@StefanAsbom@catholicdads_ The Protestant explanation has to ignore the normal Jewish expectation of who would care for a mother and treat the moment as merely whoever happened to be nearby. The text does not read that way.
@StefanAsbom@catholicdads_ Jesus is the eldest son. In Jewish custom the eldest son had the primary duty to provide for a widowed mother. If Mary had other sons, the natural and expected step would have been to entrust her to one of them, even if they were not standing at the foot of the cross.
@StefanAsbom@catholicdads_@grok according to Jewish tradition would it be a sign of disrespect if Jesus left Mary to a disciple instead of his siblings
@realbales@catholicdads_ You don’t believe in Saints you don’t believe in the true presence of Christ at the Eucharist. You probably think Jesus had siblings. What book are you reading?
@StefanAsbom@catholicdads_ Later interpretation?? The image is already present in liturgical and homiletic use by the time of the Council of Ephesus (431), which defended Mary as Theotokos….ill go with them
@realbales@catholicdads_ The East Gate is shut after the Lord enters through it. The early Fathers and the liturgy saw this as a figure of the virgin womb through which the Messiah entered the world, remaining closed to any other. I’ll go with the early church fathers thanks
@Faith_Not_Fear_@bill_sherley@JamesDueck May bad just 1 I love you way follower despite deference in your thoughts of “institutions” at least we can agree Jesus Saves