⚠️ Warning: Extremely long post about the CFP — but it needs to be said.
Since the beginning of the College Football Playoff, there has been only ONE team that was in position to make the playoff, lost a conference championship game, had idle teams behind them, and did not drop in the rankings the following week:
2025 Alabama.
There have been only TWO teams total who were in CFP position, lost a conference championship game, and did not fall at all:
• 2022 TCU
• 2025 Alabama
Let’s talk about why those situations are not the same — and why the Alabama one is a problem.
⸻
2022 TCU
TCU was ranked #3 and lost the Big 12 Championship by 3 points in overtime.
The team directly behind them at #4 USC got blown out by 23 in their conference championship game.
If the committee dropped TCU to #4 and moved idle #5 Ohio State to #3, Michigan would have played Ohio State twice in three games, and OSU would have faced Michigan back-to-back.
That was a clear structural reason not to reshuffle the rankings.
⸻
Now compare that to 2025
This is where it gets uncomfortable.
• Both teams around Alabama were idle — yet Alabama doesn’t drop to #10
• Both teams around BYU were idle — BYU drops to #12
• Both teams around UVA were idle — UVA drops to #19
So let’s be honest:
Is dropping Alabama to #10 really “punishment” when they���re in either way?
Or are we protecting the ACC’s last at-large team by making sure no one sits between Miami and Notre Dame?
Because if Alabama drops to 10, suddenly there’s a problem the committee doesn’t want to solve.
And let’s be clear — that’s the ACC’s fault, not Notre Dame’s.
The ACC Championship tiebreaker was asinine. If Miami had been in the ACCCG and lost, does anyone actually believe they wouldn’t have dropped?
⸻
History is very clear
Conference championship losers have absolutely been passed by idle teams and missed the playoff:
• 2022 USC
• 2017 Penn State
• 2015 Iowa
• 2017 Auburn — beat Georgia three weeks earlier, then lost the SECCG and got jumped
So the argument that “Alabama beat Georgia earlier” is not a shield.
We’ve seen that exact scenario before — and it didn’t matter then.
⸻
Ranking position shouldn’t matter
Whether you’re ranked 1 or 22, the criteria should be applied the same way.
4-team playoff
12-team playoff
16-team playoff
The rules don’t change.
Yes, fringe teams will get squeezed sometimes — that’s the trade-off.
Playing a conference championship game gives you control:
• Win and you’re in
• Lose and you hope the cards fall your way
That’s how the system has always worked.
So stop with the “we can’t punish conference championship losers” narrative.
It’s simply false — and honestly, idiotic.
⸻
It gets worse when you look at the week before
Go back one week before the conference championship games.
Alabama got moved UP after a “great” 27–20 win over 5–7 Auburn — a team that was:
• Winless at home vs SEC teams
• Playing under an interim head coach
Why did Alabama move up?
Because leaving them at #10 would have caused issues if:
• BYU won
• Alabama lost the CCG
Suddenly the committee might have had to bump Alabama out.
So they preemptively solved the problem.
⸻
And the résumé argument doesn’t hold up
“Alabama beat four ranked teams in a row and has the best win of the year.”
No — they didn’t.
• Georgia dog-walked them last week, proving teams change
• Only two of those wins are still ranked
• Vanderbilt, Tennessee, and Missouri have ZERO wins over ranked teams
• Tennessee and Missouri have a combined ZERO wins over FBS teams with winning records
Those rankings were inflated by preseason bias.
⸻
So what’s actually going on?
Why can’t we question this?
There has been no rule change saying conference championship losers can’t drop.
This is not a Notre Dame problem.
This is a CFP problem.
And the longer we pretend otherwise, the worse the credibility gap gets.
TIME TO GET HYPE IRISH NATION!!!! ☘️☘️☘️
Top 25 matchup against Pitt. It's time to silence whiny Narduzzi and the rest of Pitt nation
TURN YOUR VOLUME UP AND GO IRISH!! ☘️💪���
**Flash Warning! Bright flashes throughout**
#GoIrish #H2P #GameDay
Brandon Graham, who played 15 seasons in Philadelphia and became the longest-tenured Eagle in franchise history, announced his retirement from the NFL. Graham returned from a torn triceps muscle to play in the Super Bowl and help the Eagles win their second Super Bowl in what turned out to be the final game of his NFL career.
Canada fans booed our National Anthem
So Team USA started 3 fights in the first 9 seconds of the game and beat Canada 3-1 on their home turf
Now America is in the Championship game
Free Bird baby🦅