assets in their building will the conversation change and develop into something more substantial.
Most clubs are so stretched right now, posting record losses through paying the going rate for players that promise nothing more than survival in the same league.
And yet there’s so much money being left on the table by not understanding how those players differ from each other in the way they see the game and their place in it.
A squad of 18 players with 18 unique personality types, yet so many commonalities to be found among them on one side of a personality coin or the other.
You can literally split a dressing room into nine different versions of blue bibs versus white bibs. And facilitate the type of banter that isn’t about appearance or birthplace.
In such a competitive environment, it’s powerful intelligence to have.
Brighton, Union SG, Lens, Hearts, Castellón…
Clubs working with Jamestown Analytics keep signing players who already stood out in our model.
So we asked: can we build a “Jamestown index” from our own data?
Here’s what we found 🧵
Starting to wonder if this could be Steve Evans' last proper job in football management, and if we're now witnessing the final stretch of it.
He's been a pantomime villain in the dugout for as long as I can remember and, credit where it's due, there's not many old-school managers who have managed to stay as relevant in the modern game as he has.
But he appears to be a fading force at this point. I'm not convinced we're going to see him recover his edge now.
He's never been a copy-paste manager in terms of the football he plays. From one job to the next, he has always adapted.
Evans knows whatever the current day trend is, and then basically does some version of the opposite, effectively landing on a system that the rest of the division don't want to play against.
It's a shrewd outlook. You've got to respect it. But he never seems to have found this edge at Bristol Rovers.
Opposition managers new to Evans are being kind in post-match interviews when saying how hard they were to prepare for, because they've played so many different systems. They don't realise it's back-handed criticism.
A Steve Evans team is supposed to be a team where you know exactly what you're going to get and it makes no difference because you're 50/50, at best, in being able to deal with it.
It's a shame because, in many ways, Steve Evans with a club like Bristol Rovers in League Two should have been the perfect swansong.
Get them up, make them competitive in League One again. Then bow out with your head held high.
But it's starting to look like this might have been one job too many for a guy who consulted a cardiologist a few years ago and lost over six stone to live the dream of spending another 20 years with his grandkids.
When you place Rovers' current plight in that context, you start to wonder whether the next few years wouldn't be better spent doing bits of media work and tending to those scrapbooks.
As someone who has been an avid Evans observer for probably 20 years, the grandkids replacing Sir Alex Ferguson as the interaction he wants you to know about is a fairly new development.
He's done the groundwork. Now it might be time for Evans to make a decision about what's really important. It's not like anyone's going to forget him.
🎙️ Steve Evans after our 2-0 defeat to Chesterfield:
“My message has always been the same - if I’m not wanted, I’ll leave. I’m not the others that hang in for paydays. Let’s not mince my words.
I sat on the bench for ten seconds to have a conversation with Paul Raynor, some of the shouts when I’ve come out - “He’s come out from hiding”. I answered them - “I don’t hide”. I’m out of the trenches, I don’t hide. I’m not like the others who hide behind the ownership. I don’t do that.
I’m not doing my job, neither is Paul, Byron or Tommo - we are not doing our jobs, but we are being let down by inconsistent players. Poor players in my opinion.”
#UTG ⛽️ | #BristolRovers 🔵⚪️