Bihar is mocked by Indians for the same reason Indians are mocked by the world.
No, it’s not racism. It’s refusal to be civil.
No, frantically googling clips of Gurgaon hooligans and Mumbai visarjans don’t help Bihar’s case, just as googling clips of Paris rioters and Chinese cattle trains don’t help India’s.
When there’s a bad stereorype, either ignore it or fix yourself. You can’t refuse to fix and also wail about the stereotype. Won’t happen.
Why is it not racism? Because in the West, Asians do not get even half as much hate as Indians. In India, Gujaratis, Bengalis, etc. do not get even a fraction of the contempt Bihar gets.
And believe me, it’s not envy. It’s the height of delusion that many genuinely feel the world envies India or India envies Bihar.
China is practically everything American communists condemn about America, amplified tenfold.
Billionaires, wealth inequality, corporate favoritism, exploited workers, political corruption, concentrated power, and virtually nonexistent political freedom.
And the greatest improvements in Chinese prosperity came when the Communist Party abandoned major elements of communist economic planning in favor of markets, private enterprise, and trade.
So naturally, American communists point to China as proof that communism works.
Apparently, capitalism becomes communism when the billionaires answer to a Communist Party.
Are you emotionally prepared for the OG Ramayana? Here’s one of many, many tests:
Ayodhya Kanda, sarga 31, verses 7 thru 11:
sumantra ānaya me dārān ye kecit iha māmakāḥ,
dāraiḥ parivṛtaḥ sarvaiḥ draṣṭum iccāmi rāghavam.
so antaḥ puram atītya eva striyaḥ tā vākyam abravīt,
āryo hvayati vo rājā gamyatām tatra māciram.
evam uktāḥ striyaḥ sarvāḥ sumantreṇa nṛpa ājñayā,
pracakramus tat bhavanam bhartur ājñāya śāsanam.
ardha sapta śatāḥ tāḥ tu pramadāḥ tāmra locanāḥ,
kausalyām parivārya atha śanaiḥ jagmur dhṛta vratāḥ.
āgateṣu ca dāreṣu samavekṣya mahī patiḥ,
uvāca rājā tam sūtam sumantra ānaya me sutam.
Translation:
“Oh, Sumantra! being all my wives, who are here. Surrounded by all of them, I want to see the virtuous Rama.”
Sumantra, after entering the gynaecium, spoke these words to those women as follows: “Oh, the venerable ladies! The king is calling you. Go there without delay.”
All those women, asked thus by Sumantra as per the king’s orders, went to his palace, after knowing the instructions of their husband.
Encircling Kausalya, three hundred fifty women, steadfast in their vow, with their eyes reddened, went there slowly.
After arrival of his wives, king Dasaratha spoke to that charioteer as follows, “Oh, Sumantra! Bring my son here.”
This is Critical Edition. Bad translation? Prefer Gitapress? Sure, look for sarga 34, verses 10 thru 14.
What do you think? Prepared for Dasharatha’s 350 wives.
I know what you’re thinking. What’s the proof those 350 women are wives and not simply attendants to 3 wives? Here’s the proof:
Dasharatha categorically asks Sumantra to fetch his dārān. The word is accusative plural for dāra. And dāra does not mean attendant or maid. It means wife.
Unambiguously.
Ask Monier-Williams. Too colonial? Fine, ask Apte. The only other meanings it carries are hole, rent, and gap, none of which fits the context at hand.
Want more?
In 31.9 (34.12 in Gitapress), the term used for Dasharatha in reference to the women is bhartur, genitive singular for bhartṛ. Now bhartṛ can mean both husband and master, granted. But ask yourself, why would maids be summoned when Dasharatha has categorically called for his wives for a private consultation (regarding Rama’s coronation)?
In fact, in the very next verse, the word used for the women in the Gitapress translation is pativratā, devoted to their husband.
Why would their devotion to their own individual husbands matter in this context unless that husband were...Dasharatha himself?
This is why mythology is meant to be taken as metaphor and allegory, not literal blow-by-blow historiography.
You evolved over millions of years to come in possession of more intelligence and discernment than any other species to have ever existed. What good is that intellect if you cannot apply most basic logic simply out of pride?
God blessed you with literacy and wisdom.
Use it.
I don’t believe in God because I’m rational.
But I wish people worshipped “nature” because that’d be so rational. Nature would absolutely punish you if you didn’t “worship” it and reward you if you did. 🤦🏽♂️
I've been pointing out since the early 2010s that Thomas Piketty, Emmanuel Saez, and Gabriel Zucman have a bad habit of biasing their data construction to fit their politics.
Whenever they make a suspect call in how to handle stats, it ends up showing that inequality is on the rise. They almost never go in the other direction. The errors are non-random and almost invariably reinforce their political claims about rising income and wealth concentration since 1980.
Piketty did this throughout his book Capital in the 21st Century.
Piketty and Saez did this throughout their famous 2003 paper on inequality in the US.
Piketty, Saez, and Zucman Saez and Zucman did this in their Distributional National Accounts paper that Auten and Splinter dissected.
Saez and Zucman did this in their 2019 book on tax incidence and inequality.
Saez and Zucman did this in their flurry of "studies" and white papers to support Elizabeth Warren's wealth tax proposal, California Prop 40, a new wealth tax in France, and dozens of other similar examples.
A new AI report (linked below) audited 138 papers by Saez and Zucman. It found thousands of errors, 194 of which were serious. A whopping 97% of the serious errors went in the same direction: they showed inequality rising faster or made it higher.
But there's a bigger scandal at play here. Despite these clear biases, Piketty, Saez, and Zucman have enjoyed a stream of praise and prestige within the economics profession. They get expedited and friendly reviews in top econ journals even though a more serious peer review should have caught many of these errors (the Quarterly Journal of Economics is a recurring offender in this regard). Journals regularly give them a pass after the errors in their old work come to light - they're never expected to correct any of it, and just keep on using it as if nothing changed. Their non-peer reviewed data claims are also treated as gospel by major media outlets such as the New York Times and the Washington Post. And they get showered with prizes - Saez and Zucman are both Clark Medal winners from the AEA, and Zucman got his prize in 2023 after evidence of major data shenanigans in his work came to light in 2019.
Until now, those of us who have been trying to correct the record have had to wade through the PSZ trio's cluttered, disorganized, and often non-transparent replication packages (almost all of which are convoluted piles of Excel spreadsheets) to find the problems. I did a line-by-line replication of Piketty and Saez's entire 2003 US income inequality series to use one example, and found it was riddled with errors - almost every single one of which biased their results in favor of their political story.
We had the means to catch this stuff as it was happening, but the economics profession failed to do its job. And it failed precisely because its elite ranks wanted to believe the Piketty-Saez-Zucman story for political reasons.
So, now that the Islamo-liberal alliance has defended the characterisation of the Constitution as fascist, will they still wave it as a weapon, and chant the Preamble as an incantation?
When someone says Hindu Rashtra - everything becomes fascism & inviolable - basic structure.
When Sharjeel says sharia law, Islamic state, then “constitution is not some infallible document” - basic structure gaya bhaand me.
Same charlatans, same lies,
These shameless mfs resort to virtue signalling when they lose an argument. This is an open call to muzzle press freedom, and worse, put a target on the publisher’s head when their campaign to figure out who the columnist behind a pseudonym is.
Having read Ibn Khaldun for years, I find the obsession with the author’s real identity to be a glaring indictment of our community’s failure to protect and understand its dissent voices.
There are countless profound reasons why a writer chooses a pen name. It can be a necessary shield against the brutal consequences faced by independent voices. It can be a deliberate choice to strip away personal ego, forcing us to focus entirely on the weight of the ideas rather than the background of the messenger. Or, it can be a proud alignment with a long, historic tradition of dissident literature.
Yet, instead of engaging with the actual arguments or addressing Sharjeel’s stand, people are wasting energy policing a pseudonym.
I stand firmly with the author. More power to Ibn Bharati. By challenging us to break free from the paralyzing cycle of victimhood and forge our own independent path, you are doing far more for the future of this community than any self-proclaimed intellectual ever has.
قناة DW الألمانية أنتجت وثائقي عن المهاجرين في ضواحي باريس، وركزت فيه على مجموعتين عايشين في نفس المنطقة.
من جهة، فيه حوالي ٧٠ ألف فرنسي من أصول صينية. في أوبرفيلييه، بضواحي باريس الشمالية، بنوا أكبر مركز لبيع الملابس بالجملة في أوروبا. حياتهم بسيطة يقومون بدري ويشتغلون لين وقت متأخر، يديرون ورش صغيرة، ويمسكون محلاتهم، ويوصلون البضايع. يرجعون يحطون اللي يكسبونه في تج��رتهم، وإذا ضاقت عليهم، يدبرون أمورهم ويحاولون يتجاوزونها بنفسهم. غالبا هادين وبعيدين عن الأضواء، ونادر يطلبون إعانات خاصة من الحكومة، وما ينزلون الشوارع عشان يثيرون الفوضى. ومع مرور السنين، زاد عدد العوايل اللي اشترت بيوت وكبرت تجارتها.
وعلى الجهة الثانية، جاليات المهاجرين من شمال أفريقيا، ساكنين في نفس الحي. اندماجهم الاقتصادي في المنطقة ما تقدم كثير. لكن الوثائقي رصد تغير خفي في طريقة التفكير و هي نظرة بدأت تنتشر بهدوء تعتبر اللي يعتمد على نفسه نوع من التهديد.
بحسب اللي رصده الفيلم، بعض اللي واجهوا صعوبة في الاندماج يميلون يشوفون أنفسهم ضحايا، ويحسون إن المجتمع مدين لهم بالكثير. بس يوم يلتفتون ويشوفو�� الصينيين اللي جنبهم، تتغير نظرتهم. وبدل ما يتعلمون منهم التجارة، يتعاملون معهم كمن��فسين.
طيب، من وين جاي هالعداء؟ أوضح نقطة صدام هي إن الصينيين كل ما نجحوا أكثر، صار التمسك برواية المظلومية أصعب. الكل هنا جاي من برا، ويواجه نفس صعوبات الغربة. وحتى الصينيين يوم جوا، كثير منهم ما كانوا يتكلمون فرنسي، ولا عندهم علاقات في البلد. فإذا فيه شخص يقدر يكد ١٢ ساعة وزيادة في اليوم، ويرتب حياته شوي شوي، يصير صعب تردد عبارة (إحنا متعثرين لأن الدنيا ظالمة) واحد يصدقك
اللي يبني نفسه بجهده وبدون ضجة، غالبا يضايق اللي تعود يلوم الظروف والعالم ويعيش في عقليه الضحيه.
وفيه اختلاف ثاني عميق في فهم الثروة. كثير من اللي يطالبون بالإعانات يشوفون الثروة كأنها كيكة حجمها ثابت، تقاسموها الناس وخلاص. ما يشوفون كيف قامت محلات الجملة هذي، وكيف أصحابها شالو�� البضايع بأيديهم، كرتون ورا كرتون. كل اللي يشوفونه إن ربح المحلات الصينية جاي على حسابهم.
وزد على هذا إن الصينيين متعودين على الصبر وتفويت المشاكل. إذا صار خلاف، عادي يختارون يعدون الموضوع عشان يحافظون على الهدوء. ومع هالخلل في التفكير، تتحول المسألة بسرعة إلى مشاكل أمنية. سطو، وترصد، واعتداءات في الشوارع، تتكرر ضد هالناس اللي كل اللي يبونه يعيشون بهدوء ويسترزقون.
Liberté, égalité, illégibilité
France is in the news for the riot reasons. Their hypocrisy needs to be called out. Maybe that's what's leading to frequent fracas on the Parisian streets. French are bloody hypocrites. They write something and say the same like it's something totally different. Yes, English has those silent letters and we know we can't really be sure about the English but a miss here and a miss there is expected. They colonised us but couldn't silence us. We trust no silent letters. But the French, holy f-word, they just place letters everywhere and tell you some entirely made up shit.
Bordeaux. Eight letters. Two sounds. Bor-doh. The "eaux" alone is four letters doing the job of one, which is the most French thing imaginable. The x stands at the end marking the end of the train of letters. (I'm adding a photo in the end)
The word for bird is oiseau. It has all five vowels, a, e, i, o and u, and pronounces not a single one of them as written. Wa-zo. We say "give it in writing" to avoid disputes here. In France, since the written letters have no value, they create disputes and disputes lead to violence.
French words come padded up with letters at the end for some weird diversity, equity, inclusion reasons. Let's include the x here because the alphabet places it so far behind to oppress the poor thing. Vingt is "van". Doigt is "dwa". Ils parlent means "they speak", but the "ent" doesn't. Thirty per cent of every sentence is dead weight.
How do they count the dead letters? Ninety-nine in French is quatre-vingt-dix-neuf. Four twenties, ten, nine. You don't say a number in France, you solve a maths problem. Mind you, these are the people who gave the world the metric system, all neat tidy tens, and then went home and counted like my dadi tallied the fresh paddy being weighed in boris at the khalihan.
In Devanagari, जैसा लिखा, वैसा बोला. Ka is ka. In Patna, in Pune, on Monday, on Maha Ashtami, in Dipke's bond or on the back of the Delhi Police truck. No letter sits quietly to do a dhappa as if its luka-chhipi. Sau mein 80 beimaan, but our script is the most honest thing in Mera Bharat Mahaan. More honest than our politicians, certainly.
We had a near miss, though. The French ruled Pondicherry until 1954. Another few decades and we'd be spelling it Poudoucheriaux and pronouncing it "Pondy" anyway.
The French gave the world liberté, égalité, fraternité. (I had to type this in Google and copy it back for those damn acute accents over the e.) No equality between what's written and what's said, but the liberty to adjust some letters for socialist reasons into a word they don't need to be in. And absolutely no brotherhood with the rest of us trying to order a croissant without being corrected.
Liberté, égalité, illégibilité.
Vive la fauxnetical farce!